r/PickAorB • u/Romanc_88 • 13h ago
A or B: Was I wrong for asking my friend not to bring their partner to dinner?
Four of us have been close friends for years. We’re a mixed group of men and women, and these days we don’t get to meet very often.
A couple of weeks ago, we finally found a Saturday when all four of us were free and planned dinner together. The idea was just to catch up like we used to.
A few hours before dinner, one friend texted the group:
“My partner is with me, so they’ll come along tonight. Hope that’s okay.”
I like their partner. We’ve met plenty of times and there’s never been a problem.
But I felt a little annoyed because nobody had actually been asked. It felt more like we were being told they were coming.
I replied, “Would you mind if we kept it just the four of us tonight? We hardly ever get to catch up anymore.”
My friend replied, “Seriously? They’re already with me. What am I supposed to say now?”
One friend privately told me they agreed with me. The other said I was making an issue out of nothing and that one extra person wouldn’t change the evening.
My friend eventually came alone, but things were noticeably awkward.
Later they told me, “You made my partner feel unwanted. We’ve been together for years and everyone knows them.”
I said, “I have nothing against your partner. I just think if four people make plans, you should ask before inviting a fifth person.”
They replied that in a long-term relationship, sometimes you should expect someone's partner to be included in casual social plans.
That’s where we disagree.
A: I wasn’t wrong. Being someone's long-term partner doesn’t mean you're automatically invited to every friend gathering.
B: I made it unnecessarily awkward. If everyone already knows and likes the partner, one extra person shouldn’t matter.
Who do you agree with?