I'm trying to decide between a Shimano Tiagra 80W, Penn International 80VISW, or stepping all the way up to a 130-size reel.
The use case is a little unusual.
I'm planning an Atlantic crossing by sailboat and want to troll while underway, mainly to catch fresh fish for dinner: mahi-mahi, wahoo and tuna.
Ideally, when a decent-sized fish takes the lure, I want enough tackle to simply keep sailing and winch it in without slowing the boat down. Basically a modern version of the heavy fixed trolling lines that sailors have used for years.
There is a reason I'm deliberately looking at ridiculously heavy tackle for that job.
Years ago I was trolling this way with an old Penn Senator 114H 6/0 when something very large hit. I never found out what it was. It just kept running until it completely spooled the Senator and disappeared with at least 300 yards of line.
Losing the fish didn't bother me. What bothered me was knowing that a fish was now swimming around with a hook and hundreds of yards of line attached to it, and may have died unnecessarily because my tackle wasn't up to the job.
I don't want that to happen again.
So yes, I realize an 80W…let alone a 130 … is absurd overkill for the mahi, wahoo and normal tuna I'll catch most of the time. That's intentional.
However, if a genuinely big tuna or marlin takes the lure, I'm not expecting to keep sailing at 6–7 knots and simply winch it in. At that point I would slow/stop the sailboat, get the sails under control and actually fight the fish.
What I want is enough capacity and strength that I have time to do that without immediately getting spooled.
I also want this to be a setup I can keep for life. If I eventually go somewhere specifically to target very large bluefin or marlin, I'd like the reel to still be useful rather than having to buy everything again.
I already own a Penn Squall 50VSW, so I have a lighter heavy-trolling option as well.
So my question is:
Which would you choose for this specific application?
Shimano Tiagra 80W: huge capacity, proven heavy-tackle reel, but “only” around 40 lb rated max drag.
Penn International 80VISW … similar 80W size/capacity but substantially more available drag.
130-size Tiagra/Penn : maximum capacity and fighting power, but nearly 5 kg of reel and probably ridiculous for 99% of what will actually bite during the crossing.
And if you choose an 80W: Penn or Shimano, and why?
I'm not looking for the lightest or most sporting setup. I'm looking for the best compromise between catching dinner while sailing, not getting spooled by an unexpected monster, and having a reel capable of serious bluefin/marlin fishing in the future.