r/hotels • u/Visual_Big_9187 • 22h ago
Hilton charged me $2800 for a "broken TV" after requesting refund for smoking room
Edit 2: (copied this edit to the top) this is Homewood Suites in London, Ontario.
I want to share an experience I had at Homewood Suites, a Hilton-branded hotel, this past summer, because I'm still stunned at how a simple complaint turned into months-long ordeal involving gas-lighting, dishonesty, and a $2,800 charge for a TV I did not break. As someone with AuDHD, I don't excel in confrontational or ambiguous situations. I try to follow the rules, trust systems, and assume good faith, but this experience made me feel completely powerless, confused, and frankly, bullied.
In mid-July, my family and friends stayed at a Hilton property that was filled with children's baseball teams. When we checked in, the room we were assigned smelled strongly of cigarette smoke. It wasn't subtle, it hit us immediately. When I went to the front desk, they moved our friends to another room but told my family they couldn't move us. So we had to sleep in a smoky room.
The next morning, I spoke with a manager who said she couldn't do anything and that the General Manager (GM) would call me the following day. She offered a late checkout, which was already included in our Hilton Gold as a perk. The following day (Monday) I heard nothing from anyone at the hotel, so by the afternoon I contacted Hilton corporate, explained everything, and opened a case.
Only later that evening did the GM call. The conversation was unpleasant. She tried to deny smelling anything and felt like she was gaslighting me at one point. I explained that I simply wanted a refund for the smoky room. She refused and tried offering loyalty points instead and brought up the late checkout as a form of payment, which I mentioned was already included as a perk of my Hilton Gold membership.
Over a week later, completely out of nowhere, I received an email from the hotel claiming that during a "routine inspection" they discovered the TV in my room was broken. There was no other explanation, just an email telling me that the TV was broken and I'm getting charged $2,800 for it.
I want to be absolutely clear: **I did not break any TV. None of us did. The accusation is false. It is dishonest. It is retaliation for pushing for a full refund for the smoky room. There is no other explanation that makes sense.**
Naturally, I disputed the charge with American Express after an agent at Hilton corporate suggested it.
For almost two months, the investigation dragged on. Finally, Amex sided with the hotel, not because the hotel provided a compelling explanation, but because they sent one single photo of a broken TV, with no context, no timestamp, no connection to my room, nothing that would tie it to me in any way. Just a picture, that was my first time seeing that picture.
Nearly 3 months later, only after Amex sided with the hotel, did I reach out to Hilton's so-called "executive office ambassador", which is supposed to be the highest level of assistance. To my shock, they completely accepted the hotel's version of events, saying the hotel claimed they replaced the TV immediately because the room type is "popular".
I didn't break anything. I didn't lie. I didn't cause trouble. I simply spoke up about a smoky room, and the hotel responded by inventing a charge and stealing my money.
How much stolen money is keeping their stock price afloat. Victims always lose and bullies always win.
Edit 1: this is Homewood Suites in London, Ontario.