The problem:
When Reddit's spam filter flags an account, users can get vague messages such as "pattern of spamming identical posts" or "suspected involvement in scams". The problem is that they don't know exactly what caused the flag.
This creates a few problems:
- Users can't learn from their mistake if they don't know what was flagged.
- Genuine users who are asking questions in several relevant subs, with no links or promotions, can't tell what caused the issue. Was it how often they posted, using the same wording, posting in too many subs, or something else?
- Appeals become harder because users don't know what they need to explain or clarify.
My idea:
When an account is flagged for spam, Reddit could show users some basic information about what triggered the flag, such as:
- Which posts or comments triggered it
- What the system detected, for example, "same text posted in 5+ subs within 24 hours"
- Whether the issue was related to the number of posts, the number of subs, or repeated wording
- A simple explanation of what type of behaviour is likely to be treated as spam
Reddit wouldn't need to reveal exactly how the spam filter works. Even a basic explanation would make things much clearer.
Why I think this would help:
- Genuine users would know what they need to change.
- People could avoid making the same mistake again.
- Appeals would be more useful because users would know what they need to explain.
- It would reduce confusion when someone's activity didn't feel like spam to them.
- It could also help separate genuine mistakes from actual spam campaigns.
Example from my situation:
My 2nd account was flagged for "spamming identical posts" after I posted similar troubleshooting questions about a software tool in several relevant subs. I didn't realise that posting the same question in 4–5 relevant subs, even without links or promotions, could trigger the spam system.
If Reddit had shown me exactly what caused the flag, I could have changed how I posted or given a more useful explanation in my appeal.