r/trains 12h ago

r/Trains Monthly Discussion & Questions Thread - September 2026

3 Upvotes

Welcome to the r/Trains Monthly Discussion Thread.

The goal of this thread is to serve as the place to ask short questions or just chat about anything trains related that might not warrant its own post.


r/trains Mar 22 '26

๐Ÿš‚r/trains staff announcement Introduction & updates to moderating, rules and sidebar.

11 Upvotes

Hello there,

I am auto, your new friendly neighbourhood Reddit mod. o/

While I have some experience moderating smaller communities, I've never moderated a subreddit before and never a community of this size and honestly, taking the right moderating actions when reviewing reports or looking through comments isn't quite coming naturally yet. If I make any silly mistakes or you believe I didn't deal with situation correctly, do not hesitate to tell me either via mod mail or in the discord. I am human, I am not going to deal with every situation perfectly and feedback is more than welcome. (Just kidding, I am obviously a robot ๐Ÿค– - Beep Boop Beep)

I am happy to be at your service.

Regardless, now that the introduction is over with, there is some practical stuff to discuss:

Bans, Ban appeals and old Mod Mail:

When I came in, there was a very large backlog in Mod Mail, including ban appeals. I have cleared this backlog the best I could, responding to most appeals and messages that came in, but unfortunately, once these appeals and Mod Mails reach about half a year old, they can no longer be replied to from our side.

If you sent in a ban appeal or question that is still relevant before July 2025 and it never got answered, please do not hesitate to send us a message through Mod Mail and me or the other mods will get to it.

In addition, I found out that some people who at any point received disciplinary action ended up in some sort of ghost-ban, where on our end in the mod tools panel the person doesn't appear to be banned, but when the user tries to post, it tells them they're banned. If you were active in r/Trains more than 5 years ago, Reddit tells you that you're banned when you try to post or comment and you have no clue why or when you got banned, please contact the mods via Mod Mail and we should be able to resolve your issue.

Mod Queue clearing:

I have cleared the Mod Queue, which was filled with over 3 years of reports, removals and filtered content. For the queue items from the last 1-2 weeks I've done this manually, and then I've mass-cleared most of the remaining queue. This process caused all filtered posts that were more than roughly 10 days old to be discarded. If you made any post more than 10 days ago which got automatically filtered and you believe the content is still relevant, feel free to reattempt posting your comment.

Moderating strategy and rules:

Due to the relatively sparse activity of moderators on this subreddit in recent times, moderating turned into a very hands-off process where y'all mostly self-moderate with some assistance from automatic filters. Beyond the filters sometimes getting overzealous, especially with politically contentious posts, (which should be resolved now,) this has generally worked fairly well. For now, though I can't speak for the other moderators when they act, I will carry this approach forward.

However, that may change. From working through the queue, Mod Mail and immediately finding myself in the deep end with several contentious posts appearing right after I got promoted, it's become obvious that the current rules don't always quite match the way action has been taken on reports both before I came in and at current. In addition, it turns out that some situations really aren't covered well by our current rules and that the wording of some rules may be contributing to a sizable amount of reports coming in for contact that very much is allowed here. We've also received feedback from several people, both via Mod Mail and in comments under recent topics about how we should be dealing with politics and controversial content on the subreddit.

Keeping all those things in mind, I will be rewriting the rules over the coming days. As part of this process, me or other moderators may place community polls both on reddit and on discord to gather feedback for how the community would like the r/trains discord and subreddit to be moderated.

Monthly discussion thread:

Until now, the monthly discussion thread was automatically generated on the 29th of every month. Beyond causing the month in the topic title to nearly always mismatch the current month, this caused the thread not to be generated in February. Starting on April 1st, the monthly discussion thread will be automatically generated on the 1st of every month instead. Until then, please feel free to continue using the January 2026 thread.

Sidebar:

We are aware the gallery in the sidebar has broken. Sadly, most images gone poof and we have no record of what exactly was in there. As we look to fill our sidebar once again, we may request permission for some people to use their photos in the side-bar via Mod Mail, but if you'd like to help, if you are posting original content, you can now use the "๐Ÿ“ธ May be used in side-bar gallery" post flair to indicate to us that we may place your photo or art in the sidebar.

With all that said, thank you for reading.

~auto


r/trains 6h ago

๐Ÿ“ฐ News These photos and videos from the Big Boy 4014 Coast to Coast tour show just how miserable the experience was

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

318 Upvotes

Original Creator: Fallen Flag Fan
Video Link: https://youtu.be/0qNEy8rsBZ8?is=iaJrJvezhx6DCNpU


r/trains 4h ago

๐Ÿ“ธ OC - Picture(s) CSX 1973 (Chessie System)

Thumbnail
gallery
150 Upvotes

CSXโ€™s Chessie System heritage unit made its first appearance in the Springfield, MO area today. This is the fourth CSX heritage unit I have caught (the other three are 1900, 1836 and 1875) and this one ranks near the top of my list out of the 21; however, itโ€™s also probably the unit that pisses me off the most because it would look phenomenal if the entire locomotive was in the Chessie scheme rather than the cab being in regular CSX colors.


r/trains 1h ago

๐Ÿ›๏ธโ€Ž Historical Polish pre-war steam locomotive Pm36

Post image
โ€ข Upvotes

The Pm36-1 steam locomotive (Pablok 1937, "Beautiful Polka") is an aerodynamic express steam locomotive with a 2-3-1 axle arrangement (Pacifik), awarded a gold medal at the World Exhibition in Paris. Its aerodynamic, dark blue steel casing was developed at the Warsaw University of Technology, reducing air resistance by 30-40% and allowing it to reach a design speed of 140 km/h (142 km/h in tests). The streamlined casing covered the wheels and mechanisms to a height of 25 cm above the rail, and access was provided by sliding doors and shutters. The wedge-shaped driver's cabin was integrated into the boiler line, improving visibility. The 1,800 hp engine had a twin superheated steam engine, a boiler with a pressure of 18 atm, a heating area of โ€‹โ€‹191 mยฒ, and a grate of 4.5 mยฒ. The overall length of the unit was 24.75 m, and the driving wheels had an impressive diameter of 2,000 mm (rolling wheels: front 1,000 mm, rear 1,200 mm). The locomotive itself weighed 88.4 t (empty) and 105.8 t in service, and with the type 32D36 tender (holding 32 mยณ of water and 9 t of coal), its total weight was 167.3 t.


r/trains 5h ago

โ“ What is this Train? Is this train from the video game Expedition 33 based on a real locomotive?

Post image
164 Upvotes

I hope that kind of question is allowed. This is a 3D render from the game Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 by Carla Devรฉze (artstation page), and I was curious whether or not if this is a real train - I looked at French trains from the timeframe of the game (about 1880-1910) but couldn't find any equivalent, though admittedly my knowledge is limited.

And if it's not a real train, what would be the closest existing locomotive? Thanks in advance!


r/trains 9h ago

๐Ÿ“ธ OC - Picture(s) Typical Swiss train formation

Post image
185 Upvotes

SBB is well known for having driving cabs and/or locomotives halfway a train, as well as mixing single and double decker cars. This train in Olten featured all of above.


r/trains 3h ago

๐Ÿ“ฐ News Severn Valley Railway begins trial of commuter services (Bewdley, UK)

Thumbnail
bbc.com
42 Upvotes

Despite living in the US, I am excited by this. I've always wondered if this was possible, regardless of location. I know you have to meet some modern standards, especially if they run on the mainline, but this arrangement is possible in some places. If this is successful, the Keighley and Worth Valley or even the West Somerset could form a partnership like this. I think the Swanage Railway does operate the occasional commuter service, but I'm not sure. Regardless, I am hopeful that this works out.


r/trains 4h ago

๐Ÿ“ธ OC - Picture(s) - May be used in side-bar gallery Diet Coke for Scale (Tampa, FL)

Thumbnail
gallery
42 Upvotes

My new job has me nearby a shunting yard. thankful to appreciate the scale of these things.


r/trains 2h ago

๐Ÿ“น OC - Video A250 Locomotives, Box Cars and a Caboose leaving Spencer Monday Afternoon

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

35 Upvotes

We shoved all the locomotives, box cars and the caboose Sunday evening to the NS yard in Spencer. NS picked them up Monday afternoon.


r/trains 10h ago

๐Ÿ“ฐ News USA Class 1 Railroads by Year

Post image
116 Upvotes

r/trains 6h ago

๐Ÿ›๏ธโ€Ž Historical Steam excursions preserved a long way from home:

Thumbnail
gallery
58 Upvotes

r/trains 17m ago

๐Ÿ›๏ธโ€Ž Historical What's that US railroad merger what-if that fascinates you the most?

Post image
โ€ข Upvotes

For me, it's basically: What if the SP regained its footing and was never folded into Union Pacific?


r/trains 9h ago

๐Ÿ›๏ธโ€Ž Historical Ex-Conrail SD60I, C40-8W, & High Hood GP38-2 take on the streets of Warsaw, IN in 2010

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

68 Upvotes

Clip from "2010 Midwestern Review in HD"

Footage by Chris Wehman


r/trains 3h ago

โ“ Question Mixed passengers / goods trains

Post image
18 Upvotes

Hi there!

Iโ€™m getting more and more fond of historical mixed goods and passengers trains and looking for pictures and documentation about them, from all over the world (both historical and current).

This kind of trains doesnโ€™t exist anymore in my country (France), but were common on small local lines. If Iโ€™mโ€™correct, they still exist in Switzerland at least (on Rhb network).

As an example, here you have an A 80 D, built by the French manufacturer ร‰tablissements Billard (now defunct), which can often be seen towing small good trailers on the metric CFD lines (pictures here with a RM30 mail car).

So, if you have any knowledge, pictures or stories to share about such trains, Iโ€™ll be more than happy to see/read them!

Picture: Wikimedia/Didier Duforest (CC-SA)


r/trains 13h ago

๐Ÿ“ธ OC - Picture(s) - May be used in side-bar gallery Old NS U-Boat and some old conrail plus an extra BNSF train and an old SOO Line grain car

Thumbnail
gallery
93 Upvotes

Bought by an excursion railroad near me, WER or "Washington Eastern Railroad"

They use these units to service the grain silo nearby

The further back units are the old conrail units

7363 and 7320 while 538 is the Northfolk Southern U-Boat before it was bought by WER and maybe rebuilt because the nose isn't right for a U-Boat


r/trains 9h ago

๐Ÿ“ฐ News Montreal to Toronto at 200 km/hr

Thumbnail
ryanhansson.substack.com
32 Upvotes

r/trains 6h ago

๐Ÿ“ธ OC - Picture(s) eastern switzerland

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/trains 7h ago

๐Ÿ•น๏ธโ€Ž Video Game Related I added trains to my road builder / traffic management game, and they take a lot of the cars off the roads they run alongside

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

18 Upvotes

I am working on a road builder / traffic management game called Traffic Architect. New districts keep appearing on the map by themselves - you never place one and you never zone anything - and everything you build is the network that has to reach them and carry what they generate. They fill your roads with cars until the roads choke, and trains are how you take that load back off.

A train carries far more people than a bus does, for less upkeep per seat, so one busy line does what a fleet of buses can't. Every line is set to carry passengers, freight, or both, and that choice turned out to be the most interesting thing in the whole system. Goods stops are slow. People walk on and off while the doors are open; a container has to be craned across, and the train stands there for it.

The catch is what a combined line is worth on paper. Nobody is assigned to a line here - every trip compares riding against driving and picks - and the estimate a rider goes on has to assume the long stop everywhere, because the line might get away with a short one but nobody can count on it. So declaring a line combined costs you commuters before a single crate turns up. The train itself only pays the long dwell where it really does goods work, but the schedule people plan around never knows that in advance. It's the honest price of keeping the option open, and it means a dedicated line beats a hedged one without any rule saying so. Going freight-only pays you back with a longer train, since a boxcar rake doesn't have to fit a platform.

Metro is underground, and it's passenger-only. You can't work goods through a tunnel station, so a line that touches one is locked to passengers until you take that stop out.

Changing trains costs time, and how much depends on the platform rather than on the station. Two lines standing at the same track is a step across, however grand the building around it. Two platforms means an underpass or a bridge. A hybrid station, with surface trains above and metro below, is the slowest, because you're going up or down. That time is priced in before anyone decides to travel, so a slow interchange can lose you a connection that looked fine on the map.

Level crossings included - the barriers close on where the train physically is rather than on a timer, and they only lift once the tail is clear. The part I like is that the car routing counts the expected barrier wait as a cost, so a road over a busy line becomes less attractive and traffic drifts onto the roads that don't cross it.

Coming to Steam this autumn, with a free demo before that: https://store.steampowered.com/app/5028050/Traffic_Architect/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=level_crossings&utm_content=trains


r/trains 22h ago

๐Ÿ“ธ OC - Picture(s) - May be used in side-bar gallery America 250 Locomotive Celebration @ NC Transportation Museum, Spencer NC

Thumbnail
gallery
229 Upvotes

We were lucky enough to attend this amazing event!


r/trains 10h ago

๐Ÿ“ธ OC - Picture(s) Triangula D-TRG 60 80 99-01 501, 25.5.2025 (D) Chemnitz-Hilbersdorf.

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Triangula D-TRG 60 80 99-01 501-8 Wohnschlafwagen (Begleiterwagen 662) am 25.5.2025 im Sรคchsischen Eisenbahnmuseum Bahnbetriebswerk Hilbersdorf in Chemnitz.

ex 50 50 21-11 298-3 Bmhย 


r/trains 1h ago

๐Ÿ“น OC - Video Need suggestions/advice for thumbnails

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

โ€ข Upvotes

I do some railfanning vids (very fledgling channel so far, 150 subs). I was curious what kind of thumbnail would garner more clicks. I've got at least 3 vids up now. Two of which feature a NFS engine in the thumbnail and those have done meagerly to say the least. Maybe 50ish or barely 100 views. I did one vid about the Northeast Regional and featured the train in question as the thumbnail. That got over 1000 views. Do people have a preference when they click on vids? Or is it just algorithm crap and a roll of the dice on what works?

Also this video isn't on the channel yet, will be featured in January 2027 as part of a new compilation I'm working on. Crescent rolling through Norcross, GA fyi


r/trains 14h ago

๐Ÿ“น OC - Video Wheel slip

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

41 Upvotes

r/trains 1d ago

๐Ÿ“น OC - Video Saxon IV K steam locomotive 99 585 on Schwarzbachbahn in Germany

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

675 Upvotes

r/trains 1d ago

๐Ÿ“ธ OC - Picture(s) Rainy California Zephyr

Post image
305 Upvotes

Amtrak 92 leads the California Zephyr eastbound by San Pablo Bay, January 2000.

Canon A-1
Canon FD 55mm ฦ’1.2
Ektachrome E100S.