Even though he said the legacy run crashed into another ship but if he read LotJ he’d understand they avoided the crash and that’s what caused the legacy run to tear up in hyperspace

Hi everyone,

I started my journey on march 2023, and still can't believe I would love Star Wars so much once again. I didn't quite know what to expect when reading novels from this franchise but I must say it blew my expectations. It's still a little bit early for me to write this, as I am currently reading Trials of the Jedi but whatever... here are a few of my thoughts on the story as whole.

--- SPOILERS ---

Still can't believe Kevmo is dead, throughout the whole initiative his death impacted me the most. I sometimes ask myself what could have happened if he lived and they both got to shake things up a bit on Jedha. Would the future have been better, would it change the way people think about the Force?

Phase 2 was my favorite, quite a bit of an unpopular opinion but I quite liked Convergence and Cataclysm. The conflict between Eiram and E'ronoh, the hardships both worlds needed to overcome even for a fragile peace... but also Getta and Axel. I quite like Axel's redemption arc.

Speaking about the Nihil, I do prefer the way fights were depicted in Phase 1. I just think that Phase 3 forgot a bit of the insanity and danger of micro hyperspace jumps and all dirty tricks used in the first spaceship battles. Marchion Ro is one of my favorite villains in Star Wars, I enjoyed seeing him taking an initially small ragtag of marauders and beating the Republic in all possible ways by striking at all their vital points rather than using brute force.

Highlights from Phase 1 and 3 for me were Elzar and Avar, their relationship, struggles and them accepting their feelings for each other while always putting others in need before themselves. Then Porter Engle, the cook who happens to be the strongest Jedi duelist as a bonus.

Did Azlin Rell "Raikiried" a Drengir? That was my thought when reading Into the light but I dunno haha. This guy must have thought he was like Kakashi !

And Reath ! How much has he grown ! From this bookworm to that young man who shouldered the weight of the whole galaxy. I really am impressed by what they did with his character arc.

I do have some criticism on the series. Maybe it'll echo with some of you, maybe not. But I did notice quite a bit of repetitiveness in the thematics around the Jedi, sometimes it felt like I was reading the same thing again and it doesn't help that these characters often express their ideas the same way.

Also, there was so much characters and parallel stories. They should have reduced its scope a bit.

If we get another initiative one day (things I would personally like to have):
- For comics, take more time with the drawings and be more consistent with the art style by working with the same artist for a full story. I would prefer less stories but more visually striking.
- I do not believe it was necessary to separate between middle grade / young adult / adult novels. Just write at the best of your abilities and don't tone it down for younger readers, people will grow up and kids won't stay kids. Especially if you read the books again in the future.

So here are my opinions on the initiative. If you read everything, thanks for taking the time ! Don't hesitate to comment your opinion too.

--- TL:DR ---

Loved the THR series, Phase 2 is my favorite but loved the stories and characters from all parts of the series. Would have loved a slightly reduced scope to avoid some of the repetitiveness and would have preferred the comics to get a bit more time to cook and also be reduced in scope and be more consistent with their art style.

I got this book from the library and was flipping through it while listening to Light of the Jedi. I noticed it had sections like 'The Battle of Jedha' which made me think it might have spoilers for the audio drama. It is a beautiful book and I really want to read it but dont want to be heavily spoiled. When is a good time to read it?

'Is that it? As a fan of The High Republic, is that all you can say about Reath Silas?'

"'Uh, he was obsessed with the Archives and preferred books to actual field work. He also had some issues with adventures and the crew of the Vessel.'"

"'HOLY SHIT, YOU ARE AN ALIEN!'"

I really liked the Old Republic books and lore, and recently discovering the High Republic era after watching The Acolyte, which I really liked. I'm going to read the adult novels in release order, but should I also read the young adult and middle grade novels? I probably won't read the comics because I was never really a comics guy.

---

Edit:

ok, after the comments here, and referencing the FAQ and the image in this comment, here's the list i made. In chronological order:

• Light of the Jedi
• Into the Dark
• Test of Courage
• The Rising Storm
• Out of the Shadows
• The Fallen Star
• Midnight Horizon
• Path of Deceit
• Convergence
• The Battle of Jedha (audio)
• Cataclysm
• Path of Vengeance
• Eye of Darkness
• Defy the Storm
• Temptation of the Force
• Tears of the Nameless
• Into the Light
• Trials of the Jedi
• Wayseeker

Seriously impressive that all this was done in the past ~5 years. Totally missed it while focusing on the disney visual media.

It says Enya and Creighton when it supposed to be Aida and Creighton. I had to read the bit again and again as i thought i had missed something

"Really? As a supposed fan of The High Republic that is the breadth of your opinion on Geode?"

"Uh, Geode was part of a crew on the Vessel. There was some controversy surrounding a rock character being introduced into the Star Wars franchise."

"HOLY SHIT, YOU ARE AN ALIEN!"

Hey guys, (Please dont spoil in the comments)

I have a question, i have followed the Completionist Reading order, on this Reddit for some time. I have just finished Into The Light.

Now i have to read some adventure Comics according to the list, and then i have to begin with "Trials of the Jedi" Then again some comics, and after that a "Valliant vow"

Is it also possible to read a Valliant Vow before Trial of the jedi, because Trials feels more Endgame to me, then Valliant. And I would like to finish big.

So what is your opinion on this matter, and has anyone done it, In this order and once again please no spoilers. Thanks

For Light And Life !!!!!

Or is it better to intersperse the comics between novels? Also, what is the difference between the regular high republic comics and Adventures?

I have to admit I didn't quite know what to expect from this novel. Aside from whether its nature as a prequel would have an impact, I was actually more skeptical given that it followed a major event like the Battle of Jedha. Fortunately, I’m happy to say that this book perfectly accomplished everything it set out to do.

I really enjoyed reading this novel. I wasn't familiar with Lydia Kang’s work, and I loved how easily she steps into the story of established characters, giving them a plausible and interesting continuation—surpassing Convergence in my opinion.

Speaking of characters, I have to admit she really resolved the issue I had with Axel Greylark. I wasn't the biggest fan of the character; he struck me as insufferable and hypocritical (and a bit cringey, too) most of the time. It was a real pleasure to see his development here, delving into a person trapped by a childhood trauma and isolated from family ties. This leads him to be both self-destructive and childish, yet deep down he seeks redemption—a journey that is very satisfying to follow. The fact that what finally ended his indecision was having to kill with his own hands speaks a lot about him; he is far from being an irredeemable monster, being more like an "edgy" teenager. Much of this is complemented by the presence of Gella Natai—an incredible character. Her bond with Axel was great and fun to read, even making me think in a romance story. I hope they return in the future.

I also liked the role played by Kyong Greylark, who chooses to be a good mother above all else, rather than a politician. It’s nice to see a dysfunctional family relationship where both parties are willing to make a change.

Of course, the story wouldn't be complete without the antagonists, and the Path of the Open Hand/Closed Fist really managed to step up their game for me. It was great to see how they planned their next attack, playing under their own conditions. The way Elecia found the perfect purpose on the resentment already brewing within her cult—making the formation of a subgroup feel natural—was an unexpected strategy; this group not only did the dirty work but also took the fall for the escalating actions against force-users. In that regard, Binnot can also be see as a tragic figure: desperate to prove himself, disillusioned, and seeking control, yet manipulated by the very person he thought he was breaking free from.

Perhaps my only criticisms of the novel concern are Xiri and Phan-tu; despite playing important roles—and having their own personal conflicts—they faded into the background as the story progressed. Since it was a story involving Eiram and E'ronoh, I would have liked to see them more involved. In the same way, I wasn't exactly a fan of Cippa; while I appreciate having another recognizable Jedi present and seeing how it is illustrated the training of a new initiate, I found her slightly annoying for much of the time.

In short, it was an excellent novel in every respect, featuring both thrilling action sequences and deeply emotional moments. I am excited to see what unfolds in Path of Vengeance.

I just completed my 3d model of Marchion Ro based on Grant Griffin's original concept art for the character! More images and details on the creation process are available on Artstation.

Here is a link to my full Artstation showcase of the piece:

https://www.artstation.com/artwork/egJ0Ab

Any likes on the artstation post would be appreciated!

Been working on a summary for all the phases. Not perfect but I felt like sharing since some of these don’t have summary’s online might be a good resource for someone. This is phase 3 and goes up till temptations. It doesn’t include defy the storm didn’t write a summary for that yet. Upload limit dictates how much I can share at a time :) that being said be warned spoilers ahead

Hi all!
Why this story isn't included in the completionist order? I think I'll just read it at the end of Phase I and that's fine, but I'm wondering why it's absent considering that several (almost) unrelated comics/stuff is included (with the bonus tag).

I've recently finished my first chain of books (Light of the Jedi, The Rising Storm and The Fallen Star) and I've enjoyed it a lot, but I feel like there's a pretty big gap that goes unaddressed?

Like, I'm assuming there's books about Avar Kriss and her struggle against the drengir and subsequent hunt for Lorana Dee that I just happened to miss, right?

I just finished this one. I went in skeptical, because typically, I find short stories end up feeling inconsequential in Star Wars, and it just isn’t usually my jam.

This really surprised me. I didn’t love all of them, but a few of them clicked for me in ways I didn’t expect.

I’m attempting a full reading order for THR. All comics, books, manga, Junior novels, everything. And I’ll be honest with you, sometimes it’s a little overwhelming. Occasionally, characters blur together for me, and or I’ll forget whether it was Bell Zettifar or Reath Silas or Imri Cantaros involved in this event or that battle, etc.

This book gave me clean perspective on some characters who, previously, I’d not really connected with.

I hated Marda Ro during Phase II. I found her unrelatable, idiotic and insufferable. The first person story in Tales gave me fresh perspective.

I never felt much of anything about Bell. Just sort of a nondescript goober padawan. Until I read his short story in this about rescuing Buryagga.

The Ram Jomaram story was adorable. Rooper Nitani’s knighting was a nice Phase II coda. Keeve’s
story was the kind of inspirational Jedi tale that makes you feel good, and the Call of Coruscant was sort of a fun coming of age romp to wrap it all up.

Unfortunately, nothing will ever make me want to read about Axel Greylark.

Amiens, France, 1995
Original post: https://x.com/valeriaaugusta8/status/2086849268531220671?s=46