r/tylertx • u/No_Maybe_IDontKnow • 7h ago
Discussion The Bitcoin Data Center That Tyler Said No To Is Back. There's A Vote THIS Wednesday. Here's What You Need To Know.
Hey Tyler,
A couple months ago, the Planning and Zoning Commission voted 5-2 to deny a special use permit for a 12-megawatt Bitcoin mining data center at 1101-1105 West Erwin Street (downtown). Twenty-six residents spoke against it. Five spoke in favor. It felt like the community was heard.
But Barrio Resources LLC filed an appeal. And this Wednesday, September 3rd, the Zoning Board of Adjustment votes on whether they have jurisdiction to hear it. If they say yes, September 10th is when they decide the actual appeal.
I spent the weekend going through the appeal documents, the acoustic report, and a lot of research. Here are the three things I think everyone should know:
- The Noise Report Is Measuring The Wrong Thing
The developer hired Hoover and Keith to do an acoustic study. It says noise at the nearest home would be about 35 decibels, well under the city's 63 dBA limit. Sounds great, right?
The problem is that dBA (A-weighted decibels) was literally designed to filter out low-frequency sound. The real threat from data centers running thousands of cooling fans 24/7 is infrasound, which is sound below 20 Hz. You don't hear it. You feel it. Chest pressure, ear pressure, vibrations that go through walls.
Researcher Benn Jordan documented this extensively. He calls these facilities "acoustic weapons" because the infrasound from industrial cooling fans travels for miles and penetrates structures. His research is on YouTube if you want to see the data yourself: search "Benn Jordan Datacenters Acoustic Weapons."
In Granbury, TX (about 3 hours from here), a Marathon Digital Bitcoin facility caused 40+ residents to report permanent hearing loss, vertigo, and chronic sleep issues. The facility was acquitted of noise violations because their dBA numbers were technically legal. The sound the test measures was fine. The sound it doesn't measure was destroying people's quality of life. Earthjustice has now filed a lawsuit on behalf of the residents.
The question we should be asking: does the acoustic report include unweighted measurements of frequencies below 20 Hz? From what I can tell, it doesn't appear to.
- 12 Megawatts Is The Power Of 3,000 Homes
According to ERCOT, 1 megawatt powers about 200-250 Texas homes during peak demand. So 12 MW equals the electricity of 2,400 to 3,000 homes. For a facility with 3 to 10 employees.
These facilities also participate in demand response programs where they get paid to shut down when the grid is stressed. In August 2023, Riot Platforms received $31.7 million in curtailment credits. They made more money shutting off than mining Bitcoin. Who pays for those credits? Ratepayers.
A Wood Mackenzie study found crypto mining adds about $1.8 billion per year to Texas electric bills, roughly $69 per household annually.
We already know what happens when storms hit East Texas. Adding 3,000 homes worth of constant load to the Oncor grid doesn't make things better for the people already here.
- What Does Tyler Actually Get?
2,400 to 3,000 homes worth of electricity. 3 to (maybe) 10 jobs. A noise profile the city doesn't have the right tools to measure. And a business model that gets paid to stop operating when we need the grid most.
I'm not telling anyone what to think. But I am asking: what does Tyler get in return?
What You Can Do
- September 3: ZBA jurisdiction vote
- September 10: Potential merits hearing (if jurisdiction is affirmed)
- Share this post
- Contact City Council: https://www.cityoftyler.org/City-Government/Mayor-and-Council/Contact-City-Council
- Attend the meetings if your schedule allows
I put together a video and a full blog post with every source and document linked at techeasetyler.com. If you want the deep dive, it's all there.
We have 3 days to make sure the community is informed before decisions are made. Please share this with anyone in Tyler who should see it.