r/puer • u/taphead739 • 4h ago
Review: 2026 Night Joe decaffeinated shou (white2tea)
7g/90mL – boiling water – 8 infusions
Since I can't drink tea after 5pm if I want to sleep that night, I was happy to see white2tea release four kinds of decaf tea last year in small packages. I tried all of them but didn't like the white tea and sheng at all unfortunately. The black tea and shou were fine, though I found decaf taste (metallic and somewhat empty in the middle) quite noticeable. The shou was most enjoyable even if it wasn't really creamy, which I usually like about shou.
This year, white2tea released several decaf tea cakes and even two types of decaf shou. Based on u/thezezethex's descriptions in another thread, I figured that the Night Joe would probably suit my taste preferences better than the other shou called Siesta, so I ordered a cake. It arrived last week and though I know that the taste is usually better if you let the tea cake rest after shipping, today I had a good opportunity for an evening gongfu session, so I gave it a try. Here are my thoughts:
There are several positive surprises about this tea. First of all, I don't notice the decaf taste at all. The overall taste is still a bit lighter than most shous I have tried, but it is surprisingly good and even a bit sweet. Earthiness is rather subtle, earlier infusions reminded me of dark chocolate without the bitterness, later infusions reminded me of wood with still some chocolate-y aroma in the background. All in all the taste is simple but pleasant.
Also, the tea was surprisingly creamy. Not in the slurry-like way where you can feel the tiny suspended particles in your mouth, but in a more homogenous and smooth way. To be fair, the tea-to-water ratio was higher than what I normally use for shou (6g/90mL), so a dense-ish liquid was expected. Infusions 2 to 4 were super dark and essentially black.
In total I got 8 infusions out of it. The first one for about 30 seconds, since the tea cake is very compressed, second to fourth for about 10 seconds, after that increasing in large increments. The last one took about 3 minutes and was still very light in color and taste. This is pretty much what I would have expected from any other shou of that price (58 USD for 200g).
Finally, the caffeine, or rather its absence: It is now 11pm and if I would have had 7g of any non-decaf shou over the last two hours, I would be absolutely awake and energized. Instead I am tired and pretty sure that I will be asleep within an hour.
The Verdict: white2tea did an excellent job with the decaffeination process, both taste-wise and in terms of residual caffeine (which I don't notice). Compared to all non-decaf shou I have tried in my life, the taste and texture of this one are nice but not exceptional. But: In light of last year's decaf shou and other decaf teas, I can say that this is by far the best decaffeinated tea I have tried so far. I am confident that I'll have many pleasant evening gongfu sessions with it in the upcoming months.