r/Thundercats • u/Terramoin • 1h ago
Comics New fan reading Thundercats 2024 comic, my review (i'm VERY mixed on this run honestly). Might be a huge dissapointing rant so be WARNED!
Little warning: I feel a bit cranky because this comic really made me well, cranky as i feel i wasted my time on it so i made come across as a little cold compared to my review about the 2 cartoons.
Okay first off, i loved the 80's cartoon, i liked the 2011 one, and i loved the 80's comic volume i got laying here that i read before i sleep.
And second: If you loved this comic thats awesome, wish i liked it as well lol.
I got the 2024 comic and read it all (including Lost) within a week.
I have made a review of the 2 shows as well in another topic and it was way more positive than this topic is going to be and i hope this isn't a spam but this is the last review i'll do as there's nothing else i got on my Thundercat radar for now.
I also refrained myself from watching reviews on this comic as it would definintely cloud my own opinion on it. This is completely 100% my own blind new fan opinion.
The things i liked:
- Its more mature, grittier and edgier, i like that.
- Loads of cool action panels.
- How the Cat Lair was build is awesome and makes more sense this way (with the robo-bears helping out)
- A good explaination on why Lion-o grew older, because his tube malfunctionated instead of "somehow he grew older".
- I liked how Third World was a prison for the mutants and it felt more like a chaotic gang vs gang world, reminded me of Mad Max in a way.
The things i didn't like, sadly enough there's a lot:
- Lion-O... holy hell was this guy unlikable from #2 and beyond, what an ass and completely not what he was in the 80s cartoon/comic and 2011 where he was calm, friendly, heroic and just chill. In this comic he was such a jerk and stuck-up with his holier than thou attitude. In #25 it made me dislike him even more, totally unreasonable, unfit to be a leader if he can't keep his anger in check. And so much for his month journey on his own away from the Thundercats to "become more adult", he grew even worse instead!
- I didn't like how the Sword of Omens broke immideatly at the start only to finally come back at the end.
- Lion-o left the team waaayyy too early, i think #8 is when he got lost only to return way later near the end. He was barely even with the team throughout this comic.
- The story felt super rushed, a lot of things happend so quickly right after the other, it had no time to breath at all. Lion-o leaving quickly, mumm-ra dying quickly, the sword breaking quickly, new characters introduced at an insane pace, everything was done super quickly as if the deadline of the comic was closing in.
- The whole team felt as if they disliked eachother more than liked eachother... lots of arguing, lying to eachother and keeping secrets even fighting physically amongst eachother out of anger.
And what happened to Panthro? He was such a cranky jerk in this run, he was fun, loyal, had a goofy sense of humour in the 80s cartoon/80s comic.
- Lion-o and Calica... they barely knew eachother, then Calica betrayed them, then she returns and Lion-o and her kiss while knowing eachother for what, max 3 days with months gap inbetween? What.................? Yes she somehow got feelings for him which wasn't clear at all, and why would she even have it?
- Bengali... joined the team for a whole 2 issues, did nothing at all and then leaves and... yeah okay thats that i guess?
I expected the reason why he joins (from a writers point of view) was to fix the Sword of Omens as he did in the 80s cartoon, but no Bengali is useless and then Lion-o somehow fixed the Sword of Omens on his own which he could've done at the start? Its never explained.
- Mumm-ra... he was awesome but... he died way too early on in this run.
- What is the plot exactly? There's just things happening with no real payoff. It were random mini stories of 2 issues and then just emptiness, nothing really went anywhere. None of what happend even mattered, i felt i can just read the first 3 issues and then skip to the end and nothing really would change.
Issue 25... oh man, this is just beyond terrible, so bad i'll make a mini review underneat:
- Where are the backgrounds? It was just grey.
- Lion-o was a douchebag for no good reason, even moreso than he already was. He seemed as if Mumm-ra possessed him or something, it was so out of character even for this run.
- Lion-o's allies fighting him just because Jaga told them so, they didn't even TRY to reason with Jaga, no they just jumped at Lion-o without a second thought. Cheetara even stated they must do it because its Jaga who told them so and because he is above Lion-o's rank lol, yeah okay... no loyalty among friends i guess.
- Then Jaga just... kills himself? Why? How? By using a blast on everyone to... knock them away? Again, why? What is the purpose of that? And that now kills him? Then why even use the attack if it kills you? And why even use it when you forced Lion-o's allies to fight him 2 pages ago!? What was even the point then!?
- Jaga told Lion-o "You suck as a leader, you cannot be a leader, you are unworthy of the sword and title" all for him to randomly say, once dying, "You are indeed a leader son..." uh dude... what changed your mind? He fought to defend himself and... that somehow changed your mind? What!?
- Lion-o is mad at Jaga for all the lies, but in the end once Jaga was dying Lion-o was okay with the lies and it is completely ignored as if it never happend. THEN WHY GET MAD AT THE FIRST PLACE!? All this, this WHOLE ISSUE, could've been prevented then!
- The other cats who attacked Lion-o are now... somehow calm and never mention the attack again they don't even apolagize for it, infact they didn't even care Jaga died!! They just... stood there and went "Anyways, so what was the book of omens about Lion-o?".
Man this comic was horrible... had to power through it after #10, might as well since i started it and would've been a waste otherwise =/ This made me not want to buy Thundercats x Silverhawkes or the Mumm-Ra solo anymore.
Good thing is: I loved Thundercat Lost, this was just fun to read and see their struggle and how friendly they were together even during stress.
