Hello! So beneath my sunroom there is some insulation that seems to be installed improperly, and seems to be getting torn apart by an animal or something? There is some plywood which the insulation is attached to by some furring strips. This is below the subfloor of my sunroom. I'm nearly certain my sunroom subfloor already has fiberglass insulation, and this may have been a strategy to increase the r value? The floor isn't noticeably cold in the winter, even in the areas the insulation pictured here has fallen down. Anyway, I reached out to a few different places that came out, and I got 3 quotes with three different strategies.
Quote 1: Remove the fiberglass insulation shown here. That leaves just the plywood that it's attached to. Then Closed Cell Spray Foam 2 inch on plywood subfloor. Cost: ~$1,450.
Quote 2: Remove the fiberglass insulation. Drill 2' holes through plywood. Tube feed nu wool cellulose into floor and plug holes with wood plugs. Cost: $950.
Quote 3: Remove the fiberglass insulation. Remove the plywood. Replace fiberglass insulation in subfloor with closed cell 4" spray foam. Re-attach plywood. Cost: ~$2,800
Quote 3 seems probably like the "best" solution, but quite a bit more money than I wanting to spend. I could also just tear down the fiberglass insulation myself, and see how things feel in the sunroom in the winter, and then decide if I need to take steps to improve the insulation in the floor.
Curious to hear others opinions on how I should proceed?
EDIT: I'm located in southern Michigan.