r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 4d ago

Meme needing explanation Whyyyy peter?

Post image
41.9k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/awesomefutureperfect 4d ago

You'd have to engineer the payload to withstand ridiculous acceleration. No big deal if the payload is a HILE projectile but if you have living things or moving parts, that can be trickier.

1

u/aggressive-cat 4d ago

that's only for a cannon, for an installation like that we could make it pretty long to keep the acceleration g's down, don't wanna hit max q while still on the ground.

2

u/mxzf 3d ago

Acceleration as you head up is one part of the problem, but deceleration as it leaves the tube and hits the atmosphere is another. The faster you go, the more friction slows you down. Trying to get productively much speed in that situation is tough.

1

u/QIyph 4d ago

Okay so I used AI for this, so take it with a grain of salt, but to accelerate a projectile at a constant 4.5G and have it reach escape velocity, at the end of the barrel, you'd end up with a ~720km cannon.

2

u/dimhue 4d ago edited 4d ago

My quick napkin math gives me about 1400km 1300km, and it would take over 40 minutes to reach that speed.

edit: fixed after I forgot earth's spin lol

2

u/Shinyscalpel 4d ago

Doesn't need to reach escape velocity... Any velocity you reach is less fuel having to be carried and spent in later stages, so more payload. You could compare costs of building such a launcher or just grabbing a plane and take it 20,000m high and also give it a spin. I'm not a rocket scientist (unless Kerbal gives you a degree lol) but I guess nobody is willing to spend that much for a reason.

1

u/aggressive-cat 4d ago

oh lol, i mean like a first stage assist to a rocket, not a full on em launcher.

0

u/TickleMyRide 4d ago

Rail guns are not the same as rockets.

1

u/Kinniska-Peculier 1d ago

“…trickier” 🤣

2

u/awesomefutureperfect 1d ago

There is no problem engineers can't solve with a large enough budget unless it also requires r+d and some scientists.