For context, I wrote another post earlier about the history of my dead bedroom and some of the reasons I’m still in the marriage. You can read it here: https://www.reddit.com/r/DeadBedrooms/s/O3o5UsPCZk
I’ve spent a lot of time reading posts here, especially the ones from people who left dead bedrooms and either found something better or at least found relief from the situation they were in. I understand why “just leave” is such a common answer here. Sometimes leaving absolutely is the right decision.
For me, though, I keep coming back to the same problem: leaving a bad situation in one area does not guarantee that I end up in a better situation overall.
My marriage has a very serious sexual and physical-intimacy problem. I am not minimizing that. It affects me deeply, and I miss being desired, touched, kissed, and having a genuinely sexual relationship with my wife. That loss is real, and staying means accepting the possibility that I may continue living with a major unmet need.
But my marriage is also much more than the bedroom.
My wife is my best friend and someone whose companionship I value enormously. We have built a life together over many years. This also isn’t a situation where I see her as the bad guy or as someone maliciously withholding something from me. Our intimacy problems are complicated, and there are things about desire, sexuality, and her own limitations that I don’t believe she simply chose.
We also have a son who is entering high school. Separating right as he enters adolescence would introduce a major amount of instability into his life, and I am extremely reluctant to do that unless I believe there is a compelling reason.
Divorce would also immediately create practical consequences. We would go from one household to two. We would probably need another vehicle. The same resources that currently support one family structure would suddenly have to support two separate lives. I would also be introducing a tremendous amount of additional stress into two areas of my life that already require a lot of attention.
It would destabilize my wife’s life as well. Whatever our problems are, I love her. I do not regard her as an obstacle standing between me and a better sex life. She is a person I care about deeply who has built her life alongside mine. Upending that has a cost to her, and that cost matters to me.
And then there is the thing I think sometimes gets lost in discussions about leaving: what exactly am I guaranteed to receive in return for all of those costs?
Nothing.
I would not be trading a dead bedroom for a healthy sexual relationship. I would be trading my existing marriage for the possibility that someday I might have a healthier sexual relationship.
Maybe I would. Maybe I would meet someone with whom the physical chemistry was incredible and the rest of the relationship was wonderful too. That is certainly possible.
It is also possible that I would spend years single. Dating might be miserable. I might find someone who gives me everything I am currently missing sexually while introducing an entirely different set of problems that are just as serious, or worse.
That is something I have become increasingly aware of. A hypothetical future partner is incredibly easy to idealize because she has no known faults yet. I can imagine someone affectionate, sexually enthusiastic, physically compatible, emotionally available, financially responsible, loyal, stable, kind, intelligent, and wonderful with my son.
But that person is imaginary.
My actual wife has known flaws because I have spent decades discovering them. Any real future partner would eventually have her own.
So I cannot look at the worst deficiency in my current marriage, imagine a future relationship without that deficiency, and automatically conclude that the second relationship would be better overall. I might simply trade one kind of pain for another.
And none of this means I think my marriage is fine. It isn’t. The lack of physical intimacy hurts like hell sometimes. I love having a best friend, but if I am being completely honest, there is also a part of me that desperately wants a lover. Friendship, however valuable it is, does not completely replace that.
That is probably the hardest part of staying. I can acknowledge everything my wife gives me, appreciate how deeply she loves me, and still grieve something she may simply be unable to give me in the way I need it. Those things are not mutually exclusive.
Staying does not transform that loss into something insignificant or acceptable. It simply means that when I evaluate the entire system rather than one part of it, leaving currently looks like a very high-cost, largely irreversible decision whose hoped-for benefit is uncertain.
I know what staying costs me.
I also know a great deal about what leaving would cost me, my wife, and my son.
What I do not know is whether the thing waiting on the other side would actually be better.
So I’m not saying I will stay under every imaginable circumstance forever. I’m saying that, given the marriage I actually have and the alternatives I can realistically evaluate today, staying still makes more sense to me than leaving.
For now, the possibility of something better is nowhere near enough for me to give up everything that is still valuable about the life I already have.