r/SurroundAudiophile • u/Shedsoundsmedia • 3h ago
Review (Recordings) does Gentle Giant's "In a Glass House" AI Assisted Remix work?
For me, this mix doesn't really work ... I don't disparage Eber Pinheiro's work, but in my opinion the AI "de-mixing" tech is not really developed enough yet to justify remixing an entire album this way. My other main point of contention is the source issue - I really don't understand why they went back to a CD master from 2009 when obviously a high quality flat transfer of the master tapes must exist in the vault.
What we have here is a mix upon a mix, and a master upon a master. In stereo, I find the rhythm section jarringly loud and the dynamics completely absent. This is improved a little bit in the Atmos mix, which is certainly less bottom-heavy but the apparent processing on the drums gets fatiguing after awhile. I think "The Runaway" is acceptable but unfortunately the mix never rises above 'acceptable' to me, and starts sounding more and more pulled apart, artificial, and even distractingly bright as you approach the final track.
Overall, I know we're in an era where AI tech is new and needs to be explored to find its limits - but its clear to me that using this tech to remix an entire album is well beyond the limits of the current (and possibly future) tech. Best used to patch holes here and there, missing tracks etc but this is something of a failed experiment, imo.
