r/okbuddycinephile 10h ago

A creative decision you can't wait people to be completely chill and normal about?

Post image
5.0k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

31

u/Daedalus_Machina 8h ago

You realize that the only reason they do that is the insane level of demand, right?

3

u/longtimegoneMTGO 3h ago

People seem to forget that they have tried making new original super heroes many, many times.

They tend to fail so badly that they end up forgotten, their books dropped and replaced with rebooted versions of characters people actually liked.

At the heart of it, it helps to remember that they have made a shit ton of super heroes over the years, and only a tiny fraction of those have actually succeeded in connecting with people and becoming popular.

The comic book industry was never particularly good with coming up with compelling characters, they were just well positioned to take a shotgun strategy, blasting out a bunch and making more of what worked.

The first 10 years of comics had well over 300 different heroes introduced. How many of those could you name now?

2

u/Daedalus_Machina 1h ago

Familiarity is a powerful force. This is where ancient myth comes from. Fresh and new is great, but even reconfigured familiar things work better than new things.

1

u/longtimegoneMTGO 59m ago

Probably not a big coincidence that the super heroes that got the most traction have some solid thematic ties to ancient myths themselves.

1

u/Dirk_Kempthorne 5h ago

There certainly is a demand for age old super heros but I would argue the rise of Japanese Manga in popularity proves that most people are fed up with characters from before the 1980's.

1

u/Daedalus_Machina 1h ago

I doubt it. Even in Japanese Manga/Anime, you're still looking at a dozen powerhouse names among a sea of plebs. One Piece and Naruto and Inuyasha are going to have many, many retellings in the next 50 years.

-5

u/MugenHeadNinja 8h ago

Demand is not an excuse, Capitalism is just continuing to plague humanity and creativity as it always has.

4

u/Asholootleigh 6h ago

You're right, even if it's an unpopular opinion.

People demand sugar in all their food, tastes good. People say it's unhealthy, and that eating too much will raise societal stress, particularly on health care. "Who cares?" the people will say, "I want my candy!". The capitalist comes in and delivers cheap mass-produced candy.

The people respond: "I love capitalism. Why shouldn't he be allowed to profit on my desires and provide me with them? The health care failing is the liberal gay immigrant transistors fault."

Downvote.

1

u/Daedalus_Machina 1h ago

You're talking about a health issue and comparing it to popular fiction. It's not unhealthy to have preferences in media.

Even in your example, you could defeat or reduce sugar in foods by sweeping changes in both demand and competition.

1

u/Daedalus_Machina 6h ago

How do you figure? If someone doesn't fill a demand, someone else will.

1

u/VirtuallyUnstoppable 5h ago

All them downvotes, yet it's the hard truth. Godspeed.