I'm currently playing a no-nonsense FBI agent in a 1920s Arkham campaign. A devoted, no-nonsense Catholic with a penchant for detectives, Special Agent Napoleon Hammermeister spent 25 years in the navy before taking a job in the Bureau of Investigation (FBI precursor.) After five years of work, he currently is 46 years old, and loves cats, trains, detective novels, and in particular his two nephews (having no interest in a wife of kids of his own).
After being transferred to the new-opened Arkham branch, opened in response to the Innsmouth Raids, Hammermeister's first incursion with the supernatural came in the form of a 4th-year medical student who had learned to resurrect the dead. Okay, maybe resurrect is too strong a word: the corpse could be reanimated within 24 hours of death, and would cause the body and soul to exist in a painful limbo. Amity Woodrow, the medical student in question, had recently lost her best friend to a house fire and was determined to not have such a fate happen again.
Armed with necrotic books, she was able to sneak animal corpses from the morgue where she shadowed as part of her medical training. After successful experimentation, she decided to attempt the process on a recently dead human. However, she realized that she could not control it properly, and went into a mild panic. She tried to hide it, but the corpse had already left.
The Bureau team investigated strange sightings around town, and eventually stumbled upon Amity's lab. After a scuffle with the corpse that ended in its permanent death, the team apprehended Amity and learned the full story.
At this point, our team discussed what to do with Amity. While we were not the ultimate authority on happenings in Arkham, as the arresting team, we could make recommendations to head office. After dispute among the party, Special Agent Hammermeister eventually submitted a report arguing that Amity Woodrow should not be arrested, nor confined to a sanitarium, nor executed. The report suggested that she should be recruited to the Bureau.
It went on to elaborate that Amity was acting out of fear and sorrow, not malice; that she was an incredibly smart mind (able to decipher ramblings on necromancy while also attending medical school); and that she would be an invaluable asset to the branch. She was months away from graduating with a medical degree (and thus knew a lot about biology and chemistry that the branch was sorely lacking); she could be a trusted doctor; but most of all, we knew she wouldn't be easily creeped out by the supernatural and unnatural, having worked at a morgue and having caused firsthand zombies.
The report surprisingly persuasive, to the point where the Bureau actually allowed Amity to join our team part-time while she finished her medical degree. It listed a few restrictions on Amity - a curfew, no access to bodies without Bureau supervisions, mandatory weekly reporting - but they were negligible compared to how her life would have turned out without such a recommendation.
Amity served as a valuable asset to the Bureau. Her forensic knowledge proved instrumental in multiple autopsies we had her perform for the Bureau. The Arkham office grew fond of Amity; particularly Napoleon, who, after years of naval service, felt like he was finally able to help someone instead of inflicting pain. He started to see her as a protegé, an associate, and ultimately an adopted daughter.
After a few months, Amity graduated medical school and joined the team full-time, taking a direct route to becoming a Bureau agent. She never broke her restrictions (grateful for the second chance she was giving), and excelled at being a full-time agent. After another year, she started dating another [NPC] agent at our office, and announced her engagement a year after that.
Was Napoleon's best moment giving the best speech at her wedding? No, but it was certainly appreciated.
Was it getting to give Amity a crossword puzzle book for Christmas? Still no.
Napoleon's best moment was getting named as Amity's child's godfather, whom she named after him: Leon.
What about you? What was your character's best moment?