r/nonmonogamy • u/Diligent_Surprise931 • 1h ago
Threesomes, Foursomes, and Moresomes I (21F) had my first threesome with my boyfriend (21M) and his best friend (20M) who flew in from Canada. It was hotter than I expected and now I don't know what to do.
Okay this is going to be long but Reddit is the only place I can actually talk about this.
I'm 21F, been with my boyfriend almost two years. Sex life has always been great and we've been getting more experimental lately, toys, porn together, all that. For a while he's been dropping the threesome idea. It went from jokes to actual conversations.
The tipping point was a movie we watched with a really hot threesome scene, both guys focused entirely on the girl. I got wet watching it and he noticed because his hand was already between my legs. He asked if we should try it, just once. I was already so turned on I basically said yes right there. My only condition was that it had to be someone I trusted, not a stranger off an app.
We talked about it for two weeks. Then he mentioned his best friend who's been studying in Canada. I'd met him before, tall, decent build, clean cut face. Once my boyfriend planted the seed I couldn't stop thinking about it. Turns out the friend was flying back to India the next month. My boyfriend started prepping him on calls, talking about "this girl" they could hook up with. When he finally told him it was me, apparently there was a silence and then the friend just said "she's hot, I'm down."
Side note, my boyfriend also wanted an FFM. Made me create a Tinder account to DM girls. Absolute failure. Every girl ghosted or thought I was catfishing. So the MMF was the one that happened.
The night itself. He flew in, spent a couple days with family, came over on a Friday. We'd been drinking to loosen up. Dim lights, clean sheets, drinks. It started slow, all three of us on the couch talking, then my boyfriend started kissing me while his friend watched. Then he nodded at his friend and his friend leaned in and kissed me too. That first kiss with someone who wasn't my boyfriend, right in front of him, sent a jolt through me. Guilt and arousal at once, straight to my pussy.
It moved fast after that. Both of them undressed me together, four hands on me, one mouth on my neck and another on my tits. They took turns going down on me. One tongue on my clit while the other guy sucked my nipples, then switching. I came fast because the sensory overload was insane. Two guys focused entirely on making me feel good. That's the part I liked most honestly, being the center of both their attention.
Then came the part I was nervous about. My boyfriend told me to suck his best friend's cock. I hesitated because doing that in front of him felt like crossing a line, even though we'd already agreed to cross every line. But my boyfriend was rock hard watching me stroke his friend, and he said softer, "go on, put it in your mouth." So I did. His friend groaned and my thighs clenched. Then my boyfriend got behind me and started fucking me while I sucked his best friend off. On all fours with a cock in my mouth and a cock in my pussy. Every thrust from behind pushed his friend deeper into my throat. I was drooling, moaning around him, completely gone.
We switched a lot. His friend fucked me while I made out with my boyfriend. My boyfriend fucked me while I sucked his friend. I rode my boyfriend while sucking his friend off standing next to the bed. I told them both no anal and no double penetration and they respected it completely. Always one at a time inside me. That mattered.
The moment that surprised me most was near the end. His friend was close to cumming in my mouth and pulled back saying "I'll pull out before I finish." Polite of him. But my boyfriend, watching from behind me, said "no, let her swallow it. She swallows mine, she can swallow yours." I looked up at my boyfriend and he was dead serious and so turned on. Something about him giving his friend permission to finish in my mouth flipped a switch. I nodded, took his friend back in, and let him cum down my throat. Swallowed all of it. My boyfriend came inside me a couple minutes later.
We collapsed after. Awkward for maybe thirty seconds and then we were laughing and drinking water. His friend slept in the guest room, left the next morning. Hasn't been weird between any of us since.
Here's my dilemma. I liked it. Really liked it. But I don't know if I want to do it again. Part of me is scared my boyfriend will want it more than I do, or get jealous later, or that I'll start comparing our regular sex to threesome sex. And I don't know if this is even a normal thing to do in India or if my circle is just extra conservative. My friends would drop dead if I told them.
Has anyone else here done an MMF with your partner and their close friend? Does it change the friendship? Did you do it again? Was it better or worse the second time? I need actual experiences, not judgment, because I'm already giving myself plenty of that. How common is this in india? I would also love to try and FFM!