r/samuraijack • u/zuzmuz • 12h ago
Discussion Finally watched season 5, here's my opinion
Might be late to the party, but just binged watched all of samurai jack (yes the entirety of the 5 seasons).
Ok so to begin with, I really loved season 5, it was truly an upgrade. If you rewatch the first 4 seasons you notice that the episodes feel quite repetitive revolving around 3 main themes (Jack trying to find a way to the get to the past and failing, meeting people and helping them out befriending them, and fighting bounty hunters) so it can get quite boring.
To start with the positive, I loved the art style and animation, it was loyal to the series and modern at the same time.
The first 3 episodes were amazing, but, like many, I found the ending a bit disappointing, I didn't hate it, but compared to the beginning of the season, where the pacing and the storytelling was on point, it felt rushed and way less impactful.
The pacing was very good for the first 3 episodes. The way they built up to the moment of his first human kill was amazing, and they way it affected him was very impactful. Combined with the fact that Jack was already tormented and on the verge of breaking and committing suicide, it truly gave a twist worthy of a finale to the Samurai Jack saga.
The 4th episode is where the cracks started showing in the storytelling, it was still fine, but not on the same level as the first 3 episodes. I knew that 1 of the sisters will survive and that it would be Ashi, it makes sense from a storytelling perspective, it's simpler. It's way more complicated otherwise, you wouldn't have time to explore the different characters in depth. Plus, you need another character to break the cycle; Jack couldn't defeat Aku, and Aku couldn't defeat Jack, having a new character tied to both was a smart choice as a plot device.
I feel they didn't properly explore Ashi's character. Jack and Ashi' relationship being a very important narrative, I felt it needed a bit more depth to be convincing. I didn't mind the romance though. I've seen many opinions online that they wanted their relationship to be a mentor/apprentice one rather than a romantic one, I disagree, a romantic relationship is way more impactful, it can be a turning point in someone's life. It can give back purpose when hope is lost. I believe Jack deserved it somehow, all his journey, he was a loner. Everybody needs somebody, sometimes, even someone as strong and determined as Samurai Jack. My problem is that they didn't explore it properly. It felt rushed, forced, and awkward instead of satisfying.
Ok so my first problem; we needed a more compelling reason why she decides not to kill him. It happened very quickly. Jack was being tormented for 3 episodes, the pacing was on point. She just lost her sisters, and had her whole worldview shattered, and made a character flip in just 1 episode, it was too quick, the pacing was off. They could've explored more the good in her, or made her confused for longer, having to fight her internal demons like Jack. Them journeying together and him showing her the evil of Aku to convince her felt silly.
I loved the episode where she travels alone and meets Jack's friends (for nostalgia reasons) even though the rave song was so cringe.
The biggest problem was episode 7. I found her fighting the orc army completely useless. I loved the plotline of Jack meditating and regaining his sword back, and the contrast with the fight. But, in my opinion, she should've been fighting her mother the whole time. It would have been way more compelling. They could've used this episode to make her flip. Imagine having your whole worldview shattered, and killing your mother this simply without really question it, it doesn't really make sense. It would make way more sense if she goes through the same journey as Jack; he faces his mad self in order to gain his sword back, and she does the same; hate her own past, her upbringing, her mother and at that moment decide to save Jack, kill her mother, then fall in love with him. I also didn't like that Jack regained his past look. I loved the look at the beginning of the season, it really showed someone who's in despair and stopped caring about himself, I understand he needed a new look after regaining his sword back, but, I really wished he kept a trimmed beard; it would've been way cooler, and maybe showed better character growth, having a 3rd version of Jack, one that regained hope, and became stronger.
To recap, episodes 4,5,6,7 were ok. Maybe we needed more time on Ashi's internal conflict.
I found episode 8 to be funny. Yes, it was awkward with the sexual innuendos and how they fell in love, but hey, romance is awkward. I didn't really mind this episode in particular, it's maybe the past episodes that made this one seem awkward. If they built it properly, they could leave episode 8 as it is and it would've been great.
While watching episode 8, I checked the episode number and thought to myself "Oh my god, there's only 2 episodes left how are they gonna resolve the story properly" and 'spoiler alert', they didn't. I really wish there was 1 more episode.
Ok so, I love the idea they were behind, but not the execution. As cliché as it might seem, the idea that Jack needed the power of friendship, and more specifically, love, to finish his quest, is a beautiful ending to the story. Because, even for someone as strong as Jack, you can't do it alone. But before continuing, let's address the elephant in the room; the guardian of the portal. I remember as a kid this episode, and it really impacted me, and during watching season 5, I was waiting to see how they will address it. And honestly, I missed it, I blinked for a second, and didn't notice that the red glasses were referring the portal guardian. That was disappointing. I knew from a storytelling point of view that him returning to the past required Ashi, it's definitely way more compelling that way, but everything felt very rushed at this point. However, I actually loved the plot twist where Aku controls Ashi and Jack saves her by telling her "I love you". People might disagree, it might be "corny" but if he said anything else would've been cornier. It needed to be personal at this point, if Jack said something like "Even if you have darkness inside of you, it's not what defines you" or any other wise thing, it would've been weak. He needed to express what she means to him, how she gave him hope again, how he couldn't stand seeing her lose herself to darkness. If you've ever experienced someone telling you "I love you" very deeply and sincerely you know how this affects you; loves makes us do crazy things. I think if they built up their relationship better, and explored Ashi's inner struggle better, this moment would have been way more impactful.
And finally, let's address the last 5 minutes of the last episode. These last 5 minutes are possibly one of the most rushed 5 minutes in the history of television. These 5 minutes alone could been explored in 2 episodes. I wished season 5 had 13 episodes like the first 4 seasons. We all knew, that eventually he would return to the past, and it makes sense that Ashi would help him, being Aku's daughter. It's not a bad ending in theory, actually it's the best one, again in theory, but for the love of God, why did they rush it this way. Let's go back to the second episode, where Jack kills the first daughter of Aku and we see blood spilling for the first time. See how impactful this moment was? It was impactful because, we've been watching 4 seasons of him destroying robots and never spilling red blood. It was impactful because earlier on, he was comforting himself by saying 'they're just nuts and bolts, they're just nuts and bolts'. They took the time, through 2 full episodes, and 1 more to show us the impact on him. Really the pacing was perfect. Then in the final episode, he tells Ashi he loves her, she takes back control of herself, notices she has the powers of Aku, goes back in time, Jack defeats Aku, they prepare to get married, and then she disappears, in freaking 5 minutes, all of this happens.
I don't really care about her disappearing and him not getting a full happy ending. Everything at this point would've felt weak and unsatisfying. I really needed an episode where he fights Aku, in the future, defeats him, with the help of his friends, the scotsman, everyone else, and specially Ashi, a climactic battle. Then he enjoys the victory with everyone, and finally he's confronted with the choice of leaving everyone and going back to the past, because of the obligation to his family. He sadly leaves all of his friends behind, and goes to the past with Ashi. When he kills Aku in the past, at that moment, Ashi disappears. It would've been a better bittersweet ending than what we got.
Finally, I really enjoyed the season, it got me hooked, and i think the reason why people are angry about the ending, is because they did a really good job in the first couple of episodes. There was so much potential, and the ending wasn't theoretically bad, it was the right ending in my opinion, but it was rushed.
For anyone who read everything and got to the end, thank you for sticking around. I really wanted to get this out of my system.