r/wiedzmin • u/ChyatlovMaidan • 4h ago
Books Actual Silver Sword Appearances
Just finished reading the series for the first time. Not the prequel novels yet, those are next, but the 1990s 'original' saga, The Last Wish through to Lady of the Lake (no one asked, but: pretty good series, liked the last book in particular, thought Time of Contempt dragged and that Ciri goes through a bit too much 90s 'not your father's fantasy genre' abuse, but I loved the character work, Justice for the Rescue Ciri Gang)
Anyways: like everyone else who came into the series primarily knowing the games (I played 1 and 2, a chunk of 3, and decided I really needed to read the books to understand 3 better, Geralt is 'the two swords' guy: Witchers carry two swords at all times, steel for men, silver for monsters. Except, as book readers know, Geralt doesn't just walk around with that silver sword, he stores it on his horse, but it got me wondering in the original saga how often that silver sword actually shows up.
By my count the silver sword makes an appearance in three of the short stories in The Last Wish (The Witcher, The Grain of Truth, and The Last Wish), and is also in the framing story (The Voice of Reason). Geralt also wields the sword in Something More in Sword of Destiny. Silver swords are referenced as a way to fight several monsters during Ciri's lessons in Chapter 3 in Blood of Elves, but I don't think past that point silver swords are even mentioned again. Geralt get the sihil from Zohan in Blood Baptism, and uses that more-or-less exclusively until the end of Lady of the Lake: if he even has a silver sword on him at the start of Blood, he doubtless loses it along with one of the Roaches in his many tribulations and not only never regains it but never has a chance to do so (I imagine it's an expensive pain). A quick words search of Storms and Ravens shows the silver swords show up those two, which I won't treat as a spoiler because of course they do, buts its the 90s saga that interests me.
Am I off in my calculations? Does Geralt not wield a silver sword in any of the original Blood-to-Lake novels? Did I miss something somewhere? His medallion is silver, and his armor silver-studded (and there's bewitching silver eyes), but I didn't see a silver sword show up again in any form after Ciri's lessons. Anyone know if I got that right?