Just wanted to share a review for those who are curious!! I’ve been to Disney world dozens of times but just went to my first party. I went with one friend.
We did lots of research and knew we couldn’t do it all. Our priorities were: three specific food items on the Halloween menu (burger and chicken strips from cosmic ray’s + beignets); headless horseman and ideally the parade; unique/new ride experiences: refurbished thunder mountain, overlay space mountain, laugh floor treat stop, and haunted mansion with character in line; and ALL the treat stops! Since we’d never been to a party, we didn’t 100% know which ones had cool/unique experiences.
We arrived close to 4 but not right at 4. We got our bags and first piece of candy, which was pretty easy. We weren’t interested in pics with Jack and sally but definitely if anyone’s reading this and making plans, if you want to do pics with Jack and sally, get in that line ASAP.
The initial piece of candy is (spoiler alert!) a king size Twix bar that has “ghoulish green” cookie/wafer in the middle (tastes like a normal Twix). The rest of the candy is fun size or mini.
We planned on shopping for Halloween/party merch, visiting the newly reopened big top circus, and doing thunder mountain before 6:30. Unfortunately it was raining/lightning, so thunder mountain was closed. We did the other two items though! We stopped in Star traders for party merch since it was close to where we got our treat bag then went to big top circus. We swung by emporium as well and thought it wasn’t too crowded or anything (some research said emporium gets too crowded but we thought that wasn’t the case and emporium or Star traders is a fine option). We then went to cosmic ray’s to wait for the Halloween menu options to be available on mobile order but noticed they were already available in person so we got our food there then were ready to go pretty close to 7 pm for Halloween festivities!
We decided to prioritize treat stops and did all of them. We thought laugh floor was a bit underwhelming (normally we are huge fans) but didn’t stay a super long time so maybe it got better. We liked the two biggest name candy stops, the one near the center of the park with the villains (evil queen / maleficent) and the one with the three hitchhiking ghosts (our fav)! However we unexpectedly enjoyed walking through the tiki room and we absolutely LOVED the philharmagic stop - our legs were killing us at that point and we stopped to watch some shorts that were playing!
Unfortunately the ground was quite wet and we read that the headless horseman doesn’t come out when the ground was wet so we abandoned the idea of seeing the headless horseman and parade (we decided we will have to come back another time)! So after doing the treat trail we did our rides: thunder mountain, haunted mansion, and space mountain. Thunder and space were pretty much walk ons and haunted mansion was maybe like a 20 minute wait.
At this point we felt we did everything we really wanted except the headless horseman and decided to head back early, around 11 instead of midnight. We were super tired. I did a bit of a walking tour of all three All-Star resorts that morning and my friend who has an annual pass did Hollywood and Epcot for a bit. In hindsight we should have rested all morning!!
We got back to the hotel and counted our candy - we are big on numbers/stats and found it super interesting that there were a number of types of candies that one person had and the other didn’t get at all. We also were surprised in the difference in number of pieces - one person had 97 and one had 88. If I can ever figure out how, I can post a screenshot of the table we made with details that shows all the types of candy we got and the count.
Overall it was a success because we did everything we really wanted to do but we want to go back and do more photo pass stops, more shows / side events (pirates, circus, cadaver dans), and the headless horseman and parade! We will plan better in the future and hopefully be a lot less tired! We also thought we’d have more spare time & squeeze in more rides than we did. That was a bit of a surprise.
If you’re going, definitely come up with a strategy first! If you love rides it’s a great idea to do a bunch of rides and a little trick or treating at the end. If you prioritize shows / parade, that’s a whole different strategy, but still fun! Either way, since you have the option, I recommend at least doing some trick or treating so you leave with some candy! It’s one of the only times you get to leave a disney park with “free” stuff (obviously included in the ticket price! But might as well get it if it’s offered!)