If Magneto was even BORN in 1945 he would be 81, if you want him to have lived through it, he would have to be 90 atleast.
So the answer is either timetravel Magneto 40 years or set the story in the 80es and since they cant to both in the MCU...
Would be cool to make Magneto a victim of a new tragedy but then he would 99% not be white and wow imagine the reactions to an arab/african/asian/south American Magneto
Its not that they are moving it, its that the suggestion has been to move it to modern day American ICE problems.
You could easily move Eriks story to Bosnia in the early 90s, and accomplish much of the same that his holocaust origin does. You also keep him jewish and connected to the holocaust because of family. He would have been raised on stories of how bad it was, and this would be an example of it happening again which would feed his hate for humans in a natural and understandable way.
Oh my god. Okay, as someone with a degree in History I'm genuinely sick right now.
You are historically illiterate. Your reckless comparison does the exact thing people claim to hate: it cheapens the Holocaust until the word “Nazi” just means “people I dislike this week.”
Nazis did not “go full Nazi minus a few dozen IQ points.” They built a one-party racial state that passed the Nuremberg Laws, ghettoized entire populations, ran mobile killing squads, then constructed an industrial system whose explicit purpose was the physical elimination of Jews as a people. Six million Jews. Plus millions of others. Gas chambers, crematoria, Wannsee, the works. It is a documented program of annihilation carried out by a government that had abolished elections, independent courts, and a free press.
ICE is a federal law-enforcement agency created in 2003 to enforce statutes Congress already passed. It detains and deports people who entered or remained in the country illegally. You can argue the statutes are too harsh, the facilities are poorly run, due process is insufficient, or family separations were cruel. Those are policy fights.They are not the Final Solution. Treating deportation of illegal entrants as equivalent to Auschwitz is not moral seriousness; it is category error. States have always controlled borders. The Third Reich’s project was the destruction of a people inside the territory it already controlled.
MAGA is a political coalition and a slogan. It has won elections, lost elections, and will do both again. It has not passed racial citizenship laws, built death camps, or launched a war of extermination. Calling it “full Nazi” is the same rhetorical inflation that once got applied to Bush, then Obama, then Trump, then whoever is next. Historians like myself who actually work on 1933–45 get sick of watching the unique features of that regime get flattened into a generic insult.
The Bosnia suggestion is simply better history. The Bosnian War produced ethnic cleansing, rape camps, and the Srebrenica massacre, over 8,000 Bosniak men and boys murdered in a few days after the UN “safe area” collapsed. That is a late 20th century European case of identity based mass killing that a Jewish family raised on Holocaust stories could reasonably experience as “it is happening again.” It keeps Erik Jewish, keeps the intergenerational trauma, and does not require pretending that American immigration enforcement is Treblinka.
If the goal is a younger Magneto who still has a historically grounded reason to conclude that humans will eventually try to wipe out the “other,” Bosnia in the early ’90s is a far more coherent transplant than grafting him onto current U.S. interior enforcement. The Holocaust origin works because the crime was civilizational in scale and intent. Swap it for something that does not match that scale and you don’t modernize the character. You make his extremism look unhinged instead of tragically overdetermined.
Use analogies that survive contact with reality or don’t use them.
Exactlky. Unless Ian McKellan is planning to live to a healthy 120 its not gonna work. Either that or you have to keep setting the movie in the 20th century.
I'd be up for it but only if they have the level of on-screen eroticism of Michael Fassbender and James McAvoy. Maybe we can get that Andrew Garfield-Michael B Jordan interracial bisexuality going on
19
u/ElkDue4803 8h ago
I mean it was a question of time no?
If Magneto was even BORN in 1945 he would be 81, if you want him to have lived through it, he would have to be 90 atleast.
So the answer is either timetravel Magneto 40 years or set the story in the 80es and since they cant to both in the MCU...
Would be cool to make Magneto a victim of a new tragedy but then he would 99% not be white and wow imagine the reactions to an arab/african/asian/south American Magneto