r/Philanthropy • u/jcravens42 • 2m ago
Commentary on Philanthropy Roundup of articles about in-kind donations being thrown away & why cash donations are always going to be fundamentally important.
NOT saying that in-kind donations to charities are always wrong. In-kind donations are NOT at all always wrong. Donating to Goodwill means you help raise funds for their job training programs. Donating to ReStores means you help fund home building, homeowner education for underserved populations, neighborhood clean ups and more.
And, yes, there are some nonprofits that can make use of in-kind donations not to sell, but to donate to others in need. One of my favorite is Community Warehouse in Oregon, which does a masterful job of both managing donations (and they are very picky) and partnering with nonprofits to get clients (you can't just walk in without a referral) - reduces waste, helps keep warehouse inventory manageable and better ensures equity. This nonprofits Facebook page is one of my favorites as an example of excellent community outreach and awareness-buildiing. Many refugee agencies right in your own community are probably looking for furniture donations, but they are often looking for specific items, ones they can pick up and immediately deliver to a family that is moving into an apartment - they usually have zero storage space for such items.
So, yes, hurrah, in-kind donations.
But to those who say that in-kind donations are better than cash donations for nonprofits and that this is a "trend" that needs to be expanded, here are some articles that say otherwise (and I know so many nonprofit folks are nodding in agreement - in-kind donations don't pay staff, don't pay utility bills, don't pay for the copier rental, and on and on).
Your clothing donations are piling up in landfills and are being sold overseas. From Emory Wheel.
Why more clothes donated to charity are going in the garbage. From the CBC/Radio-Canada, Canada's public broadcaster.
Donation Dumping: The Hidden Harm to Nonprofits and the Environment. From CareIt.
The Second Disaster: Why Goodwill Goes Bad in a Disaster Zone. From Team Rubicon USA.
When In-Kind Donations Are Not Kind. From The Center for Disaster Philanthropy.
Why Cash Donations Help Food Banks More. From Feeding America.
Why Cash Donations are So Valuable to Food Banks. Los Angeles Regional Food Bank.
If anyone has an article about the keys to success for a charity that is based on in-kind, donations, by all means, post it. Or if you work at such a nonprofit and want to share your best practices (how you deal with donation bottlenecks, storage, inappropriate donations, refusing donations. after-hours dumping, equitable distribution, identifying who gets what, etc.), by all means, share it, since that is as much about managing philanthropy as what software to use to manage cash donations and how to properly engage volunteers.