r/icarly Oct 23 '25

Announcement User flairs are now active

25 Upvotes

Go add your new flair!

Will keep adding to the list over time so keep an eye on it.


r/icarly Nov 08 '25

Announcement Updated subreddit rules.

12 Upvotes

Just wanted to let you all know that there have been some updates to the sub rules.

Nothing crazy, however in the interest of transparency wanted to let everyone know instead of just doing it quietly. As always, rules are available in the sidebar on desktop and at the top of the sub after clicking on the subreddit name on the app.

Removed rule:

  • Memes must be SPICY
    • a fun rule, but too vague and open to multiple different interpretations. Therefore difficult to moderate fairly.

Additions:

  • Sales and fundraising must be approved by a mod first
    • this is included in the rule "No Spam, excessive self-promotion or unauthorized sales"
    • We recently had a situation with a possible scam sale, as such all sales and fundraising must be authorized by a mod in modmail first.
  • Use spoiler tags for the iCarly Movie

    • This is included in the "use clear titles and spoiler tags" rule
    • With the possibility of the iCarly movie please use the reddit spoiler tag function if posting or commenting a spoiler about the plot. Posts providing production updates or merely speculating about the plot are not considered spoilers and do not need to be tagged.
  • No AI generated posts

Rules about post titles, reposts, quality, harassment and the sexualization of underage characters and cast remain, but may have been reworded for better clarity. Reddit terms of service also apply and content may be removed even if not explicitly listed in our rules as reddit rules are site-wide.

Any way! That's the end of this boring post. Thanks for everyone who makes this sub great! we really don't have to step in and remove rule breaking stuff very often which is all thanks to you!


r/icarly 16h ago

Original Discussion Steven cheated on Tori with Carly, not the other way around

98 Upvotes

This is just a detail I noticed, but I haven't seen anything discussing it. If Steven and Carly's 100-day kiss was next month after his return to Seattle, then Steven and Tori's 100-day kiss was earlier than that. That means that Steven started dating Tori before he started dating Carly, making Carly (without her knowledge) the other woman. This doesn't diminish Carly's experience because she did discover that her boyfriend secretly had another girlfriend, which is always a huge betrayal no matter whom he dated first (and she didn't even know who was the first girlfriend until she talked to Tori and learned about the latter's 100-day kiss that night). I thought this was an interesting detail that no one seemed to have talked about yet.


r/icarly 1d ago

Other Discussion Nathan Kress directed episodes of Hollywood Arts

Post image
184 Upvotes

r/icarly 19h ago

Original Discussion Dave’s Dad was Abusive

Thumbnail
gallery
39 Upvotes

I feel bad that Dave got his laptop destroyed because of Fleck, but I do agree that Dave’s dad was out of line when he destroyed Dave’s laptop with a hammer. Yelling at Dave is understandable, but destroying his laptop was bullshit because he could have grounded Dave instead, contact Fleck’s parents to bill them to remove the paint from his car, and could have told Dave that Fleck either isn’t welcomed in the house anymore or he could hang out with him at his place.

It’s understandable on one part for Dave’s Dad to not like Fleck with how it was shown that Fleck did cause issues before like accidentally cutting Dave that caused him to bleed. He could have billed Fleck’s parents instead of taking his anger out on his son.


r/icarly 3h ago

Original Discussion How would you rank the seasons?

2 Upvotes

I would rank them

  • Season 6
  • Season 4
  • Season 3
  • Season 1
  • Season 2
  • Season 5

(IK this is bold but I genuinely prefer 4 and 6 to 1-3, but I do agree season 5 is the worst season, I just kind of feel seasons 1-3 are boring, but season 3 is better than 1 and 2)


r/icarly 1d ago

Original Discussion Do we think Melanie ever asked Sam about what he said

Post image
83 Upvotes

This scene is so funny to me because once he says “you swore we’d never do that again” she just looks so confused LOL, also who else was pissed off by the way Freddie acted in this episode I wish they let him see her and Sam together in the end scene
(I could only find this picture on a YouTube video because I obviously can’t screen shot Netflix)


r/icarly 1d ago

Original Discussion Gordon Birch - iDo

Thumbnail
gallery
69 Upvotes

The actor also appears in "Two and a half men" as 'Gordon' too


r/icarly 1d ago

Original Discussion What was the deal with The little girl in ISpace Out

7 Upvotes

It’s weird how they had Spencer chalk it up to a hallucination she was only hiding at certain times when Spencer had people come see her to mess with him. Clearly some irresponsible parent was letting their child wander around the building. it seemed like it was just a typical lazy Schneider’s Bakery plot with no real purpose beyond being ‘random’ and a frustrating non-resolution. I was hoping they would finally resolve that and reveal who she was in the revival but they didn't we were robbed of a great resolution to this day that little girl's identity still hasn't been revealed


r/icarly 2d ago

Other Discussion Is iCarly worth watching as an adult?

75 Upvotes

Hi! I know that the target audience is primarily teenagers, and I know that most, if not all, of you here are adults. Many of you probably watched it during your childhood or teenage years, and some of you may have even rewatched it when you got older. But for someone like me who never watched it growing up, would it still be enjoyable and worth watching, or is it simply no longer aimed at someone my age?


r/icarly 2d ago

Original Discussion What if Walter White was the Chemistry teacher at Carly's school?

5 Upvotes

What would happen?


r/icarly 2d ago

Original Discussion iRescue Carly

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

It's a little cringy how Carly behaves in this episode, lol


r/icarly 2d ago

Original Discussion Does anyone have the extended version of isaved your life?

8 Upvotes

So i'm trying to find the extended version of isaved your life but i can't find it.

If you have it please dm me.

If you have the extended pilot episode that would also be great.


r/icarly 3d ago

Original Discussion favorite icarly episode?

Post image
157 Upvotes

r/icarly 3d ago

Original Discussion iMeet Fred made me mad

Post image
622 Upvotes

I remember watching this episode live when I was younger and asking myself why Freddie didn’t like Fred. Looking back now, I actually agree with him. Fred really wasn’t all that funny lol.

What really made me mad was Fred quitting his videos just because Freddie said he didn’t like them. Like damn, it was one person’s opinion 😭 Freddie wasn’t telling everybody else not to watch Fred or trying to get him to quit. He just didn’t think he was funny.

Then Freddie gets picked on, kicked out of clubs, and Sam keeps bullying him over it like he did something wrong. That whole situation was so unnecessary.

I know it was supposed to be funny, but watching it now, I’m definitely on Freddie’s side. He shouldn’t have been treated like that just because he had a different opinion.


r/icarly 3d ago

Original Meme ICARLYS BEEN HIJACKED BY A PSYCHOTIC SHEDUCK

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/icarly 3d ago

Revival Discussion As a kid I thought Freddie's camera was so cool I wanted one but now I'm older this is the most useless piece of crap I have ever seen it's so big and bulky and what's with the glow stick

Post image
254 Upvotes

r/icarly 3d ago

Original Discussion Another good option as Socko (Best player, 2011)

5 Upvotes

To me could be perfect.


r/icarly 3d ago

Original Discussion Remember Ashley Argota in iCarly?

Post image
41 Upvotes

r/icarly 4d ago

Original Discussion Nobody has respect for Carly’s house lol

Thumbnail
gallery
251 Upvotes

It really baffles me that literally nobody had respect for the Shay’s household, especially in the episode iBeat the heat. I really wish they were both more assertive in this episode lol, I know everyone was all sweaty and everything but they just inviting themselves in without any regard of the owners

And there’s so many other episodes where people have no respect, like iStakeout, iSam’s Mom, iGet banned, iScream on Halloween etc. Carly and Spencer are really nice and patient people, honestly everyone would’ve been banned I was them lmao😭


r/icarly 4d ago

Revival Meme Carly's pregnant?

Thumbnail
gallery
84 Upvotes

Meme + original image.


r/icarly 3d ago

Original Discussion What if MEGAN fought Shelby Marx?

7 Upvotes

Not Carly, but MEGAN. How would that go?


r/icarly 4d ago

Original Discussion Favorite Quote

18 Upvotes

What is your favorite quote from the show?

Mine is, from the episode titled, I Got Detention…

“Do I smell burritos?”

I still laugh so hard every time.

Blind OP.

Edited to add the episode title.


r/icarly 4d ago

Fan Art Trying to draw Miranda (work in progress). I don't think I like it. 😔

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/icarly 4d ago

Original Discussion why didn't sam fight shelby marx?

9 Upvotes

rewatching the show for the first time since i was a kid, and it was literally my first thought when i got to this episode. carly was very clearly joking when she called her out, and i don't think it would be believable at all for her and shelby to have a real fight. now sam is known for her feisty personality and getting into actual fights and winning so it would be a much more believable fight, and despite the webshow being called icarly she's basically as famous, like luigi, so wouldn't even be less marketing potential.

besides making more sense in-universe, i also just think it would be a far more interesting and less bad plot for the episode itself, have sam and shelby originally friendly gonna fake it mostly but maybe sam gets too into the trash talk and actually upsets her, or maybe they can't decide who gets to win in their mock fight and out of self-confidence from both of them now they're gonna fight for real, carly tries and fails to be the mediator and other shenanigans ensue.

overall just think this difference would make for a better special.