r/riverdale • u/Nina9969 • 1h ago
RANT Not-so-hot take: Polly is the most tragic character in the whole show Spoiler
THIS WAS A COMMENT BEFORE!!! I just thought that this is so insane, I HAD to share my realization with y'all
At the start of season 5 I was like "this girl has been THROUGH it! I'm sure they'll just leave her alone now"
Bffr, all her plotlines were based on pure INSANITY
But NOOO they had to do her dirty again and actually KILL HER OFF in the most gruesome of ways.
Like give this bitch a break
Season 1, she got pregnant at 16 BY HER COUSIN whom she was in love with. Did I also mention he was murdered by his own father? Anyways. Not only that, but her own parents locked her up in an illegal asylum, where she had no idea that "the love of her life"/ LITERAL COUSIN was murdered.
Then, in season 2 it turns out that her father is a serial killer (aka has been living with a psychopath for over 16 years). Her older brother shows up, and it's then proven that he is infact NOT her brother but the person who "killed" her actual brother
In season 3 she is manipulated and brainwashed by a CULT that is not only a cult, but also an underground system of human and organ trafficking. The brainwashing leads to her practically hating her own sister and dragging her mother who's also a secret FBI agent down with her. If this isn't bad, tell me what is!
And ofc that's NOT ALL, cause in season 4 her ACTUAL brother shows up, and on top of all the gathered up trauma she has experienced over the last few years, guess WHAT? Her actual brother, Charles is ALSO a serial killer, and is infact DATING her fake brother whom she thought was killed by her father (again, SERIAL KILLER) in season 2.
And then. The final blow
Now being a single mother, and a young adult who still lives with her mother in a town that has no future whatsoever, she starts working as a prostitute in what I can only describe as the most creepy highway in the history of television. She is then BRUTALLY murdered, leaving her 7 year old twins and products of accidental incest completely orphaned, and under the care of her mother, Alice, who is also high-key mentally unstable!! Alice is not only equally traumatized, but has also lost 2 kids.
Like the nightmares of this poor girl are endless!!
I'm not a supporter of suicide, of course, but if I were Polly, I'd be gone WAY earlier.
You can't convince me that she isn't the most tragic character in the entirety of Riverdale
BTW thanks for reading all of this.

