We have a 1940s Cape Cod (1400 sq ft) with a masonry fireplace, opening is 34"W x 29.5"H, current glass doors with viewable area 30"W x 22"H. Been running a Portland Willamette Ultra Fyre log set for years and honestly the flame is nice to look at and we get a fair amount of radiant heat but we're looking to get less draft and more heat than it can give. Here is what I have looked at so far.
Valor G4, shop owner is from the neighborhood. My friends have an older G3 in an identical house/floorplan and the heat tends to emit out and up and not very far past the room. The G4 looks much better but the log pattern is still a little bulky and the flames while pretty good seem to be concentrated in one spot. Viewable area is smaller, 28" x 18". Max btu is lower but the turn down is the lowest.
Kozy Heat Nordik-34i, 30" x 22" viewing area which is basically the same size as our current glass doors, flame looked the best of anything we saw in person, but the safety screen is coarse and once you notice it you can't unsee it. Still it's a strong option because of the flames, logs and large viewable area. I don't suppose that there is an upgraded see-through screen available?
Mendota FV44i Flame-in, Nice flames, large viewing area, 29"x20", clear screen that I didn't think was even there until I touched it, but we thought the birch logs were bulky. Did not get to see other log sets to compare.
Regency Gi33, mesh screen almost disappears and we liked the low profile surround/built in look, but the while the flames were positioned well around the logs they were pretty stationary and not very dynamic. 29"x18" glass, smaller than Kozy and Mendota more like the Valor.
Lopi/FPX 616 , saw it in person but didn't get a good look at the flame to remember it, need to go back, 28" x 20" viewable sits in between the Valor/Regency and the Kozy/Mendota units. The owner said that the units are shipped assembled and installs are easier.
The fireplace opening is boarded by 8" brick on each side and 7" on top. All of the shops except the valor dealer will custom cut the surround to fit our exact opening instead of being limited by stock sizes that cover a lot of the brick. I like that Valor doesn't need any power to run in an outage but we have battery backup that may be able to maintain the draw from the powered units.
Trying to figure out how much weight to put on the power independence (valor), see through mesh screens, viewing area, and how realistic the flame looks. Is there anything that I should go look at or consider before picking from this list? Thanks!