r/TheBoredDen • u/ipanicprofessionally • 3h ago
News Does it concern you that the Chief Justice himself called this construction likely unlawful?
Chief Justice John Roberts just told the country that President Trump's White House ballroom construction is "likely unlawful" and the Supreme Court let the bulldozers keep running anyway.
In a 5-4 order issued Monday, the Court's conservative majority allowed construction to continue on the $400 million ballroom, built on the site of the demolished East Wing. The majority sided with the Trump administration on narrow grounds, finding the National Trust for Historic Preservation likely lacks legal standing to challenge the project in federal court.
But Roberts broke from his five Republican-appointed colleagues, joining Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, and Ketanji Brown Jackson in dissent. The National Trust's lawsuit, filed in December, argues the Trump administration violated federal law by moving forward without congressional approval and without submitting plans to the National Capital Planning Commission and the Commission of Fine Arts.
Roberts invoked Winston Churchill's warning that our buildings shape us in turn, then added that this is exactly why the people responsible for the White House must follow the rules governing what gets torn down and built at what he called the People's House.
This fight is far from over. A federal judge had already blocked above-ground construction, and an appeals court upheld that order, citing the missing congressional authorization. Monday's ruling does not resolve whether the ballroom project is actually lawful; it only lets construction continue while litigation drags on in the lower courts.