r/greatsword 10d ago

Affinity focus or attack focus?

Im CB main but im trying to master GS as well. Just to try something new. which techinically is better focus if u have 4x attack and 1 sharp before i pull the trigger on making it a gogma weapon. Also which build and weapon skills matches certain focus. Thanks!

3 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

2

u/frmchimp 10d ago

They actually have very similar effective raw. Affinity is better for landing consistent crits (duh), and attack focus crits less frequently but has higher peaks. I’d suggest checking out the GS document in r/MonsterHunterMeta

2

u/AstalosBoltz914 10d ago

If you’re going for meta, Affinity. It’s more consistent with crits and helps with managing things way more since the negative crit from attack focus really fucks with set ups unless you got a hyper specific one on hand

For affinity focus set ups I’ve noticed WAY more higher numbers on my TCS compared to my old attack focus set ups which were near identical.

Now granted, my current affinity gs has 25% affinity with the modifiers and what not without any set bonus skills but honestly, it’s super good over all to have! And you don’t gotta max out as much with the set up! Like I can run max might 2 since it gets me up to 80+% affinity without taking into account wex! (I got wex 3 on my set so that should be near 100% with everything going right)

My full set is

Gogma Dragon gs (Affinity focus with 3 attack, 1 affinity, 1 sharpness modifier) (set bonus stuff are Soul of the dark knight + lord soul) (TOOK FOREVER TO GET THE SKILL BONUS!)

The armor is

At Ark helm

AT Nu chest

Bale Gloves

Dosha B coil

Gogma A leggings

This gives access to lords soul, Bale 2 piece, and Dosha 2 piece for HUGE raw boosts as well as over all GS goodness!

I’m currently aiming for a tali with attack boost 3 with either Agitator 1, Burst 1, or Flayer 1 to max out my set since the one TINY issue is I’m missing 1 lvl of agitator for that little extra affinity but mostly the boost to the attack when a monster is mad. If I can get that- OOOO I’ll be set! (This set ‘could’ in theory work with attack focus, HOWEVER! You’ll be under clocking affinity and you’ll need to give up either Flayer or burst deco if you want max might at full to get full Affinity I feel which to me, isn’t too good)

1

u/crabsage89 10d ago

That set is badass! I’ve heard some arguments about maxing agitator over wex, I’d like to hear your opinion on that!

2

u/AstalosBoltz914 10d ago

Wex with the set up I’ve got isn’t at all a requirement due to the affinity you get from everything else. Wex just acts as a support to get the affinity to guaranteed 100% on a hit via a weak point or wound. Agitator does that job slightly better with extra since it gives a solid attack buff on top of the affinity boost. If you choose to run this set, all you’ll need is AT Ark helm giving you 3 Wex and that’s it

1

u/crabsage89 10d ago

Gotchya! Yeah gunna give this set a go, trying to roll SotD/LS on an affinity focus dragon GS for a while now lol

2

u/AstalosBoltz914 10d ago

It took me many days to get just that on my dragon GS. Been trying to get it on my Fire GS in turn but it’s been a PAIN

1

u/crabsage89 9d ago

The grind is real! Happy hunting brother, and thank you for the recommendations!

1

u/imhim_imthatguy 3d ago

Can I see what skills you have? Like your deco setup

1

u/AstalosBoltz914 3d ago

I’m not home as of the moment but once I am I will share a screenshot

1

u/Healthy_Complaint384 10d ago

Easiest to build and all rounder affinity focus, max unga bunga attack focus. IMO affinity if you are looking to craft only 1 weapon.

there is not an ultimate meta set for GS, the only "consensus" is to get a bale/lord souls in your gogma weapon and use any other set you like or matchup dependent.

most seen set should be: Ark y, udra y, bale, dosha, gogma a

but i personally love this one: bale, ark y, bale, bale , ark y.
a lot of regen and 0 elemental alignments

1

u/AstalosBoltz914 10d ago

That utility build you suggested sounds funky, I may have to take a look at that one lol

1

u/Healthy_Complaint384 10d ago

it is, just remember to put blackest knight in the radial menu for insta use, you can swap the talisman for an attack instead

1

u/zirc123 10d ago

So basically 4x attack 1 sharp then affinity focus is the way to go? Then bale/lordsoul?

1

u/Healthy_Complaint384 10d ago

yeah,this is the easiest to build around IMO

1

u/zirc123 10d ago

If u go attack focus, it wont crit as much?

1

u/Healthy_Complaint384 10d ago

you can, but your build gonna need latent power as a main source of affinity, nothing wrong in that but it has time restrictions to use it, you can use corrupt mantle to proc it at the start of the fight, this is the way to play around this skill

1

u/zirc123 10d ago

I see. I kinda wanna farm At arkveld. So im building towards raw with highest damage possible. But im clueless lol

1

u/Healthy_Complaint384 10d ago

thats the best aproach to this fight, you can go for the dahaad build or the gore build for this fight, but i find using 2 ark y pieces helps a lot for the chip damage, im not at home atm, i'll share some builds to you later.

1

u/zirc123 10d ago

Wait i thought gore build isnt much effective when using GS. Isnt bale/lordsoul always the prio?

1

u/Healthy_Complaint384 10d ago

yes it is, but in this particular fight you can ditch bale if your main dmg gonna be offsets

1

u/zirc123 10d ago

So if i wanna farm At arkveld, which weapon skill should aim for? Gore/lord soul? Or bale/lord is still better?

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Acceptable-Arm-4579 10d ago

Affinity is way more versatile you can make up for the missing raw with agi and burst

1

u/Acceptable-Arm-4579 10d ago

And it attack boost charms

1

u/zamaike 9d ago

All attack always. Pair it with weakness exploit5, resentment5, offensive block3, attack 5, shield3/iron wall1, flayer5, partbreaker3. Want to have a special effect on it maybe. Like bale gs, shatter, zoh shia, or laz gs even

Your attacks will crit for 1k sometimes on weakpoints. Wound damage sometimes can hit 2k

-1

u/DarkmoonGrumpy 10d ago edited 10d ago

Attack, usually.

Affinity is fairly easy to max with armour skills but not with 100% uptime, so its more a preference thing. I prefer more Raw.

For the actual rolls, Sharpness and 4x Attack is the way.

1

u/zirc123 10d ago

Which weapon skills do i aim for? Also if u can recommend me a build. Trying to farm At Arkveld

1

u/DarkmoonGrumpy 10d ago

Focus and Crit Boost are the main two weapon skills; then I personally like to take a Guard Up/Guard gem for comfort.

For the meta builds, check out the pinned thread on r/MonsterHunterMeta. It'll have a breakdown of meta sets per Title Update so you get a feel for progression.

Do note, the meta sets are nearly always 100% damage focused, I'd sub out some skills for preference if you're unsure on your ability to not get hit.

1

u/AstalosBoltz914 10d ago

Actually with affinity focus you can have space to be able to slip on things like Flayer and burst allowing for even better raw in some cases then most attack focus builds without sacrificing all that much. In fact for my set I gave up a max might since I’m overlocking on affinity if I had it (that and I didn’t have the technical space for a third lvl anyway) so I used my spare 3 slot for Flayer and my dps racked up higher then my old attack focus builds I had.

1

u/Acceptable-Arm-4579 10d ago edited 10d ago

Please post your average dps my guy. There’s a huge difference between having affinity skills vs having high affinity up time. You can make up the missing “30”raw with agi 5 and burst 1 by going affinity on your weapon!