TL DR: I know what I feel. I know what I want. I’m finally putting all of myself on the table. Now I need to know what you want and what you are willing to do about it.
Let me say all of these so I can get it out of my system.
I am tired of understanding you. There. That might be the most honest way to start this.
I understand you all the time, I understand that you need space and process things differently. I understand that words are harder than actions. I understand that you don’t naturally initiate texts, that you could be thinking about me even if you don’t reach out. I understand that you weren’t ready for a relationship and that you never promised me one. I understand your resistance to labels. I understand that school is exhausting, and you don’t know what your capacity is. I understand that we are different. I do understand all of that.
But sometimes I want to ask, do you understand me? Do you understand what it felt like to be the person who wants you this much while constantly trying not to want too much from you? Do you understand how many times I have wanted to text you and stopped myself? I see something funny and I want to tell you. Something happens at work and I want to tell you. I hear a song and think of you. I see something you would like. I have some completely stupid idea that I know you would laugh at. And my instinct is to tell you. But typically, I don’t, not because I don’t want to talk to you but because I want to know if you will come looking for me. Do you know how shitty that feels? I don’t want to run experiments on you. I don’t want to sit here thinking, don’t text her, let’s see how long it takes. I hate that. I hate that I even think that way. But what else am I supposed to do when I want to know what happens to us if I stop creating momentum for both of us. So I stop and then there is silence. And I told myself: She’s busy. She’s tired. This doesn’t mean anything. She told you this is how she is. Give her space. Don’t be needy. Don’t make this bigger than it is. Meanwhile another voice in my head is saying, why is it too hard for her to reach for me? And I hate that voice because I know it isn’t completely fair. But it is there and I am done pretending it isn’t. Sometimes I want you to fucking miss me, not privately, not somewhere inside your head where I am supposed to trust that I exist. I want you to miss me enough to do something about it. I want you to think, I haven’t talked to her today. I want to know what she’s doing. I want you to send me the stupid thing. Tell me the boring thing. Ask me the unnecessary question. I don’t care what it is. I just want to feel you reaching for me.
And yes, I know you have. Believe me, I know. I remember every one of them because apparently, I have become a person who remembers the days the woman she wants texted first. Think about that. I notice it because it still feels exceptional after all these months. Then there are the moments when I give you something vulnerable and you just ignore me. I told you I missed you. You know how easy that sentence would have been to answer? I miss you too or maybe I know you do. Four fucking words. That’s it but you didn’t. Maybe you read it and smiled or thought it was sweet. Perhaps you didn’t know what to say. I can come up with several more explanations as I have become excellent at explaining you but underneath every explanation was that it hurts. I told you I missed you and you left me there. I know that sounds dramatic for one text, but it isn’t one text. It is everything underneath it. It’s months of sometimes feeling like I am standing in front of you with my heart in my hands while you quietly decide how much of it you are comfortable touching.
I have tried so hard to make this comfortable for you. I have tried not to pressure and rush you. I have tried to respect every boundary. We agreed with this We’re Not Dating universe because somehow that was the only place where we could have each other without having to call having each other anything. Honestly, for a while, that worked for me too. It was fun. It was weird but it was ours. We got to discover each other without forcing an answer, but we are 40+ fucking dates into this now. Forty. At some point I need to be allowed to ask: What the fuck are we doing? Because this does not feel casual. This does not feel like friendship with benefits. This does not feel like two women killing time until January. You are woven into my life. I know the little ways you show me you care. I know how present and affectionate you are when we are together. When you are kissing me, laughing with me, holding my hand, and pulling me closer, I experience you as wanting me even though it took me a while to believe that you want me. That’s part of what makes this so goddamn confusing. Because when I am with you, I don’t doubt you. When you’re touching me and kissing me and laughing with me and pulling me against you, I am not sitting there wondering whether this is real. It is fucking real. I feel it. And then I leave and somehow, we turn back into two people who are “not dating.” We turn into people who can go on for days without communicating. One is really not communicating, and the other one is refusing to communicate to not pressure the other. That difference between who we are together and who we become apart is becoming increasingly painful for me. Sometimes I want to look you straight and say: Look at us. Just fucking look at us. What exactly do you think this is? And maybe you genuinely don’t know. Maybe that is the answer. But I am allowed to say that being loved or whatever word you are comfortable using for what you feel for me by someone who refuses to name what is happening can be incredibly lonely. Because I am living it. I am not hypothetical about you anymore. You are not an experiment to me and not a woman I am casually exploring.
You are S. And I fucking love you. There. I LOVE YOU. I have known it for a while now. I have carried it around. I have almost said it. I have thought about when I should tell you and how I should tell you and whether you’re ready and whether it would scare you and whether it would make you feel pressured and whether you would think I suddenly expected something from you. Do you understand how crazy that is? I am in love with you and somehow, I have spent more time worrying about whether my love will inconvenience you than simply being allowed to feel it. I don’t want to do that anymore. I love you. You don’t have to say it back. You don’t have to feel the same way but I am not going to act like my feelings are smaller than they are just because the truth might make you uncomfortable.
And here’s another truth I hate admitting. There have been moments when I have been ridiculously happy because you initiated something that I would consider completely normal if I were in a regular relationship. You texted first. You suggested the date. You picked me up. You asked what we are going to do tomorrow. And I am sitting here internally going: Oh my gosh, she is here. And then another part of me thinks: C, what the fuck? Why does basic reciprocity feel like Christmas morning? Why am I keeping mental receipts every time she moves toward me? Why does it mean so much? Because I have been longing for it. That’s why. I don’t need you to become me. God knows two of me would be fucking exhausting. I don’t need hundreds of texts a day. I don’t need every weekend or every evening. I don’t need constant reassurance. But I need something more than this. I need to be wanted. I need to feel pursued. I need to feel like you are capable of being the person who says: I want to see you. I miss you. Come over. Are you free? I was thinking about you. This reminded me of you. I want you here. I want to know what your wanting looks like when you stop being afraid of it. I want some agency from you. Not because I want control. Because I want a partner. And I know, we’re not partners. Fine. Whatever. Then I want the woman who has spent 40+ dates building something intimate with me to take some responsibility for whatever the hell we are building. Because I cannot do September through December exactly the way I did March through August. I can’t. I know too much now. I feel too much now. I am not asking you to know whether you want me forever. I am asking you to show me that you want me now. Actively. Deliberately. Without me always having to create the opportunity.
I need you to take some emotional risk because I have taken so much of it. Risk texting me first and wondering whether I’m busy. Risk asking to see me and possibly hearing no. Risk telling me you miss me. Risk saying something tender without knowing exactly what I will do with it. Risk wanting me where I can hear and feel it. I need you to look inside your heart, ask how much you want this and what you are willing to do about it.
And I need words sometimes. I am tired of doing emotional archaeology, collecting tiny clues and reconstructing your feelings from them. I can handle imperfect and messy words. Tell me you want me. Tell me you are scared. Tell me you don’t want to lose me. Tell me you’re confused. Tell me you’re falling for me. Tell me you aren’t. I can handle the truth. What is exhausting is constantly having to interpret silence.
I know there is a possibility that I will tell you all of this and you will say: C, I can’t give you more. That terrifies me. Because then what? What the fuck am I supposed to do with that? I love you. I don’t want to walk away from you. I don’t want another woman. I don’t want some hypothetical emotionally available person who texts every morning and communicates perfectly. I want you. I wanted this to be you. I want your stubbornness, your independence, your resistance to labels, and your strange little ways of showing affection. I want the teacher with the dog, the cat, the house, the routines, and her guarded fucking heart. I want the woman who makes me laugh. I want the woman I cannot stop kissing. I want the woman whose body I know and whose mind I am still learning. I want my friend. I want you.
That is why I have been patient. That is why I have stretched and tried to learn how you love instead of demanding that you love exactly like me. You have taught me that quiet love can still be real and that difference does not automatically mean incompatibility. And I am proud of that because that tells me I am growing inside this relationship.
But I am also teaching myself something: understanding you does not require abandoning me. I matter too. My need for communication matters. My desire to feel wanted matters. My need for acknowledgement and reciprocity matters. My fucking heart matters.
Sometimes I have negotiated against myself because I was afraid of losing you. I don’t want to lose you but I also don’t want to keep losing pieces of myself to keep you and I think I have done that sometimes. Every time I wanted to say something and decided it was too much. Every time I needed reassurance and told myself to self-soothe instead. Every time something hurt, and I immediately defended you to myself. I made myself smaller and accepted less because less from you still felt better than losing you completely. That is mine to take responsibility for. You did not ask me to do that, and I do not want to resent you someday for sacrifices you never asked me to make.
So I am telling you now.
Underneath all of this frustration is the simplest truth: I love you. I love being with you. I love our romance, our intimacy, and friendship underneath all of it. I love who I am when I feel safe beside you. I love you enough that I desperately want to find out what happens when we both truly show up for this. Not just me. Both of us. I don’t need you to become someone you are not. I need you to want this enough to reach for it too because I cannot keep carrying both sides of something that is supposed to belong to both of us. So please don’t hear this as me leaving, it is the exact opposite. This is me fighting like hell to stay. This is me finally putting everything on the table. This is me saying: Here I am. All of me, with all my big feelings and big questions. No filters. No pretending I don’t need anything. No weird project names to hide behind. Just me. I love you. I want you. I want this to be you.