r/Natalism • u/Mysterious-Ice6304 • 14h ago
Aa a father to 4 children, I think birth rates will continue to decline pretty much no matter what.
Having kids is hard work. Even for a man who doesn't have suffer pregnancy nor breastfeeding, it's just been something that has taken over my life completely.
But i enjoy it. It's the best thing to ever happen to me beyond my wife. I simply wouldn't have it any other way.
Others too, often remark on how happy I look. They're right. I've never been happier. But there's an important prerequisite: I can be happy just watching my kids be happy.
I have very little time for things I enjoy doing as an individual. The kids get first dibs, and then it's my wife. But that's okay, my kids won't need me forever.
For the time being, I derive joy from the dynamic of between my children, watching them enjoy their childhood, live out the realisation of all my aspirations I could only dream of as a child, and step into some really big shoes as they build themselves up piece by piece to hopefully one day become a fantastic grownup.
The thrill I get from when my child accomplishes something they didn't think they could do is unlikely anything I've experienced before. It's truly glorious.
Given this is a natalist forum, I expect many of you here'll know what that feels like. But here's the thing: do you notice many people doing the same?
Taking our kids to a softplay or birthday party, me and my wife are usually the only ones that actually ENJOY watching our kids play. Most parents are either talking amongst themselves, using the opportunity to take a break and crack open a bottle of wine for some nice grownup banter, or even hovering over their child for an inability to let them learn from their mistakes.
I talk to any parent around us, the usual go-to banter is centred around the insufferable hardship of parenting and the joys of "me time" or thinly-veiled boasts on how gifted their child is.
In the midst of all this, my preaching of "80% of the time you spend with your children happens before the age of 11" often has no place.
To be clear; this is not meant as slander against parents with those kinds of preferences. In fact, their thinking is only natural.
Why would anyone dedicate their entire adult life to another human being? We don't need children to take care of us anymore - we have pensions for that sort of thing. It just makes no logical sense.
It's a fallacy. All the incentives and government support in the world wouldn't change a thing. Perhaps it could artificially boost the numbers a bit, sort of like how women in poor countries are being forced into surrogacy. But would you really be a good parent if the reason why you did it is because you made money doing it? Evidence seen here in the UK tells me otherwise.
No matter what, becoming a (good) parent is a loss of self. I view myself as having been remade anew, but I realise and accept that this view is an unpopular one. For most, parents don't WANT to be parents, they SUFFER it because wanting to be a parent often isn't logical. It's primal, and it's emotional.
Since women started having a choice and started receiving higher education, the enormous burden of suffering childbirth and is logical fallacies were exposed. Still, we're animals and our primal instincts will drive us to have children. But not for all.
Conservatively, even if only half the female population decide children aren't for them (a reality here in the UK); TFR suffers a massive blow. Amongst the other half of the women that do have kids; 1 child per woman would be TFR of 0.5, the ever-popular "two and done" would leave TFR at a meagre 1.
To get it even close to replacement rate, the remaining half would need to have 4 at least children each. As someone who's got experience in this, this does make me laugh. So many people have called me and my wife crazy. Amongst us millennials, we've even outdone many religious families.
And yes, we are odd. We'd rather have playfight sessions in the living room or cuddles on the couch over holidays in Spain, Italy or Greece. It's okay that the world around us isn't built for a family of 6, so that we've had to squeeze into our modest used car and or that eating out at most cafés is near impossible.
It's just unrealistic for people to want to live like us. I accept that, and would rather navigate through what provisions the world can make for that reality.