I'm surprised how Aamir Khan who is one of the most successful and talented actors of bollywood is being discredited during his bad phase even though he enjoyed an extraordinary box office run at the peak of his SuperStardom.
How fair is it to say that credit for Aamir's great films should go to Kiran and since she left he hasn't been able to do well?
As a matter of fact Kiran Rao has No successful film as a director/producer, Whereas Aamir Khan even before she came in his life delivered many blockbusters including All Time Blockbuster many of his films have been classics as well, infact He even delivered a clean hit as actor/producer after she left his life.
Not just Aamir has always been praised for his excellent script sense by people in the industry right from the start along with his acting skills but also they specially mentioned how Aamir was involved in the film making process right from start to finish and made changes in original story as well.
Aamir has always taken risks, he had the habit of swimming against the tide right from the start of his career, he did stories which weren't conventional, he worked in genre of films which were not favourite of audience at that era, did 1 film at a time, distanced himself from award shows, He never relied on big directors, producers and worked with many new ones who were not successful and most of them have their 1st/only/biggest success and/or best film with Aamir.
Qayamat se Qayamat Tak came with a debutant director when masala films were working and it had a tragic ending, then he worked with another debutant in Dil, Jo Jeeta Wahi Sikandar, Sarfarosh (debutant director) were another non conventional films
Ghajini's climax was changed by Aamir, He also contributed in changes for films like 3 idiots and Rang de basanti, Taare zameen par was directed, Hum hain raahi pyaar ke was written by Aamir, How Aamir Actually Selected Nitesh Tiwari's Dangal and worked for it is also mentioned in detail in various interviews, Sitaare Zameen Par was Made After Kiran Left Him.
It is wierd how Aamir is discredited from his blockbuster success because he gave a couple of flops.
Aamir had the vision to act in Lagaan and produce it when no one wanted to, Dil Chahta Hai is another trend setting urban film released in the same year, He chose these projects before meeting Kiran.
Also Was Kiran part of the Dhoom 3 discussions or not? It was an ATBB but criticism has been there for its quality
Was She Not Associated with Mangal Pandey? Which took a bumper opening and then crashed and became a flop even after having close to 1 cr footfalls?
The only unsuccessful film (though not an outright flop) Aamir had during his golden run after 2005 till 2017 (which is one of the greatest runs in bollywood history) was directed by Kiran- Dhobi Ghat.
Aamir dodged a bullet by not doing Laapata Ladies as it would have been his 6th flop after 1995, 2nd of this decade.
Kiran's own films or her interest by her own admission won't be box office success like the way Aamir's is.
Kiran is still in his life in an official capacity. She mentioned this in her divorce or immediately after divorce announcement.
Constantly demeaning Aamir's contributions to films and his talent isn't fair.
Aamir’s run from Lagaan to Dangal worked wonders but it also includes movies like 3 Idiots, Ghajini, Dhoom 3 and PK which weren’t his own production but were key to his box office dominance during this period.
Aamir’s problem is there was a time he was swimming against the tide and he won. He is still trying to do the same, like not accepting remakes and feel good drama will not work or having a six month OTT window won’t work. This time his decisions are turning back on him.
Just because someone is down doesn't mean we have to kick him!