I’m in my early 20s and potentially choosing between two permanent full-time opportunities in completely different areas. I’m curious what people with more career experience would do.
Job A is an account/operations coordination role.
It pays roughly €7–10k more, is predominantly remote and has a very good benefits package. The work involves coordinating accounts, keeping processes moving, dealing with issues, tracking progress and communicating between different internal teams.There’s also potential progression into things like account management, operations, customer success, service delivery or project-based roles.The major downside is that the working hours are later than a normal office job, so I’d sacrifice most of my weekday evenings.
Job B is an entry-level Recruitment Consultant position. It pays less initially but has normal office hours and a hybrid working arrangement. I’d be managing candidates through the recruitment process, interviewing/screening people, following up with them and getting them ready to start work. It’s also performance-based with individual/team targets.
This is where I’m struggling with the decision:
I’ve actually been thinking about getting into recruitment/HR for a while.
I enjoy talking to people and I think the relationship-building side would suit me. However, I don’t have an HR/recruitment degree or direct recruitment experience, and I’ve found that a lot of jobs in the area want previous experience. So part of me feels like being offered an opportunity to enter recruitment without already having that background is something I shouldn’t dismiss, because once I have experience I could potentially progress into senior recruitment, talent acquisition, HR-related roles etc.
On the other hand, Job A is objectively the stronger offer financially. It pays considerably more from day one, has better benefits and is more flexible. The operations/account-management route also seems to have plenty of progression, so I’m wondering whether I’m overvaluing recruitment simply because I’ve previously considered getting into it.
I’m not particularly attached to either job title. I’m mainly trying to make the decision that gives me the best combination of earning potential, career progression, job security and quality of life over the next 3–5 years.
If you were starting out in your career, would you:
A) take the significantly better-paying operations/account role and build a career from there
or
B) accept less money to get your foot in the door of recruitment/HR because it’s an area you’ve already been interested in?
I’d especially love to hear from anyone who’s worked in recruitment/HR or account management/operations. What does progression and earning potential actually look like a few years in?