Hi everyone,
I'm a senior in mechanical engineering at McGill with a strong interest in robotics/mechatronics/IoT, especially medtech. I've spent most of this summer weighing one big decision: pursue a 2-year thesis master's, or go straight into industry after my bachelor's. Here's my thinking on both sides.
Why a master's appeals to me
Mechatronics is inherently multidisciplinary, so I suspect a master's isn't just useful but actually required for some roles in this space. I'm also genuinely drawn to a thesis track over a course-based one: I want to work (when in industry) in new product development, not maintaining legacy products, and I'm passionate about working on something novel. A thesis gives me a shot at doing that: a year or so of deep, high-level work on an original project, ideally with a professor who has industry ties (I've already identified a few who fit). If I go this route, I'd also want to aim for a top school rather than staying at McGill, but I honestly don't know how competitive that makes me. I'm not sure how McGill is viewed by admissions committees at top programs, so I don't even know if I'd have a real shot getting in.
Why industry appeals to me
The alternative is skipping the master's and working my way up directly. I'm confident I could grow quickly that way, and I'd supplement it with side projects and self-directed learning. That said, part of me still leans toward the master's. The multidisciplinary nature of the field and the chance to work on something novel at a high level are hard to walk away from. There's also the fact that most side projects end up being fairly "cheap," derivative GitHub-clone type builds, whereas a thesis is a genuinely serious, sustained piece of work. That gap in depth is part of what keeps pulling me back toward the master's. Still, I can't fully rule out the industry path.
Some context on where I'm coming from
I've prioritized my GPA (3.7/4.0) over extracurriculars, so I have some projects but no design-team experience, you know the kind that tends to land internships at places like Tesla. That's part of why the master's appeals to me: if I already sacrificed project time for grades, doing a thesis feels like a natural next step. And honestly, two years feels like a small trade-off in the long run, especially given my long-standing interest in research with real industry ties.
TL;DR: Senior in MechEng at McGill, want to work in new product development. Deciding between a thesis master's (research tied to industry) or going straight into industry with side projects on the side.
My main questions:
- Is a master's actually valuable for someone aiming at NPD/startup-style work in this field?
- Would it give me a real edge over other candidates?
- Is my instinct right that the multidisciplinary nature of mechatronics makes a master's more worthwhile?
- Or is skipping it, going straight into industry plus side projects, the smarter move?
Would love to hear your thoughts, especially from anyone who's made a similar call.