r/Coros • u/rouxchauve92 • 8h ago
General Discussion Coros Apex 4 Review : Pros and Cons ( So frustratingly close to perfection! )
So I got the Coros Apex 4 about a week ago after 8 years of wearing an Apple Watch followed by about a year with a Garmin.
I will just drop a quick review, or much like a pros and cons list. Some of them I have never seen anybody talk about, which "affect" me the most. As much as the device is far from being perfect, it is also so frustratingly close to being perfect. Well for me.
PROS :
- Maps ! Of course. I won't go into the detail here, you know.
Hardware ! If all the CONS in the following section are about software, the hardware is ON POINT. Love the quality of titanium bezels and sapphire glass. I love the rotating dial (even if software implementation could be better).
- Comfort ! Comfortable HR sensor : Most Garmins now have the new "sharp" disk-shaped HR sensor from Elevate gen 4 and 5. I cannot wear this more than a few hours before having pain on my wrist and a ring-shaped mark. And no, it's not too tight. Garmins with "dome" shaped sensors were always fine, and Apple Watches too. Here the HR sensor and the whole watch feel super comfortable and I can wear it all day and night without problems.
- MIP Screen ! Oh I hate it so much that most Garmins now have AMOLED. This one is debatable, but I just cannot stand having a tiny screen on my wrist (main reason I ditched the Apple Watch). Quality and contrast are super good. Yeah it's dim, so what ; it's an MIP, so that's also the point.
- Phone App ! It is great, much better and clearer than the Garmin one. ( Why can't Coros actually put as much effort into the Watch firmware ?? ( See CONS ) )
- Weather ! Of, Garmin on-watch weather is, at least here where I live, ALWAYS so wrong. Coros using Apple Weather for data make it much more accurate.
- Price ! Yeah, of course, less than half the price of a Fenix 8 solar (even discounted because of the Fenix 9 release ) is not negligible.
CONS [ All software elements that could easily be fixed and that would make this watch "perfect" in my opinion ]:
- The On-Watch Stress graph. Why on earth does it look like that ? No axis, just floating bars. It's hideous and COULD be better, like the HR graph ( or actually any other on-watch graph that actually looks good ). This is just bad for no reason.
- Only having a weekly bar-graph and no daily graph for steps count and calories burned makes no sense. The watch is capable of showing great daily graphs ( again, like the HR one ) so why not provide the most essential one here ?
- Better night / focus modes. The fact that we cannot configure night/sleep mode drives me crazy. I hate having auto-lock ON on the watch, but the rotating dial just always turns by itself at night and messes with the watch. It would be so simple just to have the option to configure sleep mode to have either touchscreen on or off, dial on or off, etc. So to wear this watch at night without messing with everything, I have to put it in sleep mode ( to reduce brightness and stop notifications ), manually disable touch, and manually enable auto-lock. That's nonsense.
- Let us choose the screen (backlight) brightness ! The flashlight widget lets us change it IN the widget, so it IS possible. Why on earth is such a BASIC setting not available ? Come on COROS!
- Notifications management could be better. Like regrouping them by app / categories, you know, like on any other watch that has phone notifications...
- The "Daily Activity" widget show 4 data : Steps, Calories, Activity Minutes, and Floors Climbed. Yet, when we select it, we see graphs (the same one that would highly benefit having a daily view and not only a week view) for all 4 ... Except for Floor Climbed. ( So 4 data points --> 3 Data points, not logical )
- Control center feels very unfinished. Why have a circular menu like this, with a big empty spot in the center ; with icons no-one can know what they do until we try pressing them. If only there was room to put a descriptive label ... Oh, wait.
- I [personnally] had a problem the first time I used the watch : Unboxed, updated to latest firmware as soo as possible. And then, screen backlight was always ON. It was either fully activated, but it was unable to go to zero and was always on (but dim) with no settings changed, only update done. Powering the watch off and back on did not solved this, but a complete factory reset did. While doing the fa tory reset I was aiming to put back the watch back in its box, but seeing that the issue was fixed after the reset, I gave it a second chance.
- Screen can auto-lock, but to way to manually lock it. An icon in the Toolbox would solve this easily.
- Screen Unlocking options : it's either off, rotate, or long press. But it does unlock while long-pressing ANY button (not just the digital crown, as the choices would implicitly suggest), which is both a bad idea (more accidental unlock) and not ergonomic at all
All in all, I'm still debating if I keep the watch or not. Even if there are a lot of positives here, the negatives are just driving me crazy (and should not even exist in the first place). Watch physical quality is awesome, but the firmware quality is mediocre and inconsistent. I hope Coros fixes them one day, but I won't hold my breath past my return window anyway.
Note : I did not talk about traning stuff and metrics and a lot of other stuff, which fall in the "It's great/it's OK" category.
So that was just my (long) 2 cents. Like it or not, I'm just dropping it here for reference and for others thinking about getting a Coros Watch.
EDIT : Added some CONs after replying them to u/COROS-Official
