My girlfriend and I were fighting. Actually, I disappeared all of a sudden in anger for 3–4 hours, and when I came back, she got angry.
We were talking, and I don't know why she was so furious with me. I was apologizing again and again, but she was saying harsh things. I thought, "It's fine, she doesn't mean all this she's just angry, that's all."
She said many harsh things. For instance, she said "I don't want you" almost 5 or 6 times.
She also said:
"I want someone who is more passionate, responsible, and loving. You aren't."
I was getting hurt, but I still didn't say anything. I thought, "She is angry, isiliye aisa bol rhi, koi ni, she doesn't mean any of this."
I was okay until this happened:
I said, "Ha yar mai ghatiya.. ek dam ghatiya aadmi hun."
She said, "You are good. But you aren't the one I want."
I was like, "What? What are you saying?"
She said, "I don't want you."
I broke down when she said this and started crying. We were chatting, so she didn't know I was crying.
I just said, "I get you... I'm sorry I couldn't be the one."
She said, "Let it be," and then we ended the conversation.
I kept crying for half an hour. You might think it's not that deep, but let me tell you why it hurt me so much.
Actually, I had a situationship with a girl when I was in 12th grade (currently, I'm in my first year). I used to put a lot of effort into her, like making birthday edits and doing small, cute things just because I liked doing them—there wasn't any other reason for it.
Once, we were chatting and she asked me, "Do you like me?"
I said, "Yeah, I do."
She said, "You are a really nice guy, but you aren't the one I want. You are a good guy, but I don't know..."
I was like, "Ah, it's fine, no problem. I get you, blah blah blah." I played it off like it was no big deal. Later on, she dumped me.
Now my girlfriend said the exact same thing, and it's scaring me. I don't want to get dumped this time. 🥀
The next morning, she apologized and said she was angry and all, but I still can't feel good about it. She used the exact same words as my past situationship, and I got dumped after that. I hope you guys understand what I'm saying. 🥀
And it really sucks when girls say, "You are a good guy, but you aren't the one I want." Just simply say, "I don't want you," and stop saying "You are a nice/good guy." You might think it makes us feel good, but it doesn't. Trust me, it doesn't feel good at all—it hurts. 💔💔
TLDR :- i disappeared for a few hours after a fight, and my angry girlfriend told me, "You're a good guy, but you aren't the one I want." These exact words triggered deep trauma from high school when a situationship said the same thing right before dumping me. Even though my girlfriend apologized the next morning, I’m terrified history is repeating itself. Saying "you're nice" doesn't soften the blow it just hurts.