r/PubTips • u/Nalsin • 57m ago
[QCrit] STARGAZER, 80k Adult Romantic Fantasy, 2nd attempt
Thanks for the feedback on my first attempt! I have expanded on Roman's motivations, added some worldbuilding, made the query less voice-y, and tried to flesh Seven's character out a bit more.
Society as a whole may have accepted new era demons, but Roman knows better. He isn’t going to forgive them for his family’s death, even if it was one of the vicious old era demons who killed them. The sole exception is his younger brother, who he is trying his best to raise despite the boy having come back to life as a new era demon himself over a decade after the slaughter. Roman’s love for his brother conflicts with his job of hunting old era demons, a mission that earns him the community’s distrust, but he maintains his life with a fine balance.
Seven upheaves it all.
A fragment of the abomination that created demons and threw the old world into ruin, Seven has a sunny outlook and no more autonomy than your average gun. Roman’s boss orders him to go with him on a mission to see if another, more dangerous fragment has resurfaced.
Roman meets Seven with ire, which she returns with a genuine enthusiasm for the world around her. Her warmth wears down on his defenses over the course of the trip, during which they supposedly find no trace of the other fragment. Rather than take his leave of her, Roman volunteers to train Seven when they return home. The more time he spends with her, the more he wishes he remembered how to be a kinder person, wants to do better by his brother, and tries to introduce Seven to the world she can only watch from a distance. Yet when the seemingly missing fragment resurfaces with a massacre, her light starts to fade as she blames herself for its actions. After years of wallowing in hatred, Roman must try to give Seven something to live for before she can sacrifice herself in a fight he knows she can’t win.
STARGAZER, complete at 80,000 words, is a standalone adult romantic fantasy with horror elements and series potential. It will appeal to fans of the nuance and slow burn of SOMEONE YOU CAN BUILD A NEST IN, the fresh starts and platonic relationships of RECIPES FOR AN UNEXPECTED AFTERLIFE, and the themes of finding hope and meaning in an uncaring universe from EVERYTHING EVERYWHERE ALL AT ONCE.
[REDACTED] a journalist and international communications student at Taiwan’s [REDACTED]. Her experiences struggling with mental health and belief that it is always worth fighting through the darkness to build a better future went into this novel.