r/BMW • u/Rooster42423 • 1d ago
Repair Help Windshield Replacement
Got a crack and was able to convince insurance to let me go OEM for my 2026 X3. Only caveat is that I’ll need to pay out of pocket and get reimbursed
Is dealer the best option? My local dealer does the replacements in house. Not outsourced.
I got a quote for $3200, and noticed it also included a bunch of other seals and sound insulation foam
I called my local reputable glass repair shop , and they mentioned they don’t usually replace all that extra stuff. They quoted $2000 for OEM windshield
I’m only leaning towards dealer so I’m covered for warranty purposes, but also a bit weary since they might not be as experienced with it as a full on glass repair shop
14
u/angmarsilar M8 & X7 1d ago
That seems excessive to me and I recently had my windshield replaced. I assume you have a HUD? If so, you have to get OEM. Even on my car, which recently had the windshield replaced, the total was about $1500 (insurance took care of everything) and it took about 90 minutes to 2 hours. Not 5 hours. My dealer doesn't do windshields at all and outsources them. If you're insurance will make you whole, it doesn't really matter then.
3
u/Fluffbutt69 2018 - G30 - 540d 1d ago
I (my insurance) paid 2300 a few years ago which included HUD glass and calibration.
4
u/FivePops 1d ago
OEM windshield on my wife’s 2019 X3 with HUD was $3600+
Went through insurance because it was a lease and wanted OEM parts on it when we turned it in.
4
u/BjjFan1129 1d ago
I used Safelite a while ago and I was fine but if its the insurance paying may as well go dealer
3
u/Quattro2point8L 2017 - F31 - 330i 1d ago
Find out who the dealer uses locally and go to them directly. You'll have to schedule a dealer trip for calibration.
2
u/Rooster42423 1d ago
My dealer does them in house
2
u/Quattro2point8L 2017 - F31 - 330i 1d ago
💀
At the end of the day, it's just glass. Over pay at the dealer or go to a reputable shop. Maybe find out who the Porsche or Audi dealers use locally.
3
u/SugarDaddyVA ‘25 X5 M60i ‘24 X7 xDrive 40i 1d ago
In the last 5 years, I’ve replaced the windshield on a 2022 X3 and a 2025 X5 two times each (lots of rocks being kicked up by semis where I live). I did Safelite for two of them and a local auto glass replacement for the other 2. Largest cost: $1600. My HUDs worked fine on both, I got recalibrated just fine and had no issues.
I don’t know that you need OEM or the dealer to be just fine.
2
u/Beneficial-Ranger238 16h ago
Agree, mine was $1260 on m440i. My tint guy said it was sloppy, but fine. I didn’t realize he did windows too or I would have let him.
3
u/Abject-Error-331 1d ago
Same. Go to satellite or something similar and they will buy the OEM from the dealership and install for 1800 less.
3
u/Invalidfox 1d ago
I had glass coverage on my 22 530i, everything was $1800 billed to the insurer if this helps
5
u/Army_31B 1d ago
I would not use the dealership, any reputable independent glass shop would be cheaper and have the capability to calibrate.
1
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
Hi Rooster42423! You've flaired this post as seeking repair advice. If your issue is resolved by a comment from another user, please change your flair to [Solved] and reply to this comment with a copy/paste of that user's comment.
If your issue was resolved by help outside of Reddit, if possible, please post what solved the issue as a reply to this comment as well. This is so others who face a similar issue can potentially find the solution more easily.
Expand comments to automod to see potential solution(s)
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/EuphoricAd3824 1d ago edited 1d ago
I got the windshield on my 2025 x3 about 6 months ago. BMW dealers in the Nashville area outsource it to a local provider. They replaced and calibrated mine with HUD for just shy of $2k. I used Ultimate Auto glass as directed by the dealership.
1
1
u/kyree47 2006 E63 650i - 2007 E63 M6 1d ago
When I had this done through insurance they contracted a 3rd party to install it but they got the replacement windshield and surrounding trim from the dealership since I also have the HUD and they’re the only place to get the glass.
I also was only going to let them install OEM glass on my car, the company they hired also pushed for OEM
1
u/Costero541 2020 - G30 - 540i xDrive 1d ago
Mine (on a 540i) was $1250 with OEM glass -- installed by 3rd party
1
u/zoegirl2003 1d ago
Just got mine done on my x4 m40i at safelight for 1100.00. All I had to pay was my 500.00 deductible . I have hud, lane assistance, etc . Everything works fine
1
u/cloud-storage-rocks 1d ago
This is why car insurance is so expensive. $1400 in labor alone is wild.
1
u/kupkrazy 1d ago
That's about how much it cost me when I replaced my windshield last summer. I chose dealer because I wanted to be sure the HUD would would properly and also properly calibrated. My insurance only covered like half, though which made me think I should have just paid for it all out of pocket rather than have this claim on my record.
1
1
u/Ok-Acanthisitta-5270 1d ago
Dealership is the way to go. Got my x7 cracked windshield replaced there for about 3600, paid out of pocket and insurance cut me a check. Get the quote from the dealership pre approved by your insurance first and insist on it (they may want to steer you to their network of glass shops, say no). Once approved, get it done at dealership, pay and get a receipt, submit receipt to insurance and get reimbursed. Took me all in roughly a week end to end, easy and straightforward.
1
1
1
u/chasing_daylight 19h ago
Safelite/Speedy will do it for 1/3rd and its covered by warranty. At least in Canada.
1
1
u/IcyHotTodoroki1 13h ago
As a former BMW Service Advisor, the extra stuff is not fluff. Had one customer go cheap and went with another company I won't bash, they didn't properly replace the seals, customer had leaks, wind noise, and their HUD was all fuzzy - ended up having to pay again to replace properly.
I had a similar issue with my windshield, and if I have a $60k+ car I don't want to go cheap on it, especially if I'm going to be reimbursed by insurance.
Better to pay once and do it right, than to cheap out
1
u/ikariaRR 1d ago
I personally stick with dealer, I’m not seeing recalibration on your bills. Make sure it’s oem if local shop and all calibrated especially w/head up display.
I went the same route for Audi
2
u/Rooster42423 1d ago
I’m hoping the calibration is lumped into the 5 hours of labor they have on there
1
u/jbiser361 '02 -332i (S54 swpd) | '19 - 330xi 1d ago
Certain new(er) BMWs don’t need to be calibrated after a replacement iirc
0
u/Any_Rhubarb_2462 22 - G22 - M440xi 1d ago
Used safelite and got the oe glass since I had to replace it again after a year(used oem last time). HUD on the oe glass is good no ghosting or blur
36
u/Pure0ne__ 1d ago
I do windshields at our dealer and you definitely need all that stuff. It's sound insulation and water channels. It's not hard to replace, and you'll be covered under warranty if anything close to the windshield failes. Camera, rain light sensor, I say stick with the dealer. That's the first thing we check on driver assistance concerns or lighting malfunctions, make sure the glass is oem.