r/WikiLeaks • u/The_VisibleInvisible • May 05 '26
Surveillance Reuters made three FOIA requests for the Collateral Murder footage. All were denied. Manning released it through WikiLeaks in 2010, did 7 years. The Apache crew were never charged.
Two of the people killed in that 2007 Baghdad airstrike were Reuters journalists — Namir Noor-Eldeen and Saeed Chmagh. Reuters had been trying to obtain the footage for three years through Freedom of Information requests. The military denied each one, and the official account of the incident contradicted what the footage showed when WikiLeaks published it in April 2010.
The Apache crew can be heard laughing on the audio. They targeted a group that included the journalists, then fired on a van that arrived to collect the wounded. The military's investigation concluded the engagement was within the rules of engagement. No charges, then or since.
Manning was 22 when she passed the footage and roughly 700,000 other classified documents to WikiLeaks. Sentenced to 35 years in 2013. Obama commuted to 7 served in 2017 — she was not pardoned. Two more imprisonments after, for refusing to testify against the organization she'd given the material to.
Pew Research, March 2015: 87% of Americans were aware of the Snowden disclosures from 2013. 25% had changed their privacy behavior. The bulk metadata program Snowden exposed continued running. The 9th Circuit eventually ruled in 2020 that it had been unlawful all along — barely covered, no operational consequence by then.
The pattern across these cases: the disclosure becomes about the messenger, the original act becomes a footnote, and the system that produced the original act continues. Awareness is not the same as accountability.

