TLDR: Barbells take long warm ups. Pistols need high reps and you have to do those reps slowly to keep balance. Bulgarian Split Squats require kind of long warm ups and because they are unilateral you have to do 2x the sets. Regular bodyweight squats require tons of reps. Am I missing something?
My current routine is a little eclectic, but centered around the six movement patterns in the recommended routine. I workout daily for (maximum) 40 minutes first thing in the morning. I can comfortably fit at least 2 of the other exercises into each session including warm up, mobility, etc, but I have to give squats their one full workout. For the past year, my variation of choice has been bulgarian split squats. I currently do 3x10 (70lbs) [this is plenty as long as I am strict about really keeping the "back leg is just for balance" mentality and not allowing any seesaw motion]. I find it takes quite some time to get neurologically warmed up for that between both the weight and the balance component. I tried rushing through the warmup before. It resulted in injury. I also personally have to do a little bit of nerve flossing to prevent numbness during the movement. I am content with this because I can progress without indefinitely adding reps but I feel as though I might be missing something-though of course there is tremendous value in finding something imperfect and just sticking to it. Upper body work and even RDLs take far less time.
In the past, I focused on pistol squats for a year or two. I found the high rep sets very time consuming. In order to do sets that pushed my muscles and not just my balance, I found I needed to practice the movement (just a little) every day and have sessions where I really pushed myself once a week (though that could be more frequent if I had the time). A set of 30 was a good challenge, but just a single set was taking quite some time-staying balanced required moving slowly and then I had to do the other leg too. Adding weight is possible, but then form decay starts to become more risky.
I have considered buying a squat rack, but much of the information I've looked at online (Jeff Nippard, Renaissance Periodization, Eugene Teo, etc.) seems to say that barbell squats, while great for getting really really strong, require even more time than single leg variations due to warming up. I also have long femurs which gives me pause about this significant space investment. The people listed above seem to love their leg press/hack squat machines, but that requires driving to a gym.
I have tried the K Boges style of super high rep bodyweight squats. While this takes little to no warm up (50-100 of them is one of the first parts of my warmup), the sets themselves take pretty long and I already do a lot of cardio biking to work. I found I could get a pretty good quad pump in 2 minutes by going fast and skipping the top ROM, but progressive loading seems like an issue. If I hold a dumbbell, I'm going to need to move more slowly.
One thing that seems promising is to do quick pump reps of BSS: just the bottom part of the ROM. Use one hand to hold a dumbbell and the other touching a wall for balance. I get to failure pretty fast this way. Anyone else do that?
Mindful Mover does his pistols with arm support and a weight vest. That would be a financial investment for me and I wonder how long I'd feel the need to warm up for that although I know he doesn't take long. Does anyone else do pistols this way? Does it work for you?
So I guess this is me just kind of musing after my split squat session. The spirit of reddit is to start a conversation, right? What do you do?