r/CompetitiveMinecraft • u/wolkjutein • 2d ago

Who Would Realistically Win?

The best Minecraft Pocket Edition player Or An Casual Java OR Bedrock PC PvPer

I play on MCPE and i suck at fighting PC players but when i fight other Pocket Edition players, I actually win... A LOT. And recently sometimes i do win against PC players, i know i don't represent all of MCPE but i'd say i'm leagues ahead of avwrage possibly top 1,000 one of the only people who can consistently beat me in MCPE is my own cousin, so clearly the odds are NOT in MCPE's favor however just how much is it not in our favor? How extreme do you have to go to make it beatable most or all of the time? Would this be how far we have to go? Is this overkill? Or is it further?

5 Upvotes

69% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

11

u/cj_isbetter 2d ago

Basically to put it into very clear terms
A great pocket edition player looses to an okay console player 9/10 times.

A great console player looses to a below average pc player 9/10 times.

There probably is some console players who can beat average pc players but like its just some things your just ao limited on while on console

2

u/OverallSpeaker1824 2d ago

I will say, I used to play with this guy called ItzShadowX3. That's his yt too. He is insane, I'd say the best mobile player ever. I switched to PC from console 5 years ago, got VERY good in bedrock edition, and I still have not gotten close to beating him... ever. His videos don't do him justice. Brotha was on a different level. I've literally never seen him lose a fight

1

u/ProfessionalStop9967 1d ago

There’s a console player that got lt3 smp so I think a good console player smokes an average pc player

2

u/realdealgrief 2d ago

I was ht1 bedrock sword in 2024 and it took me like six months of playing and like 500 hours of java playtime to get lt3 the skill cieling is definitely higher on java

1

u/Perfect_is_me 2d ago

Pocket edition loses, pojav launcher will win though.

1

u/Weekly_Newspaper_505 1d ago

Right what you have realise is bedrock is limited on what you can do where as java players have pushed the game to a whole new level.

1

u/Relevant-Cup5986 1d ago

i regularly beat pc players in zeqa spear and bedwars and i use the dpad instead of the to many buttons control mode

1

u/Vivid_Spare_7627 2d ago

In bedrock pvp the mobile player would win in 1.9 Java pvp it's completely unfair since on mobile you can't do a lot of things you can do with keyboard and mouse

-2

u/trjoacro 2d ago

Best MCPE player as long as the others are only casuals

3

u/Whycantitypeanything 2d ago

I mean he's literally right

The average Minecraft casual is absolutely dogshit at pvp

Even mcpe has players that do grind PvP

Are they worse than java players that grind pvp? Absolutely

But are they still leagues ahead of casuals? Yes

A ht5 will fuck up the majority of casuals, so even a mobile player who's skill would correspond to like ht4 will beat pretty much every casual

1

u/trjoacro 11h ago

Exactly, yes

-2

u/JoshDix22 2d ago

💀

2

u/trjoacro 2d ago

I don't understand why I'm being downvoted, I've played Pocket Edition for hundreds of hours and beat a couple of PC players on the way aswell as dozens of Console players.
I swear this sub is full of casuals lmao, everyone glazing technoblade and not getting any facts straight

0

u/Wide_Balance_5495 2d ago

A decent pc player will win 99/100 times against a console or mobile player.