Ok, just another post on this subject. Hoping you all can just help with a sanity check.
I've played a good amount of guitar in my life so am probably intermediate there but probably only advanced beginner on piano, around level 5 of the Alfred books, having taking lessons bi-weekly since pandemic. I tried a local jazz ensemble class in the local community college but felt a bit overwhelmed with everyone else's knowledge of the genre. That said, the format was quite clear. Comp on a song, meaning finding the right times to lay out or to play on beats 2 and 4, find non-clashing chord voicing, primarily right-hand accompaniment, and solo over the head or whatever when it was my turn. Tough but made sense.
I recently joined a classic rock band to play keys. They've got 2 guitars, bass, and drums. These guys play some Bowie, Beatles, Cream, Grateful Dead, etc. I have a pretty cheap Casiotone keyboard. It's got 600 tones. I think I struggle with not only playing but also with the tones, playing just piano until now. I pretty much switch between an electric piano sound and rock organ.
Ok- my question is how much to play? If doing I Am the Walrus, it sounds good holding down an organ sound with whole notes, perhaps with the triad, just on one hand. Great. But songs that don't have original key parts, say something like Taxman or Day Tripper. Just plink on 2 and 4 with a piano tone on the verse, maybe hold down chords on chorus? Or on a Dead song... just chords in a higher register? Maybe find some space to do a little riff if guitar isn't playing? I guess I'm having impostor syndrome. I'm hardly doing anything on a lot of songs, especially 12 bar blues type songs... while guitarists are wailing away, drummer is laying it down, bassist has a groove going, singer is killing it.... I keep reading to just stay out of the way as to not muddy it up. Is that what I should expect going forward?
Sorry for the rant and thanks for reading. Just not sure if I should expect, or try, something different.