r/indiebiz • u/launch3r • 9h ago
Why I gave the free tier every feature instead of a crippled demo
I’m building Prompt Maschine, a focused mobile product for songwriters who use Suno, Udio and other AI-music tools.
The product has a lot of interconnected tools — prompt builder, structured lyrics, YouTube and audio analysis, rhyme controls, Style Trainer, conflict detection and Auto-Fix. My first instinct was to lock the more advanced tools behind PRO.
I changed that. The free plan now includes every tool, but limits usage to 3 generations per day. The reasoning is simple: users cannot understand the value of the workflow if the most useful parts are hidden. The subscription ($9.99/month or $59.99/year) removes the cap instead of unlocking a different product.
The positioning challenge has been harder than the engineering. “AI lyrics app” sounds generic, while the real value is reducing the repeated editing between a rough idea and a prompt that Suno or Udio can actually use. I’m now leading with the workflow and concrete before/after examples.
Product: https://promptmaschine.com
Apple: https://apps.apple.com/app/prompt-maschine/id6762012689
Android: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.traianarion.promptmaschine
For other indie founders: would you rather see a feature-limited free tier with more daily usage, or the whole product with a low daily cap?