I was looking through what I've already read and I've realised that I've already done all of the big names. There's maybe a few left that I haven't done, but we're talking single digits at this point.
I'm about 2/3 of the way through Baldr Sky now and while I'm loving it so far, I'm getting this sensation that once I reach the end, that'll be one more VN off the list (on a list that is already getting quite short).
I don't really want to read 7 out of 10 slop for the remainder of my time in this genre and I'll be honest, I don't really have the time to learn Japanese nor the inclination so really I can only read fan-patched or officially translated novels anyway.
This is less a "what should I read next" and more a bittersweet reflection that I don't think I will find anything that makes me feel the same way that Fata Morgana, Steins; Gate, Clannad, Umineko, Subahibi etc etc etc made me feel.