Project instruction vs chat prompt

[u/soroxas14]

I’m hoping someone can assist me in defining the difference and assist if my projects are incorrectly structured. Currently I have created project folders for specific topics (ie travel, finance, health). For each project folder I have limited memory to the project and, included a role prompt related to the subject in the project instructions.

Do the individual chats gain enough guidance this way, or should each new chat start with that role prompt anyway?

[u/AutoModerator]

If this prompt worked for you, say what you used it for. If you changed it to get a better result, paste the change.

Prompt Teardown is a free weekly email. Every prompt in it was run, broke somewhere, and got fixed before it went out. Read this week's issue

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/borick]

usually i start the prompt with referenence to the file I want it to use so there's no ambiguity

[u/Rough_Influence_2621]

Kinda but I’ve found they’re 2 separate beasts.

For me I keep the permanent role, rules and behaviour in the project instructions which is similar to what you said .

That’s what they’re they’re good for. Pasting the same massive role prompt into every new chat feels a bit like introducing yourself to your own staff every morning and explaining what company they actually work for. 🥳🥳

My rough rule is: project instructions = how project operates.
Project files = its mini rag. VERY MINI THOUGH. Don’t go dumping in a million tokens worth of material. The model won’t know where to pull from.
Then chat prompt is what you want to do right now.

Another thing to keep in mind is context getting bloated during a long session. Especially when coding, I compact fairly aggressively around 30–40% because after enough debugging, tool calls and abandoned ideas, the context can start looking like a garbage can.

The 30–40% figure is my own rule, though, not an official recommendation.

So I wouldn’t keep reposting the role prompt. Id set the permanent rules once, give each chat a clear job, and manage context separately when it starts working up a junk pile again.

[u/Rough_Influence_2621 → u/Rough_Influence_2621]

Just one dudes opinion 🥳

Let us know how ya go in testing !!!!

[u/Digitalhemanga]

If the role/instructions are already in the Project instructions, you don't need to paste the same role prompt into every new chat.

The project-level instructions are there specifically to give the chats inside that project the shared context. I'd only add something in the individual chat when that particular task needs extra rules/context.

Otherwise you're just repeating the same instructions and making the setup harder to maintain.