I didn’t think this was going to be a thing until kindergarten, but it’s come up and I don’t know what to do. My twins are 18 months old. My son is very, very rough with his sister. Daycare and us have been trying to redirect, praise when he’s gentle, model what we want to see, give other items that he can get that sensory seeking out on (such as other things to hit, bite, push), etc. No matter what we do, as soon as he sees his sister, it’s game over. He’s abandoning the alternatives to tackle her to the ground, hit, bite, etc. It seems to happen when he gets super excited and he’s just trying to play. At first, it was just her. Which isn’t okay, she deserves to not be getting jumped on, hit, bit, etc. But, she also has no issue shoving him off, telling him no, etc. If she gets a bite or a scratch, daycare knows we’re not going to flip, because we’re working on it at home as well.
Now, he’s starting to do it to the other kids. Again, just being playful, but he bit two kids a couple weeks back. A teacher basically had to be by his side at all times, which obviously isn’t practical in a 1:4 setting. It meant the other teacher was basically responsible for the other 7. Around this time, our daughter got sick and she stayed home. Daycare reported that the behaviors didn’t happen at all when she wasn’t there. He was still wild and chaotic (said with love), but he didn’t hurt anyone. They asked for permission to trial separating them into other classes for a week. We agreed. They moved our daughter as, again, our son seemed fine when it was her removed from the equation and everything else was the same. Full week, 0 incident reports. Our daughter is very chill and laid back so she also didn’t care about the transition, loved her new teachers and friends. The two rooms are the same age ranges, so it really wasn’t a huge change. At home, it’s still WWE, with us intervening. And again, easier for us to do because there’s 2 of us and just 2 of them.
Yesterday, they were back in the same room and it was the same as before. He was hitting other kids, jumping on his sister, trying to bite (they caught him before he could). They told us they usually won’t separate multiples unless the parents ask but they think it may be worth doing permanently. I’m not entirely opposed, but I am worried about their bond. Unfortunately, due to our work schedules, our kids are there pretty much at opening and while we don’t shut the place down, they are there pretty late. So, if they’re not getting a lot of “awake time” together at this stage, will it impact their bond? The daycare says they’ll do whatever we’re comfortable with. I feel silly for being resistant. If this is what works, it’s what works.
My husband had the idea of we do this for now and then when they’re ready to move up to the next age group (in about 10 months), we revisit and trial having them in the same class again. Maybe by then, our son will be out of this phase. I am leaning toward that, and the daycare is open.
I also tried to run the same experiment yesterday after I picked them up. My husband took our daughter somewhere, I took our son somewhere else. While he was still all over the place and being his usual crazy self, he wasn’t trying to hurt all the other kids.
Will separating them temporarily for most of their waking hours have a big impact on their bond? Has anyone ever had twins separated this young?