For a DIYer with casual woodworking projects, I don't need a very expensive dust extractor or a battery only item (like Milwaukee Dust Extractor) for something like this. They are also very $$$. Therefore looking for a decent budget setup.
Will be making some closets and cabinets over the next few months, main use being M18 track saw, but future uses could be some smaller sanding projects (5" orbital sander, etc).
How does the Hercules Dust Extractor for $369 stack up for those who use it? Is it really loud?
Also, how does a DE stack up vs. a shop vac for regular shop vac type trash pickup? What about for wet/water pickup? Wouldn't mind having a DE if its also versatile like a shop vac, but also is a DE for my main purpose.
Debating this route vs. a "quiet" branded shop vac.
Can someone recommend some setups for me, and even accessories like hoses/adapters you think are great or if the stock DE is fine?
Few options I'm thinking about and looking for feedback on:
- Budget + Compact + Look Good Option: $75.99 (when on sale) DeWalt 8-Gallon 4HP Stealthsonic Quiet Stainless Steel. MSRP is $99.99 Costco. Stainless, compact, quieter. Wet and dry. Think I can't go wrong here. Con: Probably need to replace the 7 ft hose. No real storage bag or legs for the accessories. Below DeWalt has that.
- Bigger Capacity but Plasticey look: Either Dewalt Stealthsonic Quiet 12 Gallon 5.5 HP ($139 Lowes / $124.99 Costco) or Shop-Vac 5430098 Ultra Quiet Wet/Dry Vac 12 Gallon 5.5 HP ($119 Amazon). I don't mind spending a little more if its better, but I kind of feel like for dust extraction, option 1 might be better? Con: Plastic look. Probably need to replace the 7 ft hose. Big Con: Mustard Yellow (lol).
- Budget Actual Dust Extractor: Hercules 12 Gallon OSHA-Compliant HEPA Dust Extractor ($369.99 Harbor Freight). Can wait for sales probably and get it like 15-20% off. But I have no comparison how much louder (or quieter) it is than the 2 above quiet shop vac options. It says you can do wet/dry, but not sure how much worse this would be as a "vac" or "wet vac" only if I needed one. Pro/Con: 17 ft hose, but it doesn't mean its a good hose. IDK.
Any hoses/adapters, things you like? I'm eying the Shop-Vac Wireless Remote Control Outlet Plug ($23.99 Amazon) to put the button on the top of the hose where it connects to the tool. Wondering if a better option exists for this too.