Am I the jerk for completely cutting off a friend after years of feeling manipulated, used, and constantly walking on eggshells around her?
I’m a university student, and I’ve been friends with this girl for quite a while. Over time, I’ve reached the point where I genuinely don’t like being around her anymore and I want to end the friendship completely.
There wasn’t just one huge incident. It’s been a pattern of things building up for a long time.
One of the biggest problems was university. At one point, she took a piece of work that I had written and used it for her own university work. It became an academic issue. She received a warning, and thankfully the instructor understood that I had nothing to do with what she had done.
What really bothered me was what happened afterwards. After we were called in about it, instead of really understanding why I might need some distance after being put in that position, she was upset with me because I didn’t come and sit with her afterwards.
After that incident, I actually tried to distance myself from her. When she noticed, she started saying things like, “You’re so difficult when you’re upset,” and posting things about how she was secretly depressed, how nobody knew what she was going through, etc. I felt guilty and eventually went back to being close with her.
I can’t know whether those posts were actually about me, and I don’t want to accuse her of faking depression. She may genuinely have been struggling. But I realised that whenever I tried to create distance, I would end up feeling guilty and responsible for how she felt, and then I would go back to the friendship even though I didn’t really want to.
Academically, she also constantly expects things from me. I study throughout the semester while also juggling university, work, home and family responsibilities. She often doesn’t put in the same effort and then, close to exams, expects me to teach her everything.
She has also pressured me to help her cheat.
She wants my notes and has even expected me to type my handwritten notes into Word because she says she can’t understand my handwriting. It started feeling like the work I had spent the whole semester doing was somehow also my responsibility to prepare for her.
Another thing that bothers me is that she seems to feel entitled to information about me. Every time grades come out, she expects me to tell her exactly what I got. If I don’t want to share my grade, she makes comments implying that I’m weird, mentally unwell, or that I’m scared of the evil eye.
I’m a pretty private person. I keep my family life separate from my friendships. She is the complete opposite. I know an unbelievable amount about her family because she tells me everything: what her siblings like and dislike, what happens between her parents, how many times they argue, problems with relatives, everything.
That is her choice, and I have never had a problem with her choosing to share those things. But sometimes it feels like because she tells me everything, she expects the exact same access to my personal life. I don’t work that way.
She also talks badly about people constantly. Friends, relatives, her sister-in-law, random people — there always seems to be somebody she is criticising behind their back. At some point I started thinking, “If she talks about everyone like this to me, she probably talks about me like this to other people too.”
Even trivial things become exhausting. She believes heavily in things like astrology and signs, such as saying that wearing a certain colour means she will succeed at something. Obviously people are allowed to believe whatever they want, but combined with everything else, I’ve reached the point where even these conversations irritate me because I don’t feel connected to her anymore.
I also really dislike the way she behaves in public. Her phone is constantly on full volume, she talks extremely loudly, her laugh can practically be heard across the building, and she can be rude or aggressive towards strangers over very minor things. If someone asks her something the wrong way, she can snap at them and completely go off on them.
Being outside with her often makes me uncomfortable because I feel like she has very little consideration for the people around her.
There was also something that hurt me a lot regarding our grandmothers.
When her grandmother died, I stayed by her side and supported her throughout the funeral and mourning period because, regardless of the problems in our friendship, I knew she was grieving and I wanted to be there for her.
But the entire time, I kept remembering what happened when my own grandmother died.
When I had tried to talk to her about my grief, instead of comforting me, she made fun of my feelings and basically acted like my grief wasn’t that serious because my grandmother lived in another country.
That hurt me deeply.
After her grandmother’s funeral, she travelled. During the whole time she was away, she barely thought of me or contacted me. Then as soon as she came back, one of the first things she said was basically, “Why haven’t you been talking to me?”
It made me feel like the responsibility for maintaining the friendship was always somehow mine.
There are also smaller incidents that sound stupid when explained individually, but they show what it feels like to interact with her.
Recently at university, we were leaving and I simply asked whether she was going home using a different form of public transport. Normally I take the tram and she takes the bus.
Instead of just answering, she started laughing at me and swearing, saying things like, “Why are you asking me this time? You ALWAYS take the tram. Now suddenly you’re asking me?”
It was such a basic, harmless question, but her tone and the way she spoke to me made me feel so humiliated that I genuinely felt like I was about to cry.
That happens a lot. I can say something completely normal, fail to give her the reaction she wanted, or do something slightly differently than usual, and suddenly I feel like I’ve committed some massive offence.
I feel like I’m constantly walking on eggshells.
I also want to be fair and say that I haven’t handled every situation perfectly either. I’ve gotten angry and said things I regret during arguments, and I’m not claiming that I’m some flawless friend while she has done everything wrong.
But I’ve reached the point where I don’t think the friendship is fixable, and more importantly, I don’t want to fix it.
A few days ago we were supposed to go out together, and I cancelled because we genuinely had guests coming over. But if I’m honest, I was relieved to have a reason not to go. I don’t want to reschedule it.
Right now, I’ve stopped initiating contact. I don’t send her things anymore. I’ve muted her on WhatsApp, Instagram and Snapchat. If she messages me, I usually don’t respond unless it is something genuinely necessary.
The weird part is that even though I’m distancing myself, I still catch myself checking whether she has messaged me and worrying about how she is going to react when she sees me at university.
I think that says a lot about how anxious this friendship has made me.
I’ve forgiven a lot of what happened and I don’t wish anything bad on her. But I’ve realised that forgiving someone doesn’t necessarily mean I have to keep giving them access to me.
I don’t want a reduced friendship. I don’t want to “work things out.” I genuinely want to end the friendship completely and just remain civil if we happen to see each other at university.
I also think part of the reason this friendship has gone on for so long is because I’m genuinely bad at saying no to people.
I struggle a lot with setting boundaries, especially when I know the other person is going to be upset with me. Even when I decide that I want to distance myself from someone, I tend to feel guilty, second-guess myself, and somehow end up back in the same relationship again.
That is basically what happened with her. I’ve tried to pull away before, but the moment she confronted me, got upset, or made me feel like I was hurting her, I gave in and went back to normal.
I know that part is on me. I need to learn how to say no and stand by my decisions instead of constantly trying to keep everyone happy. But I also think that is why ending this friendship feels so difficult to me. It isn’t that I secretly want to stay friends with her. I don’t. I just struggle to tolerate the guilt and conflict that comes with saying, “I don’t want this relationship anymore.”
I’m worried that if I sit down with her for a long conversation, I’ll end up doing exactly what I’ve done before: feeling guilty, apologising, backing down, and somehow walking away still being her friend even though that isn’t what I want.
AITAH for cutting her off entirely rather than sitting down with her and trying to repair the friendship one more time?