r/PickAorB Jul 25 '25

How to Use r/PickAorB: A Space for Real-Life Choices

12 Upvotes

r/PickAorB is a space that honors the real, often messy emotions we face when caught between life choices, A or B. But this isn’t just about black or white thinking. Here, you’re invited to share your inner conflicts, doubts, and uncertainties. Even more importantly, we’re here to explore the “third way,” a possibility beyond A or B that you might not have considered yet.
Whether you’re standing at a crossroads or simply seeking connection through others’ stories, this is a space for expressing, listening, and discovering together.

Core Values

  1. Express your real thoughts and doubts We welcome you to open up about the complicated emotions behind your choices. There’s no such thing as a perfect answer, only honest sharing.
  2. Respect others’ decisions and stay open to new possibilities Everyone’s background and values are different. We don’t judge what’s right or wrong. Instead, we honor each person’s decision while also encouraging you to look beyond A and B and consider creative or unconventional paths.
  3. Kindness first, no hate, no mockery This community is rooted in sincerity, empathy, and understanding. We don’t tolerate attacks, discrimination, or ridicule. Let’s keep this a safe space where people feel supported in being vulnerable.

Community Rules

  1. Post real-life dilemmas and honest reflections Your post should come from your own life or observations. The more details and emotions you share, the more others can connect and respond meaningfully.
  2. Use the A or B format in your title Your post title should clearly state your dilemma. This helps others quickly join the conversation.
  3. No hate speech or personal attacks Treat everyone with respect. Avoid insulting, discriminatory, or inflammatory language. If you see inappropriate comments, report or kindly remind others to keep the space safe.
  4. Promote supportive, thoughtful interaction When replying, aim to offer empathy, personal insight, or constructive advice, not harsh criticism or dismissal.
  5. Feel free to suggest a third way Sometimes the best path isn’t A or B. Don’t hesitate to propose a different perspective, idea, or hybrid solution. Your creativity might inspire someone else.

How to Post

  1. Start your post with an A or B question in the title Example: “AorB, Go back to school or accept job offer?”
  2. Share your dilemma or observation In the body of your post, describe the real-life situation, your hesitation, emotional struggle, and any background details. The more personal and specific, the more others can relate.
  3. Clearly define your A and B options Let people know what you’re deciding between, including pros, cons, and how you feel about each.
  4. Invite suggestions and third-way thinking Ask the community not just for a vote, but for fresh perspectives, a path you might not have thought of yet.
  5. Be open and real You don’t need to have it all figured out. This is a space for honest uncertainty. Your openness makes it easier for others to support you and feel less alone too.

And finally
If you're feeling stuck, try writing it out.
If you see a post that resonates, maybe your words will help someone feel a little more seen.
We're all figuring out how to make choices.
We're all learning how to take care of ourselves.
May this be a space where you feel safe enough to pause, reflect, and speak.
Welcome. Share your A or B.


r/PickAorB 1d ago

A or B: My neighbor says my EV charger's "hum" keeps his wife awake. At 2am he opened my panel and flipped my main breaker. $210 of food spoiled, my car sat at 9%. Now he wants ME to compensate HIS "sleep damages"

16.7k Upvotes

I bought a used EV last fall. Installing the Level 2 charger cost $1,800 because the electrician had to run a new circuit to the garage. The unit sits on my garage wall. When it charges, it makes a soft click when the car connects, and a small fan runs. Standing next to it, it's quieter than my refrigerator.

My neighbor's house is about 12 feet away.

In April, he left a note on my door saying a "hum" was keeping his wife awake and asking me to "address it." I stood in my side yard at midnight and honestly couldn't hear the charger over the crickets. Still, I set the car to charge from 11pm to 6am on the off-peak rate and told him to let me know if it still bothered her.

Three weeks later, he had filed a complaint with the HOA. A guy from the committee came out with a decibel meter and read 38 to 41 dB at the property line, which was below the HOA's noise limit. The complaint was closed.

My neighbor wasn't satisfied. He knocked on my door and said his wife "hasn't slept properly in months" and that I should charge at the public station in the shopping center "like considerate people do." I told him the unit had passed the HOA's own test and closed the door.

Last Tuesday at 2:04am, my doorbell camera, which covers the side yard, recorded him walking onto my property with a flashlight. He opened the exterior electrical panel, shut off the breaker connected to my charger, and walked home. Total time: 41 seconds.

Nobody noticed until morning. The fridge had been off for seven hours. I threw out $210 in groceries, including the leftover half of my daughter's birthday cake. My car, which was scheduled to charge overnight, sat at 9%. I made my meeting by fast-charging for 25 minutes, which cost $19.

I printed the video stills and the grocery receipts and brought them over. He didn't deny any of it.

He said, "You bought the toy car, not me. If it makes noise, that's a you problem. Every home comes with a right to quiet enjoyment. Look it up."

Then he told me his wife's sleep was worth more than my groceries. He had receipts too: a sleep clinic copay and a white noise machine. He said if I covered those costs, "we'd call it even" for the food, since the noise "started this."

His wife has stopped waving at us. Another neighbor told me I should just move the charger or pay the costs, because we still have to live next to each other.

I filed a police report for the trespass. The officer documented it but left it to me whether to pursue charges.

A) I drop it. Pressing charges over groceries starts a war I have to live next to for years. I pay the costs, switch to daytime charging or the public station, and keep the peace.

B) The charger passed the HOA's own decibel test. He came onto my property at 2am and cut power to my house. I pursue the trespass and take him to small claims for the $210, and let his "sleep damages" explain themselves to a judge.


r/PickAorB 11h ago

A or B: Was I wrong for asking my friend not to bring their partner to dinner?

124 Upvotes

Four of us have been close friends for years. We’re a mixed group of men and women, and these days we don’t get to meet very often.

A couple of weeks ago, we finally found a Saturday when all four of us were free and planned dinner together. The idea was just to catch up like we used to.

A few hours before dinner, one friend texted the group:

“My partner is with me, so they’ll come along tonight. Hope that’s okay.”

I like their partner. We’ve met plenty of times and there’s never been a problem.

But I felt a little annoyed because nobody had actually been asked. It felt more like we were being told they were coming.

I replied, “Would you mind if we kept it just the four of us tonight? We hardly ever get to catch up anymore.”

My friend replied, “Seriously? They’re already with me. What am I supposed to say now?”

One friend privately told me they agreed with me. The other said I was making an issue out of nothing and that one extra person wouldn’t change the evening.

My friend eventually came alone, but things were noticeably awkward.

Later they told me, “You made my partner feel unwanted. We’ve been together for years and everyone knows them.”

I said, “I have nothing against your partner. I just think if four people make plans, you should ask before inviting a fifth person.”

They replied that in a long-term relationship, sometimes you should expect someone's partner to be included in casual social plans.

That’s where we disagree.

A: I wasn’t wrong. Being someone's long-term partner doesn’t mean you're automatically invited to every friend gathering.

B: I made it unnecessarily awkward. If everyone already knows and likes the partner, one extra person shouldn’t matter.

Who do you agree with?


r/PickAorB 4h ago

A or B: If your beloved relative is in the terminal stage of life, and the doctor has privately told you that he has little time left, but he himself asks you with hope: “My illness will get better, right?” Would you choose to tell the truth, or to say a comforting lie?

13 Upvotes

A – Tell the truth
You uphold honesty as an absolute moral duty, believing that every person has the right to know their own condition, no matter how painful. You respect his autonomy, even if it costs him his final peace.

B – Tell a comforting lie
You choose kindness over truth, prioritising his emotional well‑being in his last moments. You believe that love sometimes requires shielding someone from unbearable pain, even if that means deceiving them.


r/PickAorB 5h ago

A or B: My friend is learning to cut hair, proudly posted the haircut she gave me, but I secretly think it’s the ugliest haircut I’ve ever had. Should I tell her?

12 Upvotes

One of my close friends recently started learning how to cut hair. There are four of us who are really close, and the other three of us have basically become her haircut models.

The other two friends were really happy with their haircuts. I was not.

Honestly, I think this might be the ugliest haircut I’ve ever had. I looked in the mirror and immediately thought, “Oh no, what did I do?” But I also knew she was really proud of it. She took pictures of my hair right there and posted them on Instagram, saying it was one of her favorite cuts she had done recently.

Then she asked me, “Do you like it?”

I said yes.

Not because I liked it, but because I could see how happy and proud she was, and I really didn’t want to be the person who killed her confidence. I figured it was just hair, it would grow out, and maybe I could live with it.

Then I got home and my partner looked at me and basically said, “Why did you get such an ugly haircut?”

And weirdly, I wasn't offended at all. I was almost relieved. Like, finally someone said what I was thinking.

I told him the whole story, and he thinks I should be honest with my friend. His point is that if she’s learning, she needs honest feedback to improve. If I keep telling her I love her work when I actually hate it, I'm not really helping her.

I kind of agree.

But another part of me keeps thinking, maybe she genuinely likes the haircut. Taste is subjective. Maybe what I hate is exactly what she was trying to create. And if I tell her I think it's awful, am I giving useful feedback or just making her feel bad because my personal taste is different from hers?

So now I'm stuck between wanting to be honest and not wanting to unnecessarily hurt someone I care about.

A: Tell her the truth, because she’s learning and honest feedback is more useful than fake praise.

B: Let it go. It’s my hair and my personal taste, and there’s no reason to make her feel bad about something she’s genuinely proud of.

And if you were my friend in this situation, would you rather I choose A or B? If you’d want me to choose A, how would you want me to tell you so you’d understand that I’m criticizing the haircut, not you?


r/PickAorB 10h ago

A or B:To resign or not

13 Upvotes

My boss (who owns the company) is, quite frankly, extremely difficult to work with.

He shouts at people, loves drama, expects perfection, and seems to genuinely believe that everyone in the company is replaceable. Somehow, I’ve managed to survive and keep my head down because I’ve been the longest-serving employee (in my position) in the company.

But I think I’ve finally reached my limit.

Recently, my assistant resigned. She told my boss that one of the reasons was the environment in the office, which is largely because of him. My boss apparently told her that he would NOT accept that as a reason for her resignation.

Then, afterwards, he asked her to make a feedback report about ME.

Now he has called me and asked me to send him both my task list and hers because he apparently wants to compare our workloads. He seems to think that maybe I gave her too much work and that THIS is the real reason she resigned.

And honestly? That really pissed me off.

Trust is extremely important to me, and I feel like instead of looking at his own behavior and the environment he has created, he is trying to find someone else to blame. And now I feel like that person is me.

I’ve been managing this situation for a long time. I’ve put up with his personality, the shouting, the drama, the constant pressure and the feeling that none of us are really valued.

But this feels different.

It feels like he is questioning my integrity and trying to make me responsible for someone else’s decision to leave.

My husband thinks I should resign. His argument is that we actually have some savings, and he has a stable job that can support me and our family. He thinks this is the perfect opportunity for my boss to finally sit back and realize that maybe the problem isn't always everyone else.

Obviously, I know resigning without another job lined up isn't something to take lightly. But financially, we aren't in a position where my family would immediately be in trouble if I stopped working. I could take some time to breathe, look for another job and figure out what I actually want.

Just for me to add, it would be hard for me to change workplace where I am as I am on a work visa tied to my current employer.

Part of me thinks: Why am I staying somewhere that makes me this miserable when I don't actually HAVE to?

Another part of me thinks: Don't make an emotional decision. You have a decent position, you're established there, and maybe you should just keep your head down and collect your paycheck.

So , should I.

A. Resign and move on.
B. Stay and continue keeping my head down.

And please tell me if I'm being too emotional about this. I genuinely want some outside perspective.


r/PickAorB 14h ago

A or B: Keep my seat or switch with a mom who wants to sit with her child?

17 Upvotes

I was on a flight and had a seat that I had specifically chosen when I booked my ticket.

A mom approached me and asked if I would switch seats with her so she could sit closer to her child. Her seat was not terrible but it was different from the one I had picked.

I said no because I had chosen my seat for a reason and I did not really want to give it up.

She seemed disappointed and I started wondering if I should have just switched to make things easier for her.

So I am curious what you would choose.

A: Keep the seat you picked and politely say no.

B: Switch seats so the parent can sit closer to their child even if you prefer your original seat.

Which would you choose?


r/PickAorB 4h ago

A or B: Current or “dream” job?

1 Upvotes

Current company A: I have few concerns about the current job. Boss, work, work life balance, salary, learning new skills, career growth opportunity, are all solid. However there are frequent and large layoffs.

New company B: The job would pretty much be the same day to day tasks, but with a much higher title. I know Reddit is against chasing titles but in this case there is no added responsibility. However the pay would be ~10% less. The company has laid off less than 1% of the staff annually for last decade so it is stable. The job itself isn’t a dream, but the company is somewhere I would love to be and would stay as long as possible. They rarely ever open any job opportunities so this is probably the only time my life would align with this particular opportunity. A big unknown is the team. It seems raises will be infrequent or minimal.

Is this a classic case of grass is greener?Assuming the pay cut does not significantly impact my life, should I:

A: Stay at current job

Or

B: Take the risk and go for the “dream job”


r/PickAorB 1d ago

A or B: Was I wrong for refusing to have sex with my husband after his father’s funeral?

38 Upvotes

My husband’s father passed away recently, and we had the funeral a few days ago.

After we got home, my husband wanted to have sex. He said he needed to feel close to me and that being intimate would help him feel less alone after losing his dad.

I told him I couldn’t. The whole day was emotionally overwhelming, and I didn’t feel comfortable being intimate right after the funeral. I needed some time to process everything.

He got upset and said my refusal made him feel abandoned during one of the hardest moments of his life.

I understand that people grieve differently. For him, physical intimacy may have been a way to seek comfort. But I also feel like I should be allowed to say no when I’m not emotionally ready.

Now I feel guilty because I don’t want him to feel unsupported, but I also don’t think grief means my boundaries disappear.

What was the more reasonable response?

A. Yes, I should have put his grief first and tried to support him through intimacy.

B. No, I was allowed to say no and ask for space, even though he was grieving.


r/PickAorB 2d ago

A or B: My neighbor's pickleball group climbs my fence for stray balls 5+ times a week. I started confiscating them into a bucket. Now he's billed me $200 for "tournament balls" saying "if you returned them promptly, we wouldn't have to climb. That's on you"

2.9k Upvotes

My neighbor spent $18,500 last spring converting his backyard into a pickleball court. Full resurfacing, permanent net, lights. It's beautiful. He plays four nights a week, and open play on Saturdays means eight to ten people I've never met.

My yard backs directly onto his. Between us: a six foot cedar fence that I paid for, my raised vegetable beds along it, and my dog Biscuit, whose entire job is lying by the back door judging everyone.

Balls come over. A lot. On a good Saturday, six or seven.

I found a guy halfway over my fence at 6:15pm, one foot in my tomato bed. I walked the balls back over myself and asked my neighbor to have people text me, or use the side gate, but please stop climbing.

I left a note attached to his net: happy to return balls if you knock, but the fence climbing needs to stop.

Someone left my side gate unlatched after letting themselves in. Biscuit got out and was found three streets away. $240 at the vet for a paw he sliced on storm drain metal.

Another time, my Ring camera caught two players opening my side gate and walking into my yard without asking while looking for a ball. My basil bed was flattened. That was the day I stopped returning anything.

Now, every ball that lands in my yard goes into a five gallon bucket by my back door. I don't throw them back. I don't answer the door for "quick grabs." Current count: 41.

Last week my neighbor came over with a handwritten, itemized bill:

36 outdoor balls at $4.00 each: $144

1 sleeve Selkirk tournament balls: $40

Total: $184

He slid it through the gap in the fence on a clipboard. When I said I'd return the balls the day he paid the $240 vet bill and the $60 in plants, he told me, word for word:

"A ball doesn't become yours because it landed in your yard. It's still in play until we pick it up. If you returned them promptly, nobody would have to climb. That's on you."

My wife thinks I should just dump the bucket back over and buy a $35 latch. She says it's "a bucket of plastic, not a hill to die on," and my neighbor's group has now started knocking at 9pm on weeknights "for one ball."

Another neighbor suggested I install a ball return flap in the fence, at my expense, "since they're going to keep coming over anyway."

A) Return the bucket, put in the flap, and give my neighbor the side gate code. It's $35 of hardware to end a weekly problem, and 41 balls isn't worth a war with eight people who apparently have nothing else to do.

B) The bucket stays, and it fills. His balls are part of an ongoing dispute, not something I should have to manage every week. He gets them back once the vet bill and the garden damage are settled. Cash first.


r/PickAorB 2d ago

A or B: My brother "borrowed" $2,000 three years ago. He just posted photos from Vegas. I commented "Glad you're doing well." Now he wants an apology for the "public callout"

980 Upvotes

Three years ago my brother called me around 11pm. He was behind on rent and said he was worried his landlord was going to start the eviction process. He asked me for $2,000 and said, "I'll have it back to you by summer."

I lent it to him. No contract, no interest, nothing in writing. We were family, so I didn't think twice about it.

Summer came and went. Whenever I brought it up, there was always something. He'd just switched jobs, his car needed repairs, he'd pay me after the holidays. After about a year I stopped asking. It wasn't worth the tension, and honestly I'd mentally written it off. I hadn't forgotten about it, though.

Last week he posted photos from Vegas. Pool cabana, fight tickets, a steak dinner. The caption was "sometimes you gotta treat yourself."

I commented: "Glad you're doing well 😊"

That's it. No mention of the money. No joke about paying me back. Nothing else.

He called me about an hour later, furious. He said I "knew exactly what I was doing" and that I embarrassed him in front of his friends. He said if I wanted the money, I should have texted him privately instead of calling him out publicly. He wants me to delete the comment and apologize.

His explanation was that a friend had organized the bachelor party and covered most of the trip, so he said he barely paid for anything himself.

My mom thinks I should apologize because "you knew how he'd take it." My dad thinks he still owes me the money and an apology, but says I shouldn't have aired it online.

I honestly didn't think "Glad you're doing well" was a public callout. I didn't call him a deadbeat or even mention the money. But I also knew exactly what I was thinking when I wrote it.

So now I'm wondering if that makes a difference.

A.Yes. The smiley face made it a dig, and I knew it. I used his own photos to shame him in front of his friends instead of dealing with the debt privately. The comment was more about getting a reaction than getting my money back.

B. No. "Glad you're doing well" isn't an insult. If he took it as a public attack, that's because he knows he owes me money. He's not really upset about the wording. He's upset that his debt became visible to other people.


r/PickAorB 19h ago

A or B: EX-keeps hitting me up wanting to fix things. We've been co-parenting our kid just fine since the split and have been single since early last year. Currently, I'm in talking stage. She's cool and all, but not sure she want marriage as much as I do.

0 Upvotes

As the headline suggest, I'm in dillema between two options. Part of me wonders if going back to the ex makes sense because of the kid and how smooth the co-parenting already is. The other part of me is curious about this new lady I'm currently talking to, and while she hasn't given clear signs to marriage, she expressed that it's something she can't make a decision on now. I don’t want to shut that door too fast either.

So, I'm stuck in the middle and don't want to make a decision I'll leave to regret. I know there are people who have been in a similar situation or those who've seen it happening, and can share as much.

A: Should I let the ex back in since she’s the mother of my firstborn and we co-parent perfectly?

B: Should I keep going with the talking stage even though I’m not sure she’ll want marriage?

For context: We broke up last year because our goals just didn’t match anymore. I went back to school for a demanding postgrad program while still working part-time, so I had way less time for family. She wanted someone who was always present, and that led to constant fights about me not prioritizing us. I tried asking for little patience and all these attempts were interpreted as someone not into marriage, and that I reminded her of his father prioritizing his career over family and breaking their parents up. Co-parenting has actually been smoother without us forcing the romance.


r/PickAorB 2d ago

A or B: Should i mow the lawn to the line where my neighbor erroneously placed markers, or keep to within my yard, leaving and uncut foot or two of grass on his side?

188 Upvotes

Street of single family homes, my neighbor happens to be a renter. He has been cutting the grass way over on my side of the property line. Thinking that the owner never pointed out where the line was when theybrented the house, i went over to politely ask him to stop driving his riding mower around a flower bed between our yards which was taking him 3 to 4 feet into my yard, right by the street in a very noticeable way. I thought we were on friendly terms where this would be no big deal. Was I wrong, he is apparently going thru some medical issues with a family member and just blew up at me. So I don't feel comfortable talking to him again about any of this.

Today, I see that he has placed landscaping lights along a line between our lots. However, they are not actually on the property line (which i told him was the utility box) but about a foot or two inside that yard. He mowed today exactly up to the edge defined by those lights, which again, is well inside his yard.

So do i:

A: Cut into his yard, up to the edge that he mowed his yard to? But then be guilty of the same thing that I originally went to talk to him about, which is cutting over the line?

B: Stay on my side, and only mow to the actual edge of my property, thus leaving an unsightly one or two foot run of uncut grass between our properties, but on his side?

Another option might be to talk to the actual owner, who is am on very good terms with, who lived next door for several years before moving away and renting out the house. Ask him to talk to the renter and see what is going on?


r/PickAorB 11h ago

A or B: which are you taking?

0 Upvotes
  • A: $10 million today.
  • B: $1 million today + the knowledge, framework and skills to build $10 million yourself.

Which one are you taking & why?


r/PickAorB 1d ago

A or B: wait for friendship to improve or just stop trying when I disagree with their parenting decisions

20 Upvotes

Got some friends who live next door, we used to spend time together weekly. I have always disagreed how they let their 5y/o daughter get away make decisions around the house (e.g. her bedtime) but it was their decision and none of my business to comment. She always behaved well at my house, following the same rules my kids do.

Now they've got a son who is now 2 and he used to be quite a sweet kid but recently I think he's realised the only way he'll get attention from his parents is misbehaving (they spend way too much time doing what his sister wants imo so he doesn't get much 1:1 time). (Example: he can tell his sister gets to stay up and watch TV but he has always been a good sleeper so never got to do that, now he throws tantrums at bedtime because he wants to watch TV too.)

It bothers me seeing him miss out like this and getting a naughty label. He also doesn't behave well at my house any more. I'm finding their company tiresome overall.

A. Stop inviting them over because I don't find them good company

B. Keep seeing them because the kid might figure out our house rules and start behaving better when he's over

... Or C. Tell them how I feel!

ETA

My inequality example wasn't a great one as a few have pointed out! Better examples:

Mum getting chocolates for my kids and her daughter: none for her son who got told off for complaining about it.

Daughter has 'special toys' son can't touch but daughter can take his favourite birthday toys out of the house while son is at home.

Daughter gets to take toys in the car but no one picks up a toy for son to play with in the car (he's not old enough to think to pick up his own yet)

Daughter gloats to son that she gets to watch tv when he's in bed.

We all went to the park but son was left at home (crying for being left out) because mum couldn't be bothered to watch him at the park and dad wanted to rest at home.


r/PickAorB 2d ago

A or B: Two friends ghosted me after I told them about my cancer diagnosis. Realized I will be seeing them soon at an event and not sure how to interact with them.

76 Upvotes

I was diagnosed with an aggressive cancer 6 months ago. 6 rounds of chemo and one massive 12 hour surgery later things are looking really good for me.

I’ve been fortunate to have the kind of support from friends and family that exceeds my ability to comprehend it. I am fully aware and thankful for my people who helped and showed me love in small and big ways. And truly a simple sweet text makes me feel loved and supported.

That said I have two friends (who are closer with each other than with me) that I haven’t heard a squeak from since I told them of my diagnosis and scope of surgery. These are the “let’s have lunch every couple of months” friends. They are not part of my closer friend group so would not be getting updates from other people (I don’t post personal on social media)

So while we aren’t the tightest i did think we were friends. Especially my one friend whose child died unexpectedly. I tried to be supportive of her in the years after - always ready to listen and trying to think of things that might make her path a little easier to walk. I would call or text her on the calendar days I thought might be hard, etc.

They both cancer ghosted me after my first chemo. And it’s not like we are young and inexperienced; we have grown children and we’ve been through it. They never asked how I was doing with chemo or how my surgery and recovery went etc. I doubt they even know I had the surgery.

I realized recently that I will likely see them soon at an event that we are all part of and I’m unsure how I want to interact with them.

Do I A - accept that people have limitations and be gracious and forthcoming when I see them? I know that everyone has stuff in their life that is hard.

Or do I B - Refuse to ignore how hurtful it is to be dropped like that. If they do talk to me say “so kind to ask” and tell them to continue to check the news online for my obit.


r/PickAorB 3d ago

A or B: My gym posted a before/after photo of me in their ad without asking. They said my membership counts as "implied consent"

990 Upvotes

I've been a member at my gym for about two years. In January, I signed up for a 12-week transformation challenge.

At the start, a trainer took front and side photos of me in front of their logo board. They did the same thing at the end. I asked what the photos were for, and the trainer said they were for my progress records and maybe the challenge board in the lobby.

I was fine with that. I actually won my category, which was a nice surprise.

Three weeks ago, a friend texted me a screenshot saying, "Congrats on being famous lol." It was my gym's Instagram.

They had posted my before-and-after photos with my first name and last initial as part of a paid ad: "REAL RESULTS. Ask about our next challenge."

It wasn't just a post on their page. It was a sponsored ad running on Facebook and Instagram, and from the dates I could see, it had been running for weeks.

I went to the front desk and asked them to take it down. The manager said the photos were gym property and that, as a member, I'd given "implied consent" for the gym to use member photos in its marketing.

I asked where I'd agreed to that. He pointed me to the membership agreement.

I pulled up the agreement on my phone and searched for anything about photos or advertising. The word "photo" didn't appear once. The closest thing I found was a line saying the gym may photograph activities and events for internal records.

The manager said he'd pass it along. A week later, the ad was still running, so I emailed corporate. They thanked me for my "engagement" and said they'd review the campaign.

The ad is still up. A friend thinks I should be flattered. "You look great, it's free motivation, who cares?"

My wife is much angrier than I am and keeps pointing out that there's a difference between putting someone's photo on a lobby board and paying to put it in front of thousands of strangers.

The photo is flattering. That's honestly not the point. If they'd asked me, I might have even said yes. I don't know, did I overreact?

A. Yes. I signed up for the challenge, agreed to be photographed, and ended up with a result I'm proud of. If the photo is accurate, this feels like a pretty minor issue. They used a flattering result to promote something I voluntarily participated in.

B. No. My photo and name being in a paid ad doesn't magically mean I consented to it. I agreed to progress photos and possibly a lobby display. A sponsored ad is a completely different use, and "you should be flattered" isn't a substitute for asking.


r/PickAorB 3d ago

A or B: My cousin knew the deed was questionable and recorded it anyway. But without it, my uncle could lose his home Monday

91 Upvotes

I just found out what my cousin did this weekend, and I'm honestly torn.

My grandmother's will was signed twelve years ago, notarized and witnessed. It left her house to her son, my uncle. He's 51, has cerebral palsy, and has lived there since birth. The house has a ramp, handrails, and other things that were added for him over the years.

She died in March. Her will didn't name an executor, so an estranged nephew was appointed. The estate has very little cash and about $38,000 in administrative expenses.

Last month, the probate court authorized the house to be sold at auction Monday at 10 a.m. to cover those expenses.

My uncle's attorney objected to the sale, but the hearing isn't until the 23rd. The court won't hear the issue before the auction.

Then my cousin found an old deed Grandma had signed nine years ago. It was never recorded and had been kept in a cedar box under her bed. The attorney looked at it and said it appeared genuine but was legally questionable.

My cousin recorded it with the county clerk on Saturday anyway, hoping it would interfere with the sale long enough for the court to hear the case.

I understand why she did it. My uncle could lose the only home he's ever known before anyone gets to decide what Grandma actually intended.

But she knew the deed was questionable. She wasn't just preserving a document. She was using it because she knew the timing might force the sale to stop.

A: Justified. She was protecting my uncle from losing his home over a dispute the court hadn't had time to resolve.

B: Wrong. She knowingly used a questionable document to interfere with a legal process. A sympathetic reason doesn't make the tactic right.

Or was there a better way to protect my uncle without doing this?


r/PickAorB 3d ago

A or B: 3 mph slower or fix it?

11 Upvotes

Today I replaced the stepper motor that moves the speedometer in my car. When test driving I noticed that it is misaligned by 3 mph.

Edit: compared to speedometer app on my phone.

A: leave it alone and attempt to trick myself and all the vehicle's future owners into driving 3 mph slower.

B: take it apart again and fix it.

I know, such a minor thing but...


r/PickAorB 4d ago

A or B: My sister asked me to co-sign her car loan "as a formality." I refused. Now my family says I'm the reason she can't get to work

756 Upvotes

My sister's car died last month. She needs one to get to her job, which is about a 35-minute drive from where she lives.

She has bad credit. A few years ago, she stopped paying a credit card and it eventually went to collections. She's upfront about it, but it still follows her.

She found a used car she liked and applied for financing. The rate she was offered was brutal. The dealer said a co-signer might get her approved at a much better rate.

So she called me and asked if I could "just sign the form."

Her exact words were, "It's a formality. You'll never hear about it again."

I asked three questions: How much is the loan? What's the monthly payment? And what happens to my credit if you stop paying?

She answered the first two, then went quiet and said, "Why are you interrogating me like I'm a criminal?"

The loan was for five years. I told her I wasn't comfortable putting my credit behind someone else's five-year car loan.

I offered what I could actually do:

• $800 toward a cheaper used car

• Let her stay with me for a month and drive her to work while she saves

• Help her look into a credit union available through her employer

She said none of that was a "real solution" and that my signature costs me nothing.

She told my mom. Now my mom says I'm punishing my sister for old mistakes and that I'm "the reason she might lose this job."

My aunt texted me that family helps family.

For what it's worth, a cousin in our family co-signed a truck loan for her son two years ago. He's missed enough payments that she's ended up making some of them herself.

My sister hasn't spoken to me since I refused. Did I go too far?

A. Yes. She needs a car to keep her job, and I had the ability to help her get one at a reasonable rate. Bringing up her old credit problems during a crisis was a low blow, and my "alternatives" were mostly ways of saying no.

B. No. A co-sign isn't a formality. If she stops paying, the lender can come after me too, and the loan can affect my credit. I'm allowed to look at her payment history and decide I don't want to guarantee the debt. I offered real help. She wanted my credit, not my help.


r/PickAorB 4d ago

A or B: A single dad is laid off because HR entered his job status incorrectly, putting his immigration status at risk. A coworker breaks company rules to fix it. Justified or unjustified?

48 Upvotes

Something happened at work that I can't quite decide how I feel about.

During a system migration, HR accidentally recorded a five-year employee as a contractor instead of an employee. Nobody caught it.

Then the company announced a restructuring. Contractors were being cut first, so the mistake put him on the layoff list.

His immigration status is tied to his job. Losing it could give him as little as 60 days to find another qualifying job or otherwise maintain legal status. If he can't, he may have to leave the US with his five yo children.

He filed a correction request as soon as he found out. HR said the normal process takes about two weeks. His manager escalated it, but the director said the final list had already gone to headquarters and couldn't be reopened for one employee.

There was one complication. A coworker still had admin access to the HR system.

After an audit the previous year, anyone outside the HR systems team was supposed to have view-only access. Company policy prohibited unauthorized changes to employee records and said violations could result in termination.

Thursday night, she logged in anyway and corrected his status.

A:Morally justified. She broke a company rule to correct a company error that could otherwise uproot a family.

B:Morally unjustified. The rule exists to protect the integrity of employee records, and no individual employee should decide when it's acceptable to bypass it, even for a sympathetic case.


r/PickAorB 5d ago

A or B: My divorced sister moved into my 430 sqft studio, so I gave her a “dog bed” and now my family says I owe her an apology

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

My sister finalized her divorce three weeks ago. Her ex got to keep their apartment, and she needed somewhere to stay while she figures out what to do next. She asked to stay with me for "two weeks, three max." Obviously I said yes. She's my sister. When we were kids she literally fought a goose for me. Not relevant, but I want that on record.

The problem is that I live in a regular 430 sqft studio. One bed, one loveseat, and basically no spare floor space.

The loveseat is not really an option. I once tried sleeping on it during a migraine and woke up feeling like my spine had filed a complaint.

I tried an air mattress first. Borrowed one from a coworker, put it in the only open space, and it was mostly deflated by 3am. We were both basically sleeping on the floor.

I looked at cots too, but she just left a marriage. I didn't love the idea of making her feel like she was camping in my apartment.

A real second bed would eat most of the usable floor space, and I don't really want to buy furniture I'll have nowhere to put once she leaves.

So at 2am I went down a rabbit hole and found something I honestly thought was kind of brilliant.

A huge orthopedic dog bed.

Not the little pillow kind. This thing was basically a giant cushioned nest. Honestly, it was comfortable enough to sleep on and big enough to use as a couch.

I watched an unreasonable number of videos of adults actually sleeping on them, and... they looked comfortable. Like genuinely comfortable.

I set it up in the corner by the window with the blanket we used growing up and my favorite throw pillow. By the time I was done, it looked more like a comfortable daybed than a dog bed.

I even test-napped on it myself. Two hours. No back pain. I almost didn't get up.

My sister arrived yesterday.

She walked in, looked at the bed, and went completely quiet.

Then she said:"What. Is. That."

I started explaining the foam, the size, how I'd tested it, and how it was temporary.

She just stared at me.Then she said, really quietly:"I just left a marriage and you're putting me in a dog bed. Like a stray you decided to keep."

She went into the bathroom and locked the door.

A few minutes later she called our mom.

Mom called me and said I needed to apologize and buy an air mattress "like a normal person."

I told her I'd swap with my sister if she wanted. She could take my actual bed and I'd sleep on the dog bed.

She said, "That's not the point."

And I honestly don't know if she's right.

For context, there's nothing remotely dog-themed about the bed. No paw prints, no bones, no weird shape. It's brand new, clean, washable, and honestly more comfortable than the mattress I slept on throughout college.

So I'm stuck between two interpretations.

A) I was insensitive. The physical comfort doesn't really matter because the symbolism matters more. A freshly divorced person being handed a dog bed can reasonably feel like she's being treated as less than a person, even if the bed itself is objectively comfortable. I should apologize and get the air mattress.

B) I wasn't. I had a real space problem, found something comfortable and temporary, and even offered to give her my actual bed. I wasn't trying to humiliate her. At some point, doesn't intent and actual treatment matter more than what an object symbolizes?


r/PickAorB 5d ago

A or B: My company laid me off 5 months ago and blocked me from taking other jobs. Now their biggest client is about to leave, and they want me back at my old pay. Am I wrong for charging triple as a consultant?

841 Upvotes

I worked as a client success manager at a B2B software company for seven years.

When I joined, one of our main accounts was worth around $200K a year. By the time I left, it had grown into a $2.4M account. I managed the onboarding, handled three major renewals, and built the relationship from the ground up.

The client trusted me. Their team regularly came directly to me when issues came up, and they made it clear that the relationship was a big reason they stayed with us.

Five months ago, the company announced a restructuring and eliminated my entire division.

They gave me a small severance package, then reminded me that my non-compete agreement would be enforced for six months. The agreement was broad enough that it would have blocked me from working for most companies in the same space.

I talked to a lawyer. He told me the restriction might be challengeable, but fighting it would take time and money I couldn't justify after losing my job.

So I waited. For five months, I turned down opportunities because they were technically with competitors. I watched my savings disappear while the company that let me go was still making sure I couldn't easily move on.

Then, about three weeks ago, they started calling.

At first it was casual. They asked how I was doing and said the team missed me.

Then they explained the real problem.

The client I had built was unhappy with the transition. The account had been handed to a more junior employee, communication had dropped, and they were seriously considering leaving at renewal.

The client specifically asked about me.

Suddenly, I went from someone they no longer needed to someone they urgently needed.

They asked if I could "just jump on a few calls" to help smooth things over.

Then it became "maybe consult for a few weeks."

Finally, they offered me a contractor role as a "Senior Strategic Advisor."

Same salary as before. No benefits. No equity. Just temporary help until the situation stabilized.

They said it would be doing them a favor.

The thing is, they are not asking me to come back and do my old job.

They are asking me to use seven years of relationships, trust, and customer knowledge to save a $2.4M account that is at risk because of decisions they made.

So I gave them my terms.

Triple my previous hourly equivalent consulting rate, contractor agreement, and a clear end date.

They said that was unreasonable and called it "extortion."

HR also reminded me about my confidentiality obligations, even though I wasn't asking to use any company information. I was offering to help protect one of their most valuable customer relationships.

My non-compete expires in four weeks. After that, I can compete freely in the market.

A - Triple is too aggressive. The industry is small, and burning this bridge could hurt me later. I should take a reasonable deal, help them out, and let my work speak for itself.

B - They used every advantage they had when I was vulnerable. Now they are in a vulnerable position, and this is the only moment I have real leverage. A company doesn't get to call something "unfair" just because the employee finally has negotiating power.


r/PickAorB 5d ago

A or B: Was I wrong for refusing to switch tables with a dad and calling out his priorities?

601 Upvotes

I booked a window table three weeks out for our wedding anniversary. A dad asked me to move to a cramped two-top by the door so his kid could "watch the streetcars."

I pointed out that his party of four was sitting at a six-seat table, with a window seat still open.

He said he "can't sit apart from his son" or the boy would melt down.

I told him if it was really for his kid, the solution was at his own table, not me giving up a reservation I'd made weeks ago.

His wife started recording and said, "Wow, really?"

Then a grandpa at the next table leaned over: "Relax, the kid's been watching streetcars for 20 minutes. He's bored."

My partner says I crossed a line by saying that in front of their child. Idk, did I go too far?

A. Yes. It's just a table, I should've moved and dropped it.

B. No. He had empty seats at his own table but expected me to sacrifice the reservation I'd planned weeks for.


r/PickAorB 5d ago

A or B: Is breaking into a building and private property to rescue a dog scheduled for euthanasia morally justified (Option A), or is it morally unjustified regardless of the outcome (Option B)

Post image
908 Upvotes