I’m a special education teacher, and I work with students with significant support needs, many of whom are autistic and communicate in a variety of ways, including through AAC.
I just got into an argument with someone about vaccines supposedly causing autism, and the conversation bothered me more than I expected it to.
I want to preface this by saying I’m not someone who immediately dismisses a claim simply because it goes against what I’ve previously learned. I’m an educator. Being a good educator means constantly learning, reading research, questioning what you know, and being willing to change your understanding when credible evidence supports it.
But the vaccine/autism conversation really bothers me because autism is so often talked about as if it’s this horrible outcome that happened to someone and that we need to find somebody or something to blame for it.
The argument I was having eventually turned to the Hannah Poling case and mitochondrial disorders. And I think there’s an enormous difference between discussing whether a physiological stressor could contribute to regression or encephalopathy in a child with a rare underlying mitochondrial disorder and taking that case and saying, “See? Vaccines cause autism.”
Those are not the same claim.
I spend my days with students on the spectrum. Some have very significant communication, behavioral, sensory, and adaptive needs. I’m not going to romanticize disability and pretend that there aren’t very real challenges for these kids and their families. There absolutely are.
But I also don’t look at my students and think, What happened to you? Who caused this?
I think: How can I understand you better? How can I help you communicate? How can I make your environment more accessible? How can I teach you skills that give you more independence and autonomy?
Maybe that’s why this subject gets under my skin so much. I’m completely open to research about autism—its genetics, neurobiology, environmental influences, everything. That’s how science works. But there’s a difference between being open to evidence and starting with the conclusion that vaccines caused autism and then trying to make every piece of evidence fit that conclusion.
I’d genuinely be interested in hearing how individuals on the spectrum themselves feel when they see these conversations, especially the constant focus on trying to figure out what or who “caused” them.