r/latterdaysaints • u/onewatt • 7h ago
A Tale of Two Prophets - How Fringe Religious Teachers and Latter-Day Saint Prophets Respond to the Same Scary Events
September 11 Attacks
I remember watching October conference after the September 11, 2001 attacks on the World Trade Center. Emotions were stirred all around the globe. The US had just gone to war in Afghanistan. The words of my roommate from the morning of the attacks were still echoing in my ears: "Is this the end of the world?"
Like many members, I kept asking myself, "what does this MEAN?" and I hoped to get a response in General Conference - a firm statement that would match the impact of the event and give prophetic guidance on what we should do next and what was going to happen next.
I think part of me was hoping for some kind of statement about how things were going to get worse and the saints needed to do something amazing. Just 6 months earlier, President Hinkley had given us quite the thrill with the announcement of the Perpetual Education Fund, and it felt important, like the church was really changing the world. So surely there would be an even bigger announcement after September 11, right? We're going to grab land in Missouri and begin to migrate to Zion! Get back to emergency preparedness like never before! Prepare for the shattering of nations!
Instead, President Hinkley acknowledged that we live in the end times, and that prophets had foreseen calamities of our day, even quoting Joel and suggesting he saw an echo of Joel's pillars of smoke in the burning towers - but then he threw water on it by saying things like "I don't know what's going to happen," and "let us be friendly and helpful, protective and supportive." He brought it down and talked about the individual need for repentance, service, and missionary work. Ordinary religious duties on the small scale.
The same things he would have said if September 11 had never happened.
I was a little... disappointed.
I didn't realize it at the time but my need for meaning and importance was a weakness that could have been exploited by those with an agenda. "I'll tell you what this means," they whisper. Then they make the event even BIGGER emotionally. "You are right to be worried. You are right to be afraid. Things are only going to get worse," they say. This is a tool called "anxiety amplification." It is used by conspiracy theorists to amplify a person's psychological need for understanding and control. They amp up the anxiety, then provide their solution. Psychologically this attaches you to the person or movement because they're the only ones making you feel any sense of control, even as they add to your fear and anxiety.
At the same time President Hinkley was writing his conference talk, LDS Uber-Prepper Joel Skousen shouted to his followers about a hidden agenda in government, a dark side in government, controlled terrorist networks, constitutional rights in peril, globalist intervention, stock trading secrets, and other historical conspiracies. He said, in essence, "not only is this important, but it's all connected to these other super important things, and it's all tied back to what I've been saying forever! Buy my book!" He claimed that September 11 was just the beginning.
Meanwhile, FLDS leader Warren Jeffs preached that 9/11 was God's answer to his prayers for destruction of the wicked. Inflating his own importance and primacy to match the event. One follower, Carolyn Jessop describes the narrative as "The destruction of the towers was just the beginning."
This pattern has continued over the years. Here are some more examples:
COVID response
On April 4, 2020, two people believed to be latter-day prophets by different groups spoke on the pandemic, just days after the whole world shut down, and the news was full of reports of dead bodies stacked like cordwood. One prophet brought it back to our relationship to Jesus, while the other connected it to every other anxiety-inducing topic he could think of.
| President Nelson | Self-proclaimed Prophet "Mr. Sniffer" |
|---|---|
| He stood in an empty conference center and explained that the Church was limiting attendance because members should be “good global citizens” and help reduce the spread of COVID-19. And then what great prophetic secret did he reveal about the pandemic? Basically: Listen to Jesus. “We are to seek, in every way we can, to hear Jesus Christ.” | He moved pretty quickly from the virus itself into constitutional rights, government power, President Trump, emergency restrictions, and the possibility that government overreach could destroy freedom. He warned that democracy itself could be destroyed by “conspiring men” mentioned in revelation. |
| "How can we endure such trials? The Lord has told us that “if ye are prepared ye shall not fear.” Of course, we can store our own reserves of food, water, and savings. But equally crucial is our need to fill our personal spiritual storehouses with faith, truth, and testimony. Our ultimate quest in life is to prepare to meet our Maker. We do this by striving daily to become more like our Savior, Jesus Christ. And we do that as we repent daily and receive His cleansing, healing, and strengthening power. Then we can feel enduring peace and joy, even during turbulent times." | "massive market shutdown that is probably precedential and likely to be repeated at some point in the future." How do we respond? "there is a need to acquire land and the need to develop water resources on the land in order to be able to sustain life." "I respect [those who care for the poor], but it's better to stand independent" (spend your money on buying land for this church instead of helping the poor.) |
| This year will be extraordinary as we focus intently on the Savior and His restored gospel. The most important lasting effects of this historic conference will be as our hearts change and we commence a lifelong quest to hear Him. | "The Lord Himself intends to assert governance over the nations and intends to bring about a full end of all nations in order to initiate His own rule. He plans to take this world over, and to do so will require the shaking of Babylon and its collapse" |
| COVID → prepare → serve → repent → hear Christ. | COVID → lockdown → politics → constitutional power → secret combinations → prophecy → end-times scenario → buy land for me. |
Russia invasion of Ukraine, 2022
A lot of members felt President Nelson's response to the Ukraine invasion was disappointing. Some wanted a one-sided condemnation. Some wanted to hear him prophetically justify one side. And some wanted him to stand up and announce that Russia is Gog, Ukraine fulfills some obscure prophecy, the third seal is opening, the bear has touched the lion, and now we finally know where we are on the apocalyptic calendar.
Instead he, once again, refocused us on our individual need to be close to Christ and bring that peace to the whole world. Shrinking the importance of the moment from global to personal.
His gospel is the only answer when many in the world are stunned with fear. This underscores the urgent need for us to follow the Lord’s instruction to His disciples to “go … into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature.” We have the sacred responsibility to share the power and peace of Jesus Christ with all who will listen and who will let God prevail in their lives.
Every person who has made covenants with God has promised to care about others and serve those in need. We can demonstrate faith in God and always be ready to respond to those who ask about “the hope that is in [us].”
Meanwhile the fringe groups raved about how this is actually connected to gadiantons, the IMF, NATO, God declaring war on certain political parties, etc. The same pattern: attach the event to everything else that seems beyond your control, and make it even bigger.
October 7 2023 Attacks in Israel
A few days after the October 7 attacks, the church and Mr. Sniffer both put out statements.
| First Presidency | Prophet "Mr. Sniffer" |
|---|---|
| "As servants of God, we affirm that He calls upon all of us to love our neighbors as ourselves, and we pray for a peaceful resolution of all conflicts." | Cites his own scripture, and identifies the conflict as fulfillment of his own prophecy, proclaiming, "God will soon judge between Abrahams sons" |
Prophet as Psychologist
Recent studies on conspiracy thinking show that anxiety is sorta like a gateway drug into a self-reinforcing circle of belief in conspiracies. Basically the anxiety drives a person to look for a sense of control. The theories provide that sense of control. However the studies show that conspiracy beliefs don't actually relieve the anxiety. One study actually showed they only amplified the levels of anxiety, leading to a greater desire to find more explanations, more theories, and reinforcing that pattern of thinking.
Essentially, these fringe groups and conspiracy theorists respond to anxiety inducing events by pointing outwards, looking for connections and antagonists to blame. But there is no peace there, just an ongoing flood of hucksters looking to turn your anxiety to their advantage.
Compare that to the pattern of the prophets. They acknowledge the anxiety. They connect ancient prophecies. then they turn us to Christ and our individual needs in relation to him. They lead us to the only methods that bring genuine peace. (yes, I checked, and even President Benson followed this pattern when he became president!)
This may not be satisfying in the moment, but it's healthy. It's actual healing.