r/Menieres • u/sabos909 • 5h ago
Any Harmonica Players with MD here?
I have a bit of an oddball question related to my Meniere's disease to ask that I'm hoping someone here can relate to.
This summer I've decided to learn to play the harmonica. I'm having a lot of fun with it, but have hit a point in my study where I need to learn how to bend notes. Bending notes on the harmonica involves breathing inward while positioning the back of the tongue towards the rear of the mouth in order tune the cavity of your mouth in such a way that it activates an additional reed in the instrument and pulls the pitch downward into a note that the harmonica cannot otherwise reach.
There's an interesting study showing MRI images of a harmonica player named David Barrett bending his notes: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/236664195_Real-time_magnetic_resonance_imaging_fo_the_upper_airways_during_harmonica_pitch_bends
I understand the technique well enough and can successfully hit my bends most of the time, however doing so causes a feeling of pressure in my sinuses and can even cause my ears to pop.
Practicing this technique for more than a minute or so often leaves me with a sense of dizziness like when I have a Meniere's attack, just without the nystagmus and spinning. It's a very similar sensation to the one I experience during extreme swings in barometric pressure. Just yesterday I spent about an hour practicing and was rewarded with imbalance and dizziness for the rest of the evening.
Are there any other harmonica players here with MD?
Have you ever experienced something like this before? I feel like the crossover population between people who play harmonica and people who have Meniere's is so small that I'm having trouble finding people who might be able to help.
I've mentioned this to my doctor and she just told me that it didn't sound dangerous but I may need to modulate my playing if I start feeling dizzy. Not super actionable stuff.
Anyways, here's hoping this lands with someone who's experienced a similar issue and can at least relate to what I'm trying to describe.
Cheers.