I'm looking for a new pair of shoes for walking/hiking and would love to hear your experiences and recommendations.
I've been wearing barefoot shoes in my everyday life for quite a while now and really like the freedom they give my feet. However, I still use my Meindl Mondello GTX for longer walks, especially when walking the dog through fields and woods.
After more than two years of use, the second sole is now getting close to being worn out, so I'm looking for a replacement.
My main use case:
- Mostly walking the dog
- Around town, but also field paths, forest trails, etc.
- Occasionally longer hikes
- Nothing technical or alpine
What I'm looking for:
- Waterproof
- Robust and durable
- Preferably relatively easy to clean
- Good grip for wet and muddy trails
- Ideally something that can handle everyday abuse rather than being a lightweight running shoe
- A lacing-free or at least tying-free fastening system, such as BOA, would be practical
- Wide and foot-shaped, with enough room for natural toe splay
The Mondello has actually worked very well for me, especially the rubber protection around the heel and toe area, which I really like. What I don't like is the suede upper, as it has become quite discolored and looks rather dirty after a while. I used them with custom made orthopedic insoles.
So I'm basically looking for something between a traditional hiking shoe like the Meindl Mondello GTX and a barefoot shoe: very wide and foot-shaped, but still waterproof, durable and protective enough for walking in the woods.
The big question, though:
I have rheumatic osteoarthritis in my knees, so I'm wondering whether moving towards barefoot/zero-drop shoes for longer walks is actually a good idea for me.
I already wear barefoot shoes in everyday life without major problems, but I'm unsure whether it makes sense to go in the same direction for longer walks and hiking, or whether a bit more cushioning/support, and the option to use orthopedic insoles would be the smarter choice for my knees.
I'm not looking for medical advice, but I'd be very interested in hearing from people who have a similar situation or have made the transition from conventional hiking shoes to barefoot/zero-drop footwear.
What would you recommend as a Mondello alternative that moves more towards barefoot shoes? And how would you approach the knee issue?